Baking soda vs baking powder, yeast, steam and air: how each leavener works
Baking soda and baking powder told apart by what they need, soda matched to the acid in the recipe, freshness tested, active dry yeast converted to instant, and air and steam recognized as leaveners too.
- Start here: the essentials
- What a leavener does
- Baking soda, and the acid it needs
- Baking powder
- Is it still fresh
- Swapping one leavener for another
- Yeast: the types and converting between them
- Steam and air
- Leaveners at high elevation
- See it: a birthday cake at 5,280 feet
- Practice: test the cupboard
- Your kitchen
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
For a first pass, make sure what is in the cupboard still works, and know which leavener your recipe relies on. Old leavener and a misread teaspoon are two of the easiest failures to prevent.
- Check the dates on the baking powder, baking soda and yeast, and test any that are old or opened long ago. Each test takes a few minutes (is it still fresh).
- Read which leavener your recipe uses and whether it has an acid. Soda needs one in the recipe; powder carries its own (baking soda).
- Measure leaveners with a leveled measuring spoon, or by weight on a scale that reads small amounts. A heaped quarter teaspoon is a different recipe (what a leavener does).
- Write each test result and the date on the ingredient check. It is in your kitchen sheet.
Minimum time: 15 minutes for the three tests. Done when: each leavener in the cupboard has a dated freshness result on the ingredient check.
What a leavener does Understand
A leavener is anything that puts gas into a batter or dough so it rises. The gas comes from three places: a chemical reaction (baking soda and baking powder make carbon dioxide), a living thing (yeast makes carbon dioxide as it feeds), or physical work and heat (air beaten in, and water turned to steam). Physical principle
Making the gas is half the job. The batter has to hold it, in a network of gluten, set egg or starch, until the oven sets the structure around the bubbles. Heat helps twice: gas expands as it warms, and water turns to steam. That is why a cake rises in the oven and not on the counter, and why a cake that sets too slowly, or a batter too weak to hold the gas, can rise and then fall. Flour and gluten covers the network.
| Leavener | Where the gas comes from | What it needs | Typical bakes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baking soda | Carbon dioxide from soda meeting an acid | An acid in the recipe, and moisture | Buttermilk biscuits, chocolate cakes made with natural cocoa, many cookies and quick breads |
| Baking powder | Carbon dioxide from soda and the acids mixed with it | Moisture, and for most powders heat | Cakes, muffins, biscuits, pancakes |
| Yeast | Carbon dioxide from yeast feeding on sugars | Warmth, water, food and time | Bread, rolls, enriched doughs |
| Air | Bubbles beaten into fat or eggs | Beating, and a structure that sets around them | Butter cakes (creaming), angel food and sponge cakes (whipped eggs) |
| Steam | Water in the dough turning to steam in the oven | A hot oven and water held in layers or a batter | Pie crust and laminated pastry layers; it adds lift to most bakes |
Most recipes use more than one. A butter cake gets air from creaming, carbon dioxide from powder, and steam from its liquid. A loaf of bread gets most of its rise from yeast and a last push in the oven.
Measuring small amounts
Leaveners go into a recipe by the quarter teaspoon, so a small error is a large share. Arm & Hammer says baking soda is about three to four times as strong as baking powder (Arm & Hammer, Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder), so an extra pinch of soda counts for more than an extra pinch of powder. Product-specific
Our default is a measuring spoon, filled and leveled with a straight edge. By weight, King Arthur Baking gives 4 g for a teaspoon of baking powder and 3 g for half a teaspoon of soda (King Arthur Baking, Ingredient Weight Chart). A quarter teaspoon of soda is then under 2 g. A kitchen scale that reads in 1 g steps cannot tell 1 g from 2 g with much confidence, so for amounts under a teaspoon we use the spoon unless the scale reads to a tenth of a gram. That is our convention; no source we found gives an accuracy figure for household scales. Convention Measuring covers scales.
Two publishers' leavener weights
| Leavener | King Arthur Baking | USDA FoodData Central |
|---|---|---|
| Baking powder, 1 tsp | 4 g | 4.6 g |
| Baking soda, 1 tsp | 6 g (given as 3 g per 1/2 tsp) | 4.6 g |
| Instant yeast, 2 1/4 tsp | 7 g | No figure |
Sources: King Arthur Baking, Ingredient Weight Chart; USDA FoodData Central SR Legacy (2018) portion weights. The soda figures differ by more than a gram per teaspoon, which is why we would not convert a recipe's soda to grams from a chart and weigh it on a 1 g scale.
