Yeast bread
Methods

Yeast bread: how to know when dough has risen enough, and how to knead, shape and bake a loaf

A straight-dough loaf taken through mixing, kneading, rising, shaping and baking, with the rise judged by the dough (how to know it has risen enough), the windowpane test, dough temperature set, and a dense homemade loaf traced to its cause.

Start here Essentials

For a first loaf, take one plain sandwich loaf through the stages and write down what the dough did at each one. A thermometer helps; the first loaf can be judged by the dough and the crust without one.

  1. Weigh or carefully measure the flour, and set the water temperature from the dough temperature box. The box and the formula are under mixing.
  2. Knead until a small piece stretches thin enough to let light through. That is the windowpane test (kneading).
  3. Let the dough rise, covered, until it has about doubled. Judge it by the dough, not the recipe's time (rising).
  4. Shape it, let it rise until a floured finger leaves a dent that springs back slowly, and bake until the center reads the loaf's temperature. See shaping and baking.
  5. Cool it on a rack before you slice it, and fill in the bread sheet (cooling).

Minimum time: about 4 hours, most of it waiting. Done when: one loaf is baked and the bread sheet records the water and dough temperatures, both rise times and the internal temperature (or, without a thermometer, the crust color and the sound of the bottom).

Mixing: the dough and its temperature Understand

A yeast bread is a dough leavened by yeast, a living fungus that eats sugars in the flour and gives off carbon dioxide and alcohol. The gas is trapped by gluten, the stretchy network that wheat proteins form with water (Flour and gluten explains it). This chapter teaches the straight dough: every ingredient mixed at once, with no starter or pre-mixed portion, then taken through a fixed set of stages. Illinois Extension's 4-H bread book calls it the conventional method.

Every source we read gives the stages in the same order. King Arthur Baking's bread class lists them as mixing, kneading, bulk fermentation, dividing and shaping, proofing, baking and cooling (King Arthur Baking School, Bread Baking Basics, a paid class we cite for its outline only). Red Star Yeast's guide and Illinois's 4-H book give the same sequence. Each stage has its own sign of being finished, and the signs matter more than the times.

StageWhat happensHow you judge it is finishedSection
MixingFlour, water, yeast and salt become one massNo dry flour left; the dough temperature is where you aimedMixing
KneadingGluten forms and lines upSmooth, springy, passes the windowpane testKneading
Bulk fermentation (first rise)Yeast fills the dough with gas and flavor developsAbout doubled in volumeRising
Dividing and shapingThe dough is cut to size and given a tight surfaceA smooth, taut loaf with the seam underneathShaping
Proofing (final rise)The shaped loaf rises againA floured finger leaves a dent that springs back slowlyShaping
BakingThe loaf expands, sets and brownsCrust color, a hollow sound, and the center temperatureBaking
CoolingMoisture leaves and the crumb setsThe loaf is cool to the touch all throughCooling

The flour is approximate; the water is not

Illinois's 4-H book makes a point most recipes leave unsaid: a bread recipe gives an exact amount of liquid and an approximate amount of flour, and you add flour until the dough stops sticking. Red Star says the flour a dough takes can vary by up to 1/2 cup, and suggests starting with about half of it and adding the rest as you mix. Weighing the flour removes most of the measuring error (Measuring), but flours still absorb water differently, so hold back a little and judge the dough. Illinois warns that too much flour gives heavy, dense bread. Test it

Bakers write a bread formula in baker's percentages: every ingredient as a percentage of the flour's weight, with flour at 100. Hydration is the water's weight over the flour's. A dough of 500 g flour and 320 g water is 64 percent hydration. The baker's percentage calculator does the arithmetic, and Measuring explains it.

Yeast, two ways

Red Star describes two ways to add dry yeast: blend it with the flour, or dissolve it in the liquid first. The maker's temperatures differ by type. Fleischmann's gives 100 to 110 °F (38 to 43 °C) for active dry yeast dissolved in water, and 120 to 130 °F (49 to 54 °C) for liquids added to instant (RapidRise or bread machine) yeast already mixed into the flour (Fleischmann's, Yeast 101). Product-specific Those are temperatures for the yeast's first contact with liquid. They are not the temperature you want the whole dough to reach, which is the next idea. Leaveners covers the types and the yeast converter swaps one for another.

