Baking problems by symptom: causes to check, with sources
Reference

Baking problems by symptom: causes to check, with sources

One row per symptom and bake: the causes three extension judging tables and two practitioners name, with the source on each, and the chapter that explains it. Filter by bake.

Each row is one symptom in one kind of bake, with the causes each publisher names. Three extension tables carry most rows: Nebraska Extension's 4-H Foods Judging Guide (revised through 2018), Utah State University Extension's Fair Judges' Manual (2015) and Utah State's older bread bulletin, Enjoy Yeast Breads Both Plain and Fancy (FN 283), written for Utah's altitude between 1976 and 2000 and used here for its fault descriptions only. Two practitioners add rows: Red Star Yeast's Tips & Troubleshooting Guide, and King Arthur Baking's How to keep cheesecake from cracking, Why are my cookies spreading?, How to tell when pumpkin pie is done and Sourdough starter troubleshooting. The last column links the chapter that explains the cause.

How to use this table

A symptom usually has more than one possible cause, and the tables list several for each. Work through them in the same order every time:

  1. Check the oven first. Oven temperature appears in rows for every kind of bake below. If you have not checked your oven against a thermometer recently, do that before changing the recipe; When a bake goes wrong explains why.
  2. Then measuring. Flour measured by cup can vary by a third (King Arthur Baking's How to measure flour gives about 120 g spooned and up to 160 g packed for one cup of all-purpose), and "too much flour" appears in many rows. See Measuring.
  3. Then ingredient temperature and freshness. Warm butter, cold eggs, old baking powder and water that was too hot for the yeast all show up below.
  4. Then mixing. Overmixing and undermixing cause opposite faults; the row says which.
  5. Change one thing, and write it down. Bake again with a single change and record it in the bake log. Changing two things at once leaves you not knowing which one worked. See When a bake goes wrong. Test it

Where two tables name opposite causes for the same symptom, both stay in the row. The clearest case is dense bread: Red Star blames an oven that is too hot, because the crust sets before the loaf finishes rising, while Nebraska and Utah blame an oven that is too cool. Both happen. Your oven check settles which one is yours. Above 3,000 ft, altitude can cause falls, spread and overflow that no row here describes; see baking at altitude and the altitude page.

Two words the tables use: too light is Utah State's term for dough or batter that has risen too far, past its peak (overproofed); molding is shaping the loaf.

Cookies and bars

SymptomCauses to check, by sourceSourceExplained in
Spread too much, flatNebraska: dough too warm; sheets not cooled between batches; wrong oven temperature; liquid or flour mismeasured; melted, whipped or oil fat; flat cookies from expired baking powder. Utah: dough too warm; dropped onto a hot sheet; wrong oven temperature; too much fat, sugar, leavening or liquid. King Arthur: too much liquid or sugar; eggs larger than the recipe means (a large egg is about 50 g); butter too warm; out-of-date powder or soda; an oven cooler than its "ready" signal.Nebraska Extension; Utah State Extension; King Arthur BakingCookies, muffins and biscuits
Run together on the sheetNebraska: dough spaced too closely.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Too darkNebraska: baked too long or too hot; a dark nonstick or glass pan without lowering the oven 25 °F (about 14 °C).Nebraska ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Pale top, burned bottomNebraska: rack not in the middle; a bar pan too deep (fill no more than two-thirds).Nebraska ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Shiny or stickyNebraska: too much sugar; underbaked.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
ToughNebraska: too much flour; overhandled. Utah: too much re-rolling; excess flour.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionFlour and gluten
HardNebraska: oven too hot or baked too long; flour too high in protein.Nebraska ExtensionFlour and gluten
Bitter or soapyNebraska: too much leavening.Nebraska ExtensionLeaveners
Bar cookies crumbleUtah: cut while warm.Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits

Muffins, quick breads and coffee cake

SymptomCauses to check, by sourceSourceExplained in
Muffins: knobs, peaks or cracks on topNebraska: too much stirring; stiff mixture; uneven oven heat. Utah: uneven heat; too little leavening; overmixed; too much flour or egg; oven too hot; pan too high.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Muffins: tunnelsNebraska: over-stirring; too much liquid; inaccurate measuring; too little fat or sugar. Utah: overmixed; too much flour. Both agree on overmixing; they differ on the ingredient causes.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Muffins: shiny or waxy surfaceNebraska: overmixed. Utah: egg and milk not mixed in well.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Muffins: crumbly and denseNebraska: under-stirring.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Quick bread loaf: crack down the centerNebraska: normal, not a fault; a large mass of batter heats slowly. To avoid it: bake right after mixing at 350 °F (177 °C); or preheat to 375 to 400 °F (191 to 204 °C) and let the covered batter stand 20 to 30 minutes; or tent with foil until it rises and browns.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Quick bread loaf: peakedNebraska: batter too stiff; overmixed; pan too small.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Quick bread loaf: cracked (other than the center crack)Nebraska: oven too hot.Nebraska ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Quick bread or coffee cake: fallen or dipped centerNebraska: oven not hot enough; underbaked. Utah (coffee cake): underbaked; liquid mismeasured; pan too small; tested too soon; jarred.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Quick bread or coffee cake: tunnels and holesNebraska: overmixed. Utah (coffee cake): oven too hot; dark or glass pans without lowering the heat; extreme overbeating.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Coffee cake: humped or peakedUtah: oven too hot; pan too small; glass, dark or enameled pan without lowering the heat; overbeating.Utah State ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Coffee cake: fruit sinksUtah: uneven layering; fruit not drained; oven too low.Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Quick bread: soggyNebraska: wrapped before cool; underbaked; too much fruit.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Banana bread: paleNebraska: bananas not ripe enough.Nebraska ExtensionFat, sugar, eggs and liquid

None of the three extension tables has a row for biscuits or scones. For a tough biscuit, the pastry rows under pies name the same causes: overhandling and too much water. The biscuit method is in Cookies, muffins and biscuits.

Cakes and cheesecake

SymptomCauses to check, by sourceSourceExplained in
Butter cake: falls or sinks in the middleNebraska: too much shortening, sugar or baking powder; peeking; oven too low; too much batter; underbaked; moved while baking. Utah: too much shortening, baking powder or soda; underbaked; door opened or cake moved too soon.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCakes and frosting; When a bake goes wrong
Butter cake: peaked, humped or cracked on topNebraska: humps or cracks from an oven too hot at first, a pan too high, too much flour; a peak from batter too stiff, too much flour, oven too hot at the start. Utah: oven too hot; too much flour; not enough liquid; too much batter; pan too high; overmixing.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Butter cake: cracked crustNebraska: oven too hot at the start; batter too stiff; pan too narrow or deep. Utah: too much sugar. The two tables name different causes.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCakes and frosting
Higher on one sideNebraska: uneven oven heat; rack not level; batter spread unevenly; air pockets not cut out.Nebraska ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Runs over the panNebraska: too much batter; oven not hot enough; too much leavening.Nebraska ExtensionCakes and frosting
Sticks to the panNebraska: overmixing; left in the pan too long; pan not greased enough.Nebraska ExtensionCakes and frosting
Dry or crumblyNebraska: overbaked; undermixed; too much leavening or flour; oven too hot; egg whites overbeaten; cocoa used in place of chocolate without adding fat.Nebraska ExtensionCakes and frosting
Soggy layer at the bottomNebraska: shortening too soft; undermixed; underbaked; too much liquid (fruit, pumpkin, applesauce); damp flour; wrapped before cool. Utah: undermixing; shortening too soft; too little leavening; too much liquid; damp flour; oven bottom not hot enough.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionFat, sugar, eggs and liquid
Soggy crustUtah: cake steamed in the pan while cooling.Utah State ExtensionCakes and frosting
Heavy, compactNebraska: overbeating or undercreaming; wrong oven temperature; pan too small; not enough leavening.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Coarse grainNebraska: insufficient creaming; bread flour; too much liquid, sugar or shortening; oven too slow; oil in place of shortening. Utah: too much leavening; insufficient creaming; liquid shortening; bread flour; oven too slow.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
TunnelsNebraska: too many eggs or too little sugar; poorly mixed; butter overbeaten; air pockets not cut out.Nebraska ExtensionCookies, muffins and biscuits
Foam cake (angel food, sponge, chiffon): fallenUtah: wrong oven temperature; underbaked; too much sugar; pan sides greased; poor mixing; pan not inverted to cool.Utah State ExtensionCakes and frosting
Foam cake: poor volumeUtah: whites under- or over-beaten; overfolding; pan not inverted.Utah State ExtensionLeaveners
Foam cake: toughUtah: underbeaten whites; overfolding; all-purpose flour.Utah State ExtensionFlour and gluten
Foam cake: compact or coarse grainUtah: compact from overfolding or underbeaten whites; coarse from underfolding or too much sugar.Utah State ExtensionLeaveners
Cheesecake: crackedKing Arthur: overbaking is the chief cause. In its side-by-side trial, a water bath worked best (9.5 of 10), soaked cake strips next (7), a steam pan on a lower rack barely helped (5.5), and a plain bake scored 5. Recipes of only cream cheese, eggs and sugar crack more readily than those with sour cream or cream; thinner cakes are easier to keep from overbaking. Done: edge firm, center just set.King Arthur BakingCakes and frosting