Baking soda, and the acid it needs
Baking soda is sodium bicarbonate, a base. It releases carbon dioxide as soon as it meets moisture and an acid (Arm & Hammer). On its own, with no acid in the recipe, it gives little lift. So a recipe that uses soda is telling you it has an acid in it, and the soda is there to react with that acid. Physical principle
The acids in a recipe
Arm & Hammer lists the common ones: honey, buttermilk, molasses, chocolate, yogurt, sour cream, brown sugar and cocoa. Iowa State University Extension adds that brown sugar's molasses makes it slightly acidic, enough to react with soda (Iowa State AnswerLine, How the Cookie Crumbles). pH is the scale of acidity: 7 is neutral, lower is more acidic.
| Ingredient | Approximate pH | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Lemon juice | 2.0 to 2.6 | Clemson Extension |
| Vinegar | 2.0 to 3.4 (cider vinegar 3.1) | Clemson Extension |
| Honey | 3.9 | Clemson Extension |
| Molasses | 5.0 to 5.5 | Clemson Extension |
| Natural cocoa | 5 to 6 | Iowa State Extension |
| Dutch-process cocoa | About 7 (neutral) | Iowa State Extension |
| Flour | 6.0 to 6.3 | Clemson Extension |
| Buttermilk, yogurt, sour cream | Acidic; no pH in the tables we read | Arm & Hammer lists them as acids |
Sources: Clemson Extension, pH of Common Foods; Iowa State AnswerLine, Natural vs Dutch-process cocoa.
Cocoa decides the leavener
Cocoa is the case where the acid is easy to miss. Natural cocoa is acidic; Dutch-process (alkalized) cocoa is close to neutral. Iowa State says natural cocoa supplies the acid for baking soda, while recipes with Dutch-process cocoa generally use baking powder, and that "cocoa" in most US recipes means natural. Use the cocoa the recipe names. If a recipe leavens with soda alone and has no other acid, it needs natural cocoa (Iowa State). The swap between the two is in swapping.
How much soda
Here the sources give less than a baker would like. Arm & Hammer says recipes typically use 1/4 teaspoon of soda per cup of flour. That is a figure per cup of flour, not per cup of acid. Colorado State University Extension's substitution table pairs 1/4 teaspoon of soda with 1/2 cup of buttermilk, sour milk or yogurt to replace 1 teaspoon of baking powder (CSU Extension, Ingredient Substitutions). That is a substitution that works, not a measured amount of soda that 1/2 cup of buttermilk neutralizes. We found no maker or extension page that gives soda per cup of buttermilk or any other acid.
So we use the two figures for what they are: a check, not a formula. If your recipe's soda is far above 1/4 teaspoon per cup of flour, read it again for a typo, and look for the acid it is meant to meet. The soda check does that arithmetic. Convention
The soda figures here are a maker's and an extension service's rules of thumb, for a starting point. Arm & Hammer's 1/4 teaspoon per cup of flour describes typical recipes; CSU's buttermilk pairing is one row of a substitution table. Neither predicts how high your bake will rise, and neither tells you how much acid a given buttermilk, yogurt or cocoa carries. Your oven, your batter and a test bake settle that. Test it
Soda acts at once
Soda reacts as soon as it is wet and meets the acid, in one burst. Iowa State says a soda-leavened dough should be baked quickly. Our default for any soda batter: have the oven hot and the pan ready before the wet and dry ingredients meet. Convention
Too much soda
Leftover soda, with no acid left to react with, stays in the bake as a base. CSU's high elevation guide warns that too much leavener in a quick bread can leave a bitter or alkaline taste (CSU Extension, High Elevation Food Preparation Guide). The symptoms page lists it with the other causes of an off taste.