Salt does more than season. Illinois's 4-H book says salt slows the yeast and gives a fine texture, and that bread with too little salt is coarse and may rise too much and fall. Red Star advises keeping yeast and salt apart when you first add them.

Desired dough temperature

The dough's own temperature sets how fast it rises. Desired dough temperature (DDT) is the temperature you aim for at the end of mixing. King Arthur Baking gives 75 to 78 °F (24 to 26 °C) as the ideal range for wheat yeast doughs. Convention You cannot heat the flour or the room easily, but you can choose the water, so the method solves for the water temperature. King Arthur's professional reference gives the formula for a straight dough (King Arthur Baking, Dough Temperature):

  1. Multiply the desired dough temperature by 3. That is the total.
  2. Subtract the flour temperature, the room temperature and the friction factor: the heat the mixing itself adds.
  3. What is left is the water temperature.

King Arthur's home figures for the friction factor are 22 to 24 °F for a stand mixer and 6 to 8 °F for mixing and kneading by hand (King Arthur Baking, Desired dough temperature). Your own mixer and habits give your own figure, and you find it from one loaf: multiply the dough temperature you actually got by 3 and subtract the other three temperatures. This is one practitioner's method; we found no extension or agency source for it. Temperature works through it, and the dough temperature calculator does the sum.

Kitchen and methodDesired doughFlourRoomFrictionWater
A mild room, stand mixer76 °F72 °F74 °F24 °F228 − 72 − 74 − 24 = 58 °F (14 °C)
A cool room, stand mixer76 °F64 °F64 °F22 to 24 °F228 − 64 − 64 − 22 to 24 = 76 to 78 °F (24 to 26 °C)
A cool room, by hand76 °F64 °F64 °F7 °F228 − 64 − 64 − 7 = 93 °F (34 °C)

The first row is King Arthur's own worked example. The other two are our arithmetic with King Arthur's friction figures. With active dry yeast, King Arthur dissolves the yeast in about 3 tablespoons of the water warmed to 110 °F (43 °C), then adds the rest of the water at the calculated temperature.

King Arthur's blog reports a test: water at 50 °F (10 °C) gave a 72 °F (22 °C) dough and a sluggish rise, and water at 120 °F (49 °C) gave large bubbles and a loaf with a gap under the crust. The middle setting gave the best loaf. The method's point is that the water is the one temperature you can set.

Kneading: building the gluten

Kneading is working the dough by folding, pushing and turning it, by hand or with a mixer's dough hook, so the gluten develops into a network strong enough to hold gas. Illinois's 4-H book describes the hand method: fold the dough toward you, push it away with the heels of your hands, give it a quarter turn, and repeat.

How to tell it is done

The sources agree on the signs more than on the time. A kneaded dough is smooth, springy and elastic, with a satiny surface and small blisters, and no longer sticky (Illinois). Utah State University's yeast bread bulletin adds a hand test: the dough does not stick to a hand rested on it for a count of 30 (USU Extension, FN 283).

The windowpane test is the check most bakers use. King Arthur Baking describes it with a piece about the size of a ping-pong ball, stretched gently until light shows through (King Arthur Baking, A visual guide to bread baking). Red Star calls it the gluten window and uses a walnut-size piece. If the piece tears before it goes thin, knead longer and test again. Test it

King Arthur's guide also defines two phrases recipes use. "Smooth and elastic" means the dough stretches without tearing and snaps back, tacky but not sticky. "Shaggy mass," the stage just after mixing, means rough and lumpy with no dry flour left.

Times are a guide

USU gives 10 to 15 minutes of hand kneading; Illinois gives about 10. King Arthur and Red Star say to go by the look and feel of the dough. We take the times as a reason to start checking, and the windowpane as the answer. Convention A stand mixer kneads faster than hands but warms the dough more, which is why its friction factor is larger.

