Bake log: what you baked, what changed and what to try next
One row per bake: the oven setting and offset, the time, how you checked doneness, the result, the cause you suspect and the one change for next time. A second sheet records a yeast loaf stage by stage.
Essential on a first pass: the bakes sheet. It is the sheet One change at a time depends on: each failure, the cause you suspect and the one thing you will change. The bread sheet is optional until you bake a yeast loaf; then it records the temperatures and times that make the next loaf repeatable.
Bakes
One row per bake worth learning from. Write what you observed in the result column and your best guess at a cause separately, so the next bake can test it. Change one thing at a time.
Bread sheet
One row per yeast loaf. Temperatures in your units. Rise times are start and end clock times, so the sheet records what the dough did rather than what the recipe said.
How to use these sheets
- One row per bake. A bake that went well is worth a row too: it is the baseline the next change is measured against.
- Keep what you saw apart from why. "Gummy band in the center" is an observation; "oven too hot" is a suspicion to test. The symptoms page lists causes to check, in the order The order of checks gives.
- Change one thing. If two things change between bakes, the log cannot say which one mattered.
- Bread by the clock and the thermometer. Write the clock time the rise started and ended, not the recipe's estimate; the dough sets the time. The dough temperature calculator gives the water temperature.
Two fictional bakers. Dana Reyes's banana bread had a dark crust and a gummy band in the center; her toothpick came out clean because she tested near the edge. Known: her oven runs 20 °F hot by her oven check. Suspected: the outside set before the center baked. Her next change is one change: set the dial 20 degrees lower and test the center. Marcus Bell's sandwich loaf, in a 64 °F winter kitchen, used 78 °F water by the dough temperature formula and came out at 77 °F; it rose well and tore along one side, which points his next loaf at shaping and scoring rather than at the dough.
The log records what you saw and what you suspect. It cannot prove a cause from one bake; a cause is settled when changing it changes the result. The published tables list causes to check, not a diagnosis of your bake.