Baking powder
Baking powder is baking soda already mixed with one or more dry acids and a starch that keeps them apart until they get wet. Because it carries its own acid, it works in a recipe with no acid ingredient. Clabber Girl's label lists corn starch, sodium bicarbonate, sodium aluminum sulfate and monocalcium phosphate (Clabber Girl Baking Powder). Rumford's lists corn starch, sodium bicarbonate and monocalcium phosphate, with no aluminum compound (Rumford Baking Powder). Product-specific
Single and double acting
Single-acting powder reacts once, when it gets wet. Double-acting powder reacts twice: once when wet and again when heated (Arm & Hammer). Your tin says which it is. Product-specific
How much happens in each stage depends on the acids in the tin, and the makers' own figures differ. Clabber Girl says its powder reacts 30 percent in the mixing bowl and 70 percent in the oven. Rumford, made by the same company with a different acid, gives the reverse: about 70 percent in the bowl and 30 in the oven, so its batter should not wait long. Product-specific
Our default does not depend on the brand: mix, fill the pans, and bake. A powder that does most of its work in the bowl loses lift while batter waits, and one that does most in the oven still gives up some in the bowl. If a recipe asks you to rest a powder-leavened batter, as some pancake recipes do, follow it, and know that the tin you use changes how much rise survives the wait.
Recipes with both
Many recipes use soda and powder together: the soda to meet an acid ingredient, such as buttermilk or natural cocoa, and the powder for the rest of the lift. Leave both in. Cutting one because the other is there takes out a job the recipe needs. Convention
The acids inside a tin
Monocalcium phosphate is a fast acid that reacts in the bowl; sodium aluminum sulfate is a slow one that waits for heat. A powder with both is the classic double-acting pairing, which is how Clabber Girl gets its 30 and 70. Rumford relies on monocalcium phosphate alone, which is why most of its reaction happens in the bowl even though the tin says double-acting. Self-rising flour may use a third acid, sodium acid pyrophosphate or sodium aluminum phosphate, by the federal standard (Flour and gluten).
Where the descriptions part
- Iowa State says most of a double-acting powder's reaction happens in the second, heated stage. That is true of Clabber Girl's figures and not of Rumford's.
- Arm & Hammer names cream of tartar as the first-stage acid in double-acting powder. Neither Clabber Girl's nor Rumford's ingredient list includes it.
Read the label on the tin you own; it is the only one whose acids are in your batter.
Is it still fresh
Leaveners lose strength with time and moisture. A tin that fizzed last year can give a flat cake this year, and the tin looks the same either way. A test takes a few minutes and settles it.
| Leavener | Keeps, by the maker | The test | A good result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baking powder | Up to 18 months unopened; best within 6 months once opened (Clabber Girl) | 1 tsp in 1/3 cup warm water | Bubbles right away |
| Baking soda | About 2 years unopened; within 6 months once opened (Clabber Girl) | A little soda in vinegar or lemon juice | Fizzes right away |
| Active dry or instant yeast | Sealed, around 2 years; opened, in the refrigerator, 3 to 4 months (Fleischmann's) | 1 tsp sugar in 1/4 cup water at 100 to 110 °F (38 to 43 °C), stir in 1 packet, wait 10 minutes | Foams up to the 1/2 cup mark |
| Fresh (cake) yeast | Best within several weeks, refrigerated; not frozen (Fleischmann's) | No separate test from the maker | Use within the maker's time |
Sources: Clabber Girl, FAQs; Fleischmann's, FAQ and Yeast 101. These are makers' figures for their own products. Product-specific
A few practical points.
- Write the opening date on the tin or jar. The printed date is for the unopened product. The opened clock is the one that matters, and nothing on the tin records it.
- Keep yeast cold and dry once opened. Fleischmann's says airtight, at the back of the refrigerator, and does not recommend freezing.
- A weak result is a fail. Slow, scattered bubbles mean the leavener has lost some of its strength, and no source we read gives a way to make up for it by using more. We replace it. Convention
- The proof test uses the yeast. A proofed packet can go into the recipe if the recipe dissolves its yeast in water; take the 1/4 cup of water out of the recipe's liquid. That is our arithmetic, not the maker's instruction.
Record each result on the ingredient check in your kitchen sheet: the item, the date opened, the test, the result and the date of the test. Next time a bake falls, the sheet tells you whether the leavener was tested and when.