Too little kneading shows up later. Illinois says under-kneaded bread is coarse and irregular. USU's fault table traces thick cell walls and coarse texture partly to too little kneading. Red Star lists over-kneading too: a dough that turns soft and sticky and no longer stretches. By hand that is hard to reach; in a mixer it is possible, so check the dough rather than the clock.

Illinois recommends letting the dough rest about 10 minutes between steps, and says whole-grain doughs benefit most. A short rest lets the gluten relax, so the dough is easier to stretch and shape.

Rising: judging the dough, not the clock

Bulk fermentation, or the first rise, is the time the whole mass of kneaded dough rises before it is divided and shaped. King Arthur Baking says it typically takes around 1 to 2 hours and that the dough usually doubles (King Arthur Baking, What is proofing bread?). Strictly, King Arthur uses proofing for the second rise, after shaping; many recipes use the word for both.

Why the clock misleads

A recipe's rise time was true for the writer's dough in the writer's kitchen. King Arthur's Baker's Hotline names what changes it: the water and air temperature, humidity, the size of the dough, the container and the shape (King Arthur Baking, How to tell if bread dough has risen enough). Red Star says the same and adds that a cooler room simply means a longer rise. So we watch the dough and use the recipe's time only to know when to start looking.

King Arthur's tip for seeing "doubled": rise the dough in a straight-sided container and mark the starting level with tape. In a sloped bowl, doubling is hard to judge by eye. Cover the container with a lid, a bowl cover or plastic wrap; King Arthur says a tea towel lets the surface dry and form a skin.

Temperature: warmer is faster, cooler gives more flavor

Our default is King Arthur's: keep the rising dough at about 72 to 78 °F (22 to 26 °C), where the yeast is active without the dough overproofing or losing flavor. Convention Other publishers give warmer ranges, listed under Go deeper below. They agree on the trade-off: a warmer rise is faster, and a cooler, slower rise gives more flavor (King Arthur and Red Star both say so). Physical principle

Your exception is your own kitchen. In a cool room, a dough mixed to the right temperature will still cool as it sits. King Arthur lists warm spots: the top of the refrigerator, a turned-off oven with the light on, a heating pad on low, or a microwave with a cup of just-boiled water beside the bowl. A thermometer in the spot, before the dough goes in, tells you whether it is warm or hot.

Punching down

After the first rise, many recipes say to punch the dough down. Red Star says this redistributes the yeast, sugar and moisture and gives a finer crumb. A firm press to deflate it is enough.

Limits

A rise time in any recipe, including the ones cited here, is a guide at a stated temperature. This chapter teaches you to judge the dough by its volume and the poke test. It cannot tell you how long your dough will take in your kitchen; the bread sheet, filled in over two or three loaves, can.

Go deeper

Rise temperatures, publisher by publisher

PublisherRise temperatureNote
King Arthur Baking72 to 78 °F (22 to 26 °C)For proofing; yeast active without overproofing or losing flavor
Illinois Extension 4-HAbout 80 °F (27 °C)A warm place, until doubled
WSU Bread LabDough 74 to 80 °F (23 to 27 °C)Desired dough temperature for its whole wheat pan loaf
USU Extension FN 28385 to 90 °F (29 to 32 °C)A bulletin from 1976 to 2000, written for Utah
Red Star Yeast85 to 95 °F (29 to 35 °C)Its "ideal"; it also says a cool room only slows the rise

All five agree that the dough should be warm rather than cold for a timely rise; they differ by about 15 °F on how warm. USU's bulletin also says that at Utah's altitude, white dough rises 2 1/2 to 3 times before it is ripe, where every other source says doubled. That is an altitude finding, not a general rule.

Slow and cold rises

Illinois's 4-H book describes a "cool rise" method: more yeast and salt, shape the dough, then refrigerate it for 2 to 24 hours before baking. Colorado State University Extension suggests a refrigerator first rise to slow yeast dough at elevation (CSU Extension, Baking at Elevation). King Arthur notes that cold dough scores more cleanly. The sources behind this manual do not give a no-knead or long room-temperature method with figures, so we do not teach one here.