Pies and pastry

SymptomCauses to check, by sourceSourceExplained in
Crust shrinksNebraska: handled too much; stretched into the pan; stored too long in the refrigerator; not pricked enough; a nonstick pan with the sides not secured. Utah: stretched into the pan.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry; blind baking
Large blistersUtah: not pricked enough.Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry
Tough crustNebraska: dough too warm when rolled; too much water; overmixed; overhandled; too much flour for rolling; not enough fat. Utah: overhandling; too much water; not enough shortening.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry
Crumbly crust that falls apartNebraska: fat cut in poorly; not enough water; too much fat; self-rising flour. Utah: too much shortening; not cut in enough; not enough liquid; rolled too thin.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry
Dry, mealy crustUtah: shortening cut in too finely; not enough liquid.Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry
Soggy bottom crustNebraska: undermixed; a shiny pie pan; pie baked on a cookie sheet.Nebraska ExtensionPie and pastry
Fruit filling spills overNebraska: oven too low; too little thickening or fruit; too much sugar; top crust not sealed. Utah: upper crust not sealed; too little thickener; top crust stretched; too much sugar.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry
Filling gummy, or a layer of thickeningNebraska: too much thickening; underbaked. Utah: too much thickener.Nebraska Extension; Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry
Filling too thinUtah: too little thickener; too much sugar.Utah State ExtensionPie and pastry
Raw, starchy taste in the fillingNebraska: thickener undercooked.Nebraska ExtensionPie and pastry
Pumpkin or custard pie: cracked, grainy, little jiggleKing Arthur: overbaked. Above 175 °F (79 °C) at the center risks dry edges and cracks; pull it with about a 4 in. jiggly center on a 9 in. pie and start checking 10 minutes before the recipe's time. A pie liquid across the whole surface is underbaked.King Arthur BakingPie and pastry
Laminated dough: butter breaks through, or oozesNebraska: breaks through when the butter is too cold and the dough too soft; oozes when butter or dough is too warm. Condition the butter to 57 to 60 °F (14 to 16 °C).Nebraska ExtensionPie and pastry
Laminated dough: bread-like, not flakyNebraska: room too hot; oven too cool; overproofed.Nebraska ExtensionPie and pastry