Swapping one leavener for another
A swap works when it puts back both halves of the reaction: the base and the acid. Our default for each case is the one the makers and an extension service agree on; where they part, the comparison is under Go deeper.
| You need | You have | The swap | Notes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 tsp baking powder | Soda and cream of tartar | 1/4 tsp soda plus 1/2 tsp cream of tartar | Acts at once, like single-acting powder; bake promptly | Arm & Hammer; Clabber Girl |
| 1 tsp baking powder | Soda and buttermilk | 1/4 tsp soda plus 1/2 cup buttermilk, sour milk or yogurt; cut the recipe's liquid by 1/2 cup | Adds tang | CSU Extension |
| 1 tsp baking powder | Soda and lemon juice or vinegar | 1/4 tsp soda plus 1 tsp lemon juice or vinegar | Acts at once | Arm & Hammer |
| 1 tsp baking powder | Soda and molasses | 1/4 tsp soda plus 1/4 cup molasses; cut the liquid by 1 to 2 tbsp | Changes color and flavor | CSU Extension |
| 1 tsp baking soda | Baking powder | 3 tsp baking powder | The recipe's acid has less soda to react with; the taste may change | Arm & Hammer; Clabber Girl |
| 1/2 tsp cream of tartar | Lemon juice or vinegar | 1 1/2 tsp lemon juice or vinegar | Adds liquid | Illinois Extension |
| Natural cocoa | Dutch-process cocoa | Cocoa 1 for 1; omit the soda; use an equal amount to twice as much baking powder | The cocoa's acid is gone, so the soda has nothing to react with | Iowa State Extension |
| Dutch-process cocoa | Natural cocoa | Cocoa 1 for 1; replace the baking powder with half as much baking soda | The soda now has the cocoa's acid to react with | Iowa State Extension |
The substitutions page carries these rows with the rest of the manual's swaps, and Fat, sugar, eggs and liquid has the buttermilk substitute made from milk.
What does not swap
- Soda alone for powder. Without an acid, soda gives little lift. Add the acid half, as the rows above do.
- Yeast for a chemical leavener, or the reverse. Yeast needs time, warmth and a dough that holds gas for an hour or more; a muffin batter is built to bake in minutes. No source we read gives a conversion, and this manual does not offer one.
- A different amount to make up for an old tin. Test it and replace it (freshness).
Cream of tartar: 1/2 or 5/8 teaspoon
For 1 teaspoon of baking powder, Arm & Hammer and Clabber Girl give 1/4 teaspoon of soda with 1/2 teaspoon of cream of tartar, and CSU's three-part version is the same with 1/4 teaspoon of cornstarch added. Illinois Extension and CSU's two-part version give 5/8 teaspoon of cream of tartar (Illinois Extension, Substitutions for Common Ingredients). The difference is 1/8 teaspoon of acid. We use 1/2, the makers' figure, because it is the one the makers of both soda and powder give; 5/8 leaves less soda unreacted. Either is a reasonable starting point.
How strong soda is against powder
Arm & Hammer calls soda "about 3-4 times" as strong as powder, and its own conversion, like Clabber Girl's, is 3 teaspoons of powder for 1 of soda. Iowa State's cocoa swap uses an equal amount to twice as much powder for the soda it removes. That ratio is smaller because the cocoa's acid is removed with the soda, so there is less for the soda to have done.
Yeast: the types and converting between them
Yeast is a living single-celled fungus. Fed on the sugars in a dough, it gives off carbon dioxide, and a dough with enough gluten holds that gas and rises. Unlike soda and powder, it works slowly and its speed depends on temperature. Physical principle
The types
| Type | What it is | How it goes in | Liquid temperature (Fleischmann's) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Active dry | Dried granules, larger than instant | Dissolved in warm liquid first | 100 to 110 °F (38 to 43 °C) |
| Instant (sold as RapidRise, bread machine yeast) | Finer dried granules | Mixed with the dry ingredients | 120 to 130 °F (49 to 54 °C) for liquids added to the dry mix |
| Fresh (cake or compressed) | Moist, crumbly blocks | Dissolved in water | 70 to 90 °F (21 to 32 °C) |
Source: Fleischmann's, Yeast 101. Fleischmann's says its Instant, Bread Machine and RapidRise yeasts are the same yeast, and that RapidRise loses its fast-rising ability if dissolved first. Product-specific
The two liquid ranges are for two methods, not two yeasts: active dry dissolved directly in the water, and instant stirred into the flour first, where the flour cools the liquid. Use the range for the method your recipe uses. The temperatures page carries them, and Temperature covers checking water with a thermometer.