Shaping and the final proof

Shaping turns the risen dough into a loaf with a tight outer skin, which holds the loaf's shape and directs its rise upward. For a pan loaf, Illinois's 4-H book rolls the dough to a 10 by 6 inch rectangle, rolls it up from the narrow end, pinches the seam and sets the loaf seam down in the pan.

Shaping is also where large holes start. Red Star traces large holes to poor shaping and says to press out the air as you shape. USU's fault table names the "shell top," a hollow under the top crust, and traces it to a gas bubble left at shaping, a surface that dried while rising, or dough that rose too far.

The pan

The pan is part of the recipe. King Arthur Baking calls 8 1/2 by 4 1/2 inches the standard one-pound loaf pan, and says a 9 by 5 holds almost 20 percent more. The same dough in the larger pan rises less above the rim and looks short. The oven and the pan covers pan sizes, and the pan scaler resizes a recipe.

The final proof and the poke test

King Arthur says the second rise needs to be judged more carefully than the first, because there is no reshaping after it. Two checks:

  • Height in the pan. A pan loaf is ready when the dough has risen about 1 inch above the rim, in the pan size the recipe names (King Arthur).
  • The poke test. Flour a finger and press it about 1 inch into the side of the loaf. If the dent stays, bake. If it springs back quickly, wait and test again. Start testing at the early end of the recipe's time. Test it

A dough that has gone too far, overproofed, feels fragile and may collapse when poked. King Arthur says a quick reshape and a shorter second rise may save it. Illinois's 4-H judging tables trace a loaf that falls in the oven to overproofing that weakened the gluten.

The opposite fault is common in a cool kitchen. An underproofed loaf goes into the oven with too little gas and too much energy left. It rises hard in the oven, often bursting at one side, and its crumb can be tight. A dent that springs straight back is the sign to wait.

Go deeper

The poke test in four versions

Four publishers describe a finger test, with different depths and for different stages.

PublisherHowFor which riseReady when
King Arthur BakingOne floured finger, about 1 inchThe shaped loafThe indent stays
Illinois Extension 4-HTwo fingertips, about 1/2 inchThe first riseThe dents remain
Red Star YeastTwo fingers to the second knuckleThe first riseThe indentations remain; about doubled
USU Extension FN 283First finger to the second joint, quickly in and outThe first riseThe hole stays, with small creases on its walls and a bubble near the edge; if the whole mass collapses, it went too far

Same idea, different stages. A deep poke in a first rise tells you the dough is ready to shape. A shallow, floured poke in the shaped loaf tells you it is ready to bake. Use King Arthur's for the shaped loaf, because a deep poke would leave a hole you would see in the baked bread.

Baking: oven spring, steam, scoring and the center temperature

In the first minutes in a hot oven, the loaf rises quickly. USU calls this oven spring: the gas expands with heat and the yeast makes a last burst of gas. Red Star says the yeast stops when the dough reaches 140 °F (60 °C), after about 5 minutes. After that, the crust sets and the loaf gets no bigger. USU describes a good pan loaf as having a shredded break along the sides and a thin, crisp crust.

The oven temperature belongs to the recipe

Bread recipes bake at very different temperatures. WSU's Bread Lab heats its oven to 400 °F (204 °C) for a whole wheat pan loaf and turns it down to 350 °F (177 °C) as the loaf goes in. Its rustic hearth loaf bakes at 425 °F (218 °C). USU's bulletin bakes white loaves at 450 °F (232 °C), and fancy sweet rolls at 375 °F (191 °C) because extra sugar browns fast. So we follow the recipe's temperature and do not carry one figure from bread to bread. Convention Check that your oven reaches it with an oven thermometer (The oven and the pan).