Yeast bread and sourdough

SymptomCauses to check, by sourceSourceExplained in
Did not rise, or rose slowlyRed Star: too little or expired yeast; liquid too hot; liquid or other ingredients too cold; too much salt (keep yeast and salt apart); too much or too little sugar; rising place too cool or too hot.Red Star YeastTemperature in baking; Yeast bread
Loaf too smallNebraska: liquid too cool; too much salt; dough too stiff; not enough yeast; rise too short; oven too hot.Nebraska ExtensionYeast bread
Heavy, dense or coarse grainNebraska: poor or killed yeast; poorly mixed; low-grade or too little flour; dough too stiff; not risen enough; too much low-gluten flour; salt left out; rise too long; under-kneaded; oven too cool. Utah: coarse from dough not stiff enough, too long a rise, dough chilled while rising, oven too cool. Red Star: coarse and crumbly from too long a rise, too much flour, oven too low, under-kneading. Utah FN 283: coarse from too little kneading, too short a fermentation, or dough too light.Nebraska Extension; Utah State Extension; Red Star YeastYeast bread; rising
Dense and gummyRed Star: oven too hot, so the crust sets before the loaf reaches full volume; taken out too soon. Nebraska and Utah name the opposite, an oven too cool, for heavy bread; check your oven to see which applies.Red Star YeastYeast bread; cooling
Solid and compact, or compact at the bottomRed Star: rise too short; flour too weak. Utah: compact bottom from an oven too low. Utah FN 283: compact bottom from pans rising on a cold surface or a cool oven bottom.Red Star Yeast; Utah State ExtensionYeast bread
Rose, then collapsed in the ovenRed Star: flour too weak (use bread flour, or add 1 tsp vital wheat gluten per cup of all-purpose); overproofed; oven too low. Nebraska: overproofing weakened the gluten.Red Star Yeast; Nebraska ExtensionYeast bread
Large holes, or a hole under the top crustRed Star: poorly shaped (press out the air when shaping); rise too long. Utah: poor molding; over-raised. Utah FN 283 ("shell top"): a gas bubble left at shaping; a dried surface; dough too light.Red Star Yeast; Utah State ExtensionYeast bread
Pale crustNebraska: oven too slow; too much salt; too little sugar; dough dried while rising; rise too short; underbaked.Nebraska ExtensionYeast bread
Sides not brownNebraska: shiny pans; pans crowded in the oven.Nebraska ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Crust too thickRed Star: oven too low; too much flour; dough dried while rising. Utah FN 283: dough too light or under-kneaded.Red Star Yeast; Utah State ExtensionYeast bread
Soggy crustRed Star: not cooled properly; take the loaf out of the pan at once and cool it on a rack (rich Bundt coffee cakes: 10 minutes in the pan first).Red Star YeastYeast bread
Too large, poorly shaped, or spilling over the panRed Star: rise too long; too much yeast; oven too low. Utah FN 283 ("overhang"): dough too light; oven not hot enough.Red Star Yeast; Utah State ExtensionYeast bread
Crack along one sideUtah FN 283 ("shell crack"): uneven oven heat or crowded pans; the crack forms on the coolest side.Utah State ExtensionThe oven and the pan
Deep cracksUtah FN 283: dough too stiff or under-kneaded.Utah State ExtensionYeast bread
Streaks in the crumbUtah: flour added at molding; dough dried on top; surface over-greased. Utah FN 283: flour added at molding or fat on the hands.Utah State ExtensionYeast bread
CrumblyUtah FN 283: too much flour; dough too light.Utah State ExtensionYeast bread
Dough too stickyRed Star: not enough flour (the amount a dough takes can vary by up to 1/2 cup); old or low-gluten flour; over-kneaded (soft, sticky and no longer stretches).Red Star YeastYeast bread
Sour taste in a yeast (not sourdough) loafNebraska: not enough salt; rise too long.Nebraska ExtensionYeast bread
Starter: liquid on topKing Arthur: the liquid ("hooch") is alcohol from fermentation and means the starter is hungry; gray, brown or black hooch does not by itself mean it has spoiled. Feed it.King Arthur BakingYeast bread; When a bake goes wrong
Starter: slow, or not doublingKing Arthur: a new starter takes 6 to 10 days to mature; keep it at about 70 °F (21 °C); heat kills it (yeast dies at 140 °F, 60 °C); severe neglect kills it. A missed feeding or a few days in the freezer does not.King Arthur BakingYeast bread
Starter: fuzzy mold, or a pink or orange tint or streakKing Arthur: discard it and start over.King Arthur BakingWhen a bake goes wrong
Caution

A starter with mold or a pink or orange tint goes in the trash, not back into a feeding schedule. That is King Arthur Baking's advice; we found no extension service or agency page on spoiled starters, so we do not go further than it does.

Limits

These are causes to check, not a diagnosis. The tables were written for fair judging and for one maker's products, and they list what commonly goes wrong, not everything that can. If the oven itself will not hold its setting after you have checked it, that is a question for the oven's maker and its owner's manual, not a recipe change. This page does not say whether a failed bake is safe to eat; for anything with eggs, cream or cheese that sat out, the two-hour rule on the storage page applies.