Converting
The packet is the unit most recipes use. One packet is 1/4 oz, 7 g, about 2 1/4 teaspoons (Red Star, FAQ; Fleischmann's). Red Star says one packet raises up to about 4 cups of flour (Red Star, Yeast Conversion Chart).
- Instant in place of active dry: the same amount. Red Star says the two can be used one for one; King Arthur Baking says to substitute instant 1:1 by weight or volume for any active dry (King Arthur Baking, Active dry versus instant yeast); Fleischmann's uses an equal amount stirred into the dry ingredients.
- Active dry in place of instant: our default is the same amount, by Red Star and King Arthur. If the yeast you hold is a brand whose maker gives its own ratio, follow that maker for its yeast. The makers' figures are compared under Go deeper below. Product-specific
- Fresh yeast: one 2 oz cake equals three packets of dry yeast, and one 0.6 oz cake equals one packet (Fleischmann's; Red Star).
The yeast converter does the arithmetic and shows each maker's figure.
What slows yeast, and what kills it
- Cold. A cool liquid slows or stops yeast (Fleischmann's, Ingredients). Red Star gives 85 to 95 °F (29 to 35 °C) as ideal rise temperatures (Red Star, Tips and Troubleshooting). A cool kitchen means a longer rise, not a failed one. Yeast bread covers judging a rise by the dough.
- Salt. Red Star says salt controls the rate of yeast action and strengthens gluten, and lists too much salt among the causes of a dough that did not rise, with the advice to keep yeast and salt apart when adding them.
- Sugar. Yeast feeds on sugar, but a lot of it slows fermentation. Red Star says to add yeast when a recipe has more than 1/2 cup of sugar per 4 cups of flour. That is why sweet, rich doughs often call for more yeast.
- Heat. Fleischmann's says a hot liquid will destroy yeast and gives no figure. Red Star gives one figure, for dough in the oven: after about 5 minutes, when the dough reaches 140 °F (60 °C), the yeast is killed and stops making gas (Red Star, Baking with Yeast Guide). The last burst of rise before that point is oven spring. Neither maker gives a water temperature at which yeast dies in a bowl, so we keep the liquid in the maker's range.
Check the liquid with a thermometer when you can. Without one, Red Star's fallback is liquid that feels comfortably warm to the touch; it gives no number for it.
The makers' yeast conversions compared
| Question | Red Star | King Arthur Baking | Fleischmann's | CSU Extension |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Instant in place of active dry | One for one | 1:1 by weight or volume | Equal amount, into the dry ingredients, liquids 120 to 130 °F, first rise replaced by a 10 minute rest | No figure |
| Active dry in place of instant | One for one | 1:1 | 25 percent more active dry, proofed 5 minutes at 100 to 110 °F, 20 minutes added to the rise | No figure |
| Teaspoons per packet | 2 1/4 | "A slightly heaped 2 teaspoons" (7 g) | 2 1/4 | 2 1/2 |
| Fresh yeast per packet | 2/3 oz in the chart; 0.67 oz (18.9 g) on its blog; 0.6 oz in a chart note | No figure | 0.6 oz | "1 compressed yeast cake" |
| Water for dissolving | "Comfortably warm" to the touch; no number | No figure in the post | 100 to 110 °F | No figure |
Sources: Red Star, FAQ, conversion chart and How to Convert Dry Yeast to Cake Yeast; King Arthur Baking, Active dry versus instant yeast; Fleischmann's, Yeast 101; CSU Extension, Ingredient Substitutions.
Read Fleischmann's 25 percent as its rule for its own RapidRise, written with its own method (proofing, a longer rise) attached. Red Star and King Arthur treat the two as one for one. All of them agree that one 2 oz cake equals three packets. King Arthur explains why active dry was once proofed as a rule: older manufacture left only about 30 percent of the cells alive, and modern drying is gentler.
Bread machines
Red Star gives 3/4 teaspoon of active dry or 1/2 teaspoon of instant per cup of flour in a bread machine, and liquids at 80 °F (27 °C). Follow the machine maker's manual where it says otherwise.
Steam and air
Air and steam lift every bake to some degree, and some bakes rely on them with no chemical leavener or yeast.