Steam, for hearth loaves

King Arthur Baking says steam keeps the crust moist and flexible early in the bake, so the loaf reaches full oven spring, and gives the crust a gloss (King Arthur Baking, A guide to baking bread with steam at home). It matters most for free-form loaves baked on a stone or a sheet; a sandwich loaf in a pan does not need it. The rule is to start with steam and finish dry. Two home methods:

  • Trap the loaf's own steam. Bake it in a covered Dutch oven or under an upturned roasting pan, and take the lid off about 20 minutes in.
  • Add steam. Preheat a heavy pan on the bottom rack and pour boiling water into it as the loaf goes in. WSU's Bread Lab pours 1/2 cup of water into a cast-iron pan on the oven floor.

King Arthur says to turn convection off when you load the loaf, and that hot water on cast iron can warp and rust it.

Caution

Water poured into a pan in a hot oven turns to steam at once, and steam burns. Wear oven mitts, pour from arm's length with your face away from the door, and close the door straight after. A Dutch oven preheated in the oven is as hot as the oven; lift it and its lid with mitts on both hands. Glass bakeware can break if water hits it hot; follow the maker's instructions (The oven and the pan).

Scoring

Scoring is cutting the top of the loaf just before it bakes. King Arthur Baking says the cut makes a weak point, so oven spring opens the loaf where you choose instead of bursting at random (King Arthur Baking, How to score bread dough). Its figures: a cut 1/4 to 1/2 inch deep, deep enough to get below the skin made in shaping; a blade held at about 30 degrees to the surface makes a raised flap, and one held upright makes a wider, flatter opening. A blade that drags may mean the dough is overproofed. A sandwich loaf can go unscored, but if one side of your loaves keeps tearing, a single cut along the top is a test worth trying. Test it

Done: crust first, thermometer to confirm

King Arthur Baking's Baker's Hotline puts the senses first and the thermometer second, because the center can reach its finished temperature several minutes before the crust is done (King Arthur Baking, How to tell if bread is done baking). Its signs: a hollow sound when you knock the bottom of a crusty loaf, a sandwich loaf rich golden brown on its sides and bottom, and a loaf that weighs at least 15 percent less than the dough did.

For the thermometer, our default is King Arthur's benchmark: 190 °F (88 °C) at the center for most loaves and rolls (King Arthur Baking, Using a thermometer with yeast bread). Convention In its side-by-side test, sandwich loaves pulled at 190 °F were moister and stayed fresh longer than loaves taken to 205 °F (96 °C). Push the probe into the center from the end or the bottom, so the hole does not show.

BreadCenter temperaturePublisher
Most loaves and rolls190 °F (88 °C)King Arthur Baking
Lean dough breads (flour, water, yeast, salt)190 to 210 °F (88 to 99 °C)ThermoWorks
Rich dough breads (with butter, eggs, sugar or milk)180 to 190 °F (82 to 88 °C)ThermoWorks
BaguettesBy crust color; the inside reaches about 212 °F (100 °C)King Arthur Baking

Sources: King Arthur Baking, as linked above; ThermoWorks, Doneness Temperatures for Baked Goods, a thermometer maker's compilation. The temperatures page carries these rows.

No reading can go above the temperature at which water boils, and water boils lower at altitude: Colorado State University Extension gives 203 °F (95 °C) at 5,000 feet. A target near 210 °F is out of reach in a high kitchen, so above 3,000 feet we use the lower figures and the crust. Physical principle Temperature covers doneness readings in general.

Go deeper

Bread at altitude

Colorado State University Extension says yeast dough rises faster at high elevation, so it suggests less yeast, or punching the dough down and letting it rise twice, and letting it rise only until doubled (CSU Extension, High Elevation Food Preparation Guide). It recommends flour of at least 12 percent protein, and less flour or more liquid in dry air. King Arthur Baking suggests about 25 percent less yeast, colder water and a lower dough temperature. The University of Wyoming Extension raises the baking temperature 25 °F above 3,500 feet; CSU gives no bread-specific oven increase. When a bake goes wrong has the full altitude tables.

