Dough and leavening: water temperature, yeast conversion and the soda check
Reference

Dough and leavening: water temperature, yeast conversion and the soda check

Three calculators: the water temperature that brings a yeast dough to its desired temperature, one yeast type converted to another by two makers' ratios, and how much baking soda per cup of flour a recipe uses, read against published figures.

Three boxes for the leavening side of a recipe. The first sets the water so a yeast dough comes out at the temperature you want, which is how Yeast bread makes rise times repeatable. The second converts yeast types by two makers' ratios. The third reads a recipe's baking soda against the published figures.

Water temperature for a yeast dough

Converting yeast

The soda check

For a recipe with baking soda: enter the flour, the soda and any buttermilk, sour milk, yogurt or molasses. The box compares the soda with two published figures. It cannot predict the rise.

Limits

The dough temperature formula is one practitioner's method and its friction factors are home estimates; the dough's own temperature after mixing settles it. The yeast and soda figures are makers' and one extension service's rules of thumb. None of the three promises a rise; Leaveners explains what each one does.

Assumptions behind the numbers

  • Desired dough temperature is King Arthur Baking's professional formula (Dough Temperature): the desired temperature times 3 (times 4 with a preferment), minus the flour, room and preferment temperatures and the friction factor, gives the water temperature. It is one practitioner's method; we found no university source for it.
  • Friction factors are King Arthur Baking's home figures: 22 to 24 °F in a stand mixer, 6 to 8 °F mixing and kneading by hand (Desired dough temperature), 0 to 4 °F for gentle folds (Determining the friction factor). Its ideal range for wheat yeast doughs is 75 to 78 °F. In Celsius, friction factors are divided by 1.8.
  • Yeast: a packet is 1/4 oz, 7 g, about 2 1/4 teaspoons (Red Star, FAQ; Fleischmann's, FAQ). Instant and active dry one for one: Red Star and King Arthur Baking (active dry versus instant). Fleischmann's uses 25 percent more active dry in place of its RapidRise (Yeast 101).
  • Fresh yeast: one 2 oz cake equals three packets (Fleischmann's; Red Star, dry to cake yeast). Per packet, Fleischmann's gives a 0.6 oz cake and Red Star 0.67 oz (18.9 g); the tool shows both and takes a Fleischmann's 0.6 oz cake (17 g) as the unit when you enter fresh yeast.
  • Water for yeast: 100 to 110 °F to dissolve active dry, 120 to 130 °F when instant is mixed with the dry ingredients (Fleischmann's). Red Star says the yeast dies once the dough reaches 140 °F in the oven (Baking with Yeast Guide).
  • Soda: Arm & Hammer's Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder says recipes typically use 1/4 tsp soda per cup of flour. Colorado State University Extension's Ingredient Substitutions replaces 1 tsp baking powder with 1/4 tsp soda plus 1/2 cup buttermilk, sour milk or yogurt, or plus 1/4 cup molasses; the box reads those as how much acid ingredient 1/4 tsp of soda balances. No maker or extension service we found publishes a soda-per-cup figure for each acid, and the "more than twice the typical figure" flag is our threshold.