Air beaten in
- Creaming. Beating solid fat with sugar traps small air bubbles, which the leavener's gas and the oven's heat then expand. Melted butter traps no air, which is one reason cookies made with it are denser and flatter (Iowa State, How the Cookie Crumbles). Cookies, muffins and biscuits covers the method.
- Whipped eggs. Beaten eggs can foam to as much as eight times their volume. Beaten whites lift angel food and sponge cakes, meringues and souffles, and add lift even in batters that also use baking powder (Exploratorium, The Amazing Multi-Tasking Egg).
Steam
Water expands enormously when it turns to steam: the Exploratorium gives one part liquid becoming 1,600 parts steam. Egg whites are about 88 percent water and yolks nearly 50 percent, so eggs carry water for steam as well as protein for structure (Exploratorium, same page). Physical principle
Pie crust shows steam at work. Pea-size pieces of cold fat melt in the oven and release steam, which pushes the layers of dough apart and makes a flaky crust (Iowa State AnswerLine, Pie Baking). That is why pie and pastry recipes keep the fat cold and the oven hot. Pie and pastry covers layered doughs. We did not find a source on bakes leavened by steam alone, such as popovers or cream puffs, so this manual does not give their method.
Sugar and a foam
In a foam cake, sugar does more than sweeten. The Exploratorium says that cutting the sugar in angel food lowers its volume, because sugar raises the temperature at which the batter sets, giving the foam more time to rise before it is fixed (Exploratorium, Why is my angel food cake such a flop?). Fat, sugar, eggs and liquid covers sugar's other jobs.
Leaveners at high elevation
Air pressure drops as elevation rises: CSU Extension gives 14.7 pounds per square inch at sea level and 12.3 at 5,000 feet. With less pressure on it, the same gas makes bigger bubbles, so a batter rises faster and higher, and can rise past what its structure holds and fall. CSU defines high elevation as starting at 3,000 feet (CSU Extension, High Elevation Food Preparation Guide). Physical principle
The usual first adjustment is less leavener. CSU's table for cakes reduces each teaspoon of baking powder by 1/8 teaspoon between 3,500 and 6,500 feet, by 1/8 to 1/4 teaspoon between 6,500 and 8,500, and by 1/4 teaspoon between 8,500 and 10,000, alongside changes to sugar, liquid and oven temperature. For yeast bread CSU suggests less yeast, or a second rise, and rising only until doubled. Oven temperatures themselves are not affected by elevation, CSU notes, and it still raises the baking temperature for cakes by 15 to 25 °F (8 to 14 °C).
These are starting points, not predictions. When a bake goes wrong covers the whole adjustment and where other extension services' tables differ, and the altitude calculator applies CSU's bands to a recipe.
See it: a birthday cake at 5,280 feet See it
The Hale household is fictional, and every fact about it is invented for this manual. Priya and Tom Hale live in Denver, at 5,280 feet, with their daughter Maya. They cook on a gas range with convection and own a kitchen scale, two 8-inch round pans and a 9 × 13. Last year's birthday cake sank in the middle. This year's is for Maya's seventh birthday, on a Saturday, for 20 guests. Priya starts with the cupboard.
Known: the tin of baking powder has no opening date. In the Clabber Girl test, 1 teaspoon in 1/3 cup of warm water gives a few slow bubbles instead of an immediate fizz, so it fails. The soda fizzes at once in vinegar and passes. The cake recipe (the same one as last year) uses 2 teaspoons of baking powder and no soda, with 2 1/2 cups of flour and 1 cup of milk. Denver sits in CSU's 3,500 to 6,500 foot band, where CSU reduces each teaspoon of baking powder by 1/8 teaspoon. For 2 teaspoons, that is 1/4 teaspoon less: 1 3/4 teaspoons.
Assumed (Priya's assumption): that last year's sinking came from the leavening, either the tired tin or the sea-level amount at Denver's elevation. Under that assumption, a fresh tin and 1 3/4 teaspoons should hold the middle.
Open: whether the old tin was already weak last year (there is no record to settle it; the ingredient check gives her one for next year); whether the cake also needs CSU's sugar and liquid changes for the band (up to 1 tablespoon less sugar per cup and 1 to 2 tablespoons more liquid per cup) and a higher oven temperature (a test bake settles it, and Cakes and frosting covers reading doneness); and whether the oven runs true, since an oven that runs cool is another cause of a sunken middle (The oven and the pan settles that with a thermometer).