Cooling before slicing

A loaf keeps cooking after it leaves the oven. King Arthur Baking says moisture keeps leaving and the crumb keeps setting as the loaf cools, and that slicing early gives a gummy interior. Its advice is to cool completely; for high-rye breads, up to 24 hours. Convention

Take the loaf out of its pan straight away and set it on a rack. Red Star traces a soggy crust to a loaf left to cool in its pan, where steam collects against the sides. A rack lets air reach the bottom.

Cool means cool all through. A loaf that feels cool on the crust may still be warm at the center; an instant-read thermometer settles it, or wait until the bottom feels the same temperature as the room. A loaf wrapped warm sweats inside the wrap and the crust turns soft. Baking ahead covers storing and freezing bread.

Caution

Do not bake bread or cake in canning jars and seal them to keep on a shelf. Penn State Extension says breads and cakes in jars are not safe to eat: baking in a jar is not canning, many of these recipes are low in acid, and there is concern that botulism can grow in the sealed jar after baking (Penn State Extension, Setting the Record Straight on Canning Breads and Cakes). It knows of no reliable or safe recipe for it. Freeze bread instead.

Lean and enriched doughs

A lean dough is flour, water, yeast and salt, with little or nothing else: a baguette, a plain hearth loaf. An enriched dough adds fat, sugar, eggs or milk: sandwich loaves with butter and milk, dinner rolls, cinnamon rolls, challah, brioche and most holiday breads. The stages are the same. Three things change.

Lean doughEnriched dough
RiseThe yeast's own paceSlower with a lot of sugar; Red Star adds yeast when sugar passes 1/2 cup per 4 cups of flour
OvenOften hot, 400 to 450 °F in the recipes cited hereCooler; USU bakes sweet rolls at 375 °F because sugar browns fast
Done190 to 210 °F (ThermoWorks); 190 °F for most loaves (King Arthur)180 to 190 °F (ThermoWorks); yeast rolls 190 to 195 °F (Kansas State)
Crust colorDeep brown, crispBrowns sooner; challah lighter golden between the braids, brioche deep mahogany (King Arthur)

Sugar feeds yeast in small amounts and slows it in large ones. Red Star's conversion chart says sugar slows fermentation, and that a dough with more than 1/2 cup of sugar per 4 cups of flour needs more yeast. Product-specific Fat coats the gluten, so an enriched dough is softer and slower to pass the windowpane test.

Enriched loaves brown before they finish inside. Fleischmann's suggests baking 25 °F lower and a little longer, or covering the loaf loosely with foil, for a lighter crust. A thermometer helps most here, because the color that means "done" on a lean loaf comes early on an enriched one.

Holiday breads are mostly enriched doughs, often braided or filled. A filled or braided loaf has more surface and more seams, so read the center in the thickest part. Rolls are small loaves: they rise and bake faster, and King Arthur measured an edge roll at 192 °F while the center roll in the same pan read 171 °F, so read a center roll. A dough with eggs or dairy follows the usual handling rules once baked; Baking ahead says which bakes need the refrigerator.

Go deeper

Whole wheat and hydration

Whole wheat flour takes more water. WSU's Bread Lab's 100 percent whole wheat pan loaf runs at 87 percent hydration, with honey and olive oil, and holds back about 10 percent of the water to add after the dough has developed some (WSU Bread Lab, The Approachable Loaf). Its dough temperature is 74 to 80 °F, with a 1 hour bulk rise, a fold halfway, and a 60 to 90 minute final proof. Red Star suggests replacing up to half the bread flour with whole grain, starting at 25 to 30 percent. USU's bulletin says whole wheat dough is ripe soon after doubling, sooner than white.

Pre-ferments, named

A pre-ferment is a portion of the flour and water fermented ahead of the main mix. It adds flavor and changes timing. WSU's Approachable Loaf ferments 12 percent of its flour as a levain, a pre-ferment made with sourdough starter, for 12 to 16 hours. King Arthur's altitude advice mentions a sponge, 1 to 2 cups of the flour mixed with water and yeast ahead of time. With a pre-ferment, King Arthur's dough temperature formula multiplies by 4 instead of 3 and subtracts the pre-ferment's temperature too. Pre-ferments as a routine are beyond one chapter.

Limits

This manual makes no health claim for sourdough. Sourdough is made with wheat flour and contains gluten. Questions about gluten, celiac disease or digestion go to a clinician or a registered dietitian (Flour and gluten).

Caution

King Arthur Baking says to throw a starter out and start over if it shows mold (often fuzzy, in various colors) or any pink or orange tint or streak. We found no extension or agency guidance on spoiled starters; this is a practitioner's rule, and we follow it.

A sourdough starter Go deeper

A sourdough starter is a mixture of flour and water kept alive by regular feeding, in which wild yeast and bacteria grow. Clemson Cooperative Extension describes sourdough as lactic acid fermentation: lactic acid bacteria from the flour, the water and the room produce lactic acid, which gives the sour taste (Clemson HGIC, Sourdough 101 Guide). A starter replaces packaged yeast; a loaf made with one rises more slowly.

Making one

King Arthur Baking's method (King Arthur Baking, How to make sourdough starter from scratch):

  1. Day 1: stir 113 g whole wheat or pumpernickel flour with 113 g water at 68 to 70 °F (20 to 21 °C) in a container of at least 1 quart. Leave it covered at about 70 °F for 24 hours.
  2. Day 2: discard all but 113 g, and feed it 113 g all-purpose flour and 113 g water.
  3. Days 3 to 5: feed the same way twice a day, about 12 hours apart.
  4. Keep going until it reliably doubles within 6 to 8 hours of a feeding. That can take a week or a couple of weeks; watch the rise, not the calendar.

WSU's Bread Lab uses a gentler method with no discard: 1/4 cup each of whole wheat flour and water, fed 1 tablespoon of each morning and night, active after about 5 days (WSU Bread Lab, Sourdough Starter). Clemson's guide follows a discard-and-feed method like King Arthur's. Discarding keeps the volume manageable and gives the remaining yeast more food.

Feeding ratios and peak times

A feeding ratio is starter to flour to water, by weight. King Arthur Baking calls 1:1:1 the minimum. More food relative to starter means a slower peak, which lets you time the starter to your day. Its trial at about 78 °F (26 °C) (King Arthur Baking, Testing different sourdough feeding ratios):

Ratio (starter : flour : water)At 4 hoursAt 8 hoursAt 12 hoursUse
1:1:1Doubled, readyBeginning to fallMuch reducedFeed in the morning, bake in the afternoon
1:2:2Nearly doubledPeakBeginning to fallBetween the two
1:4:4Not yet doubledNearly doubledPeakFeed at bedtime, bake in the morning

One starter, one trial, at one temperature. A cooler kitchen moves every column later. King Arthur says the ratio changes timing, not how the starter bakes.

The sources give different peak times for a mature starter: Clemson says it doubles within 4 to 6 hours of feeding; King Arthur's creation guide says 6 to 8; its visual guide says about 8. Temperature and feeding ratio explain most of the spread. King Arthur's visual guide describes a ripe starter: doubled, just starting to sag, slightly higher at the edges than in the middle, with fine bubbles on top. Clemson adds a float test: a spoonful that floats in water is ready.

Keeping it

King Arthur Baking keeps a starter in the refrigerator and feeds it once a week: keep 113 g, feed 113 g each of flour and water, leave it out 1 to 2 hours until bubbling, and refrigerate it (King Arthur Baking, Sourdough Baking: Maintain). At room temperature, it feeds every 12 hours. Measure starter by weight; its volume changes with its thickness. To dispose of discard, King Arthur dries it on parchment or thins it with cold water before it goes down the drain.

Signs of trouble

King Arthur Baking's troubleshooting page says a mature starter is hardy (King Arthur Baking, Sourdough starter troubleshooting). It survives a missed feeding, uneven amounts, a stainless steel bowl and a few days in the freezer. Heat kills it: yeast dies at 140 °F (60 °C). Liquid on top, called hooch, is alcohol from fermentation and means the starter is hungry; King Arthur says gray, brown or black hooch does not by itself mean spoiled. Mold and pink or orange streaks do, as the caution above says. When a bake goes wrong lists starter problems with the rest.

See it: a sandwich loaf in a cold kitchen See it

Fictional example

Marcus Bell is fictional, and every fact about him is invented for this manual. He wants one sandwich loaf a week. His kitchen is 64 °F (18 °C) in winter. He has a stand mixer, a scale and an instant-read thermometer. His loaves have been dense, and the tops tear.

Known, from his bread sheet: 500 g bread flour and 320 g water, which is 64 percent hydration. He aimed for a 76 °F (24 °C) dough; with King Arthur's stand-mixer friction factor of 22 to 24 °F, the formula gave 76 to 78 °F water, and he used 78 °F (26 °C). After mixing and kneading in the stand mixer, the dough read 77 °F (25 °C), inside King Arthur's 75 to 78 °F range. Room 64 °F. Bulk rise from 09:10 to 11:00, 1 hour 50 minutes, in a straight-sided container with a tape mark; it had about doubled. Shaped, then proofed 55 minutes in the loaf pan. Baked to 195 °F (91 °C) at the center, which is above King Arthur's 190 °F benchmark and inside ThermoWorks' lean range. The top tore along one side.

His friction factor, worked out. The dough came out one degree over his target. 77 × 3 = 231. 231 − 64 (flour) − 64 (room) − 78 (water) = 25 °F, just above King Arthur's 22 to 24 °F for a stand mixer. For his next loaf, 25 °F is his own figure: 228 − 64 − 64 − 25 = 75 °F water for a 76 °F dough.

Assumed (Marcus's assumption): his flour was at room temperature, 64 °F, because the bag sits on the counter. If the flour was colder, his friction figure is higher than 25. Reading the flour with the probe settles it.

Open, and who settles each:

  • Whether 55 minutes was long enough for the final proof. In a 64 °F room the shaped loaf cools as it sits, and a loaf that goes in underproofed rises hard and bursts. He did not poke test it. Marcus settles it on the next loaf by baking when the dent springs back slowly, whatever the clock says.
  • Whether the tear comes from the proof or the oven. USU's fault table traces a crack along one side to uneven oven heat or crowded pans, on the cooler side. King Arthur says an unscored loaf bursts where it chooses. Marcus checks his oven with a thermometer (The oven and the pan) and scores the next loaf once along the top.
  • Whether the loaf is dense because of the proof, the flour or the kneading. One change at a time settles it: the proof first, because the bread sheet shows it as the shortest stage in the coldest room.

Under these assumptions, the most likely single change is a longer final proof in a warmer spot. That is a guess to test, not a finding; When a bake goes wrong explains why only one thing changes.

Practice: one loaf, logged stage by stage Practice

Minimum: one plain pan loaf from any recipe you trust, with the bread sheet filled in. Without a thermometer, write the crust color and the sound of the bottom where the temperatures go. Time: about 4 hours, most of it rising and cooling, plus 10 minutes to write it up. Materials: flour, yeast, salt, water, a bowl or straight-sided container with tape, a loaf pan, a rack, a scale or measuring cups, an instant-read thermometer if you have one, and the bread sheet.

  1. Before mixing, read the room and the flour. Put the numbers in the dough temperature calculator with 77 °F as the target and your mixing method's friction factor. Write the water temperature it gives.
  2. Mix, holding back a little flour. Add it until the dough stops sticking. Write the flour you used.
  3. Knead until the windowpane test passes, and read the dough's temperature. Write it and the time.
  4. Rise it covered, with a tape mark. Write the start time. Check from the early end of the recipe's time; write the time it doubled.
  5. Shape, pan it and proof it. Poke test from the early end. Write the time the dent sprang back slowly.
  6. Bake at the recipe's temperature. Read the center, or knock the bottom. Write the reading and the crust color.