What she does: she buys a new tin, writes the opening date on it, and records both tests in the ingredient check. She bakes one test layer two weeks before the party with the fresh powder at 1 3/4 teaspoons, changing nothing else, and logs it in the bake log. If the middle holds, the leavening was the cause under her assumption; if it still dips, the sugar and liquid adjustments are the next single change.
- Clabber Girl, FAQs: shelf life and the warm-water test for baking powder, and the soda test.
- Arm & Hammer, Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder: what soda needs, its strength against powder, and the swaps.
- Fleischmann's, Yeast 101: the yeast types, their liquid temperatures and the proof test.
- CSU Extension, High Elevation Food Preparation Guide: why leavening changes with elevation, and the cake table.
Practice: test the cupboard Practice
Minimum: test the baking powder, the baking soda and the yeast you have, and write the three results. If you have only one or two of them, test those. Time: 15 minutes, most of it waiting on the yeast. Materials: a teaspoon and a 1/4 cup measure, three small glasses, warm water, vinegar or lemon juice, sugar, a thermometer if you have one, and the ingredient check in your kitchen sheet.
- Read the dates. Note the printed date on each tin or jar, and the opening date if you wrote one.
- Test the baking powder. Stir 1 teaspoon into 1/3 cup of warm water. Watch for bubbles right away.
- Test the soda. Drop a little into a spoonful of vinegar or lemon juice. Watch for an immediate fizz.
- Proof the yeast. Stir 1 teaspoon of sugar into 1/4 cup of water at 100 to 110 °F (38 to 43 °C), add one packet or 2 1/4 teaspoons, and wait 10 minutes. It should foam up to the 1/2 cup mark.
- Write each result and today's date on the ingredient check. Replace anything that failed, and write the opening date on the new one.
- Read one recipe you bake often. Name its leavener, and if it uses soda, name its acid.
Watch the two stages. Stir 1 teaspoon of double-acting powder into 1/3 cup of room-temperature water and watch for a minute. Then set the glass in a pan of hot water and watch again. If your powder is the 30 and 70 kind, the second fizz will be the larger. Test it
Check a recipe's soda. Put a soda recipe's flour and soda into the soda check and see where it sits against Arm & Hammer's 1/4 teaspoon per cup of flour.
Convert a yeast recipe both ways. Take a recipe that uses one packet of active dry and write the amount of instant and of fresh yeast it needs by each maker's figure, using the yeast converter.
Your kitchen Your kitchen
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does each leavener in your cupboard have a dated test result on the ingredient check?
- Does each opened tin or jar carry its opening date?
- For a recipe you bake, can you name its leavener and, if it uses soda, the acid the soda meets?
- When you swapped a leavener, did the swap supply both the base and the acid?
- Did you measure leaveners with a leveled spoon, or on a scale that reads small amounts?
- If you bake above 3,000 feet, have you read the reduction for your band?
Worked example
Priya's cupboard meets the first two criteria: both tests are recorded with a date, and the new tin carries its opening date. Her recipe uses powder only, so the acid question does not arise. Her adjustment follows CSU's band for Denver. What she has not shown yet is that the leavening was the cause of last year's sinking. Under her assumption it was; her test layer, baked with one change, settles it, and the oven check rules out the other likely cause.
Common mistakes
- Trusting the printed date on an opened tin. The date is for the sealed product. Test it.
- Using soda in place of powder with no acid added. Little lift, and possibly the bitter or alkaline taste CSU describes. Add the acid half of the swap.
- Letting a soda batter wait. The gas escapes before the oven can set it. Have the oven hot first.
- Heaped spoons. A heaped quarter teaspoon of soda holds noticeably more than a level one. Level it.
- Dissolving instant yeast in water at the instant temperature. The 120 to 130 °F range is for liquid added to the dry ingredients, not for dissolving.
- Swapping natural and Dutch-process cocoa without changing the leavener. Iowa State gives the leavener change for each direction.
What is still unresolved
This chapter cannot tell you how much soda a given acid needs; no source we found publishes that, and a test bake is the only measure. It does not tell you why a particular bake fell; leavening is one cause among several, and When a bake goes wrong takes them in order. Rising and proofing a yeast dough are in Yeast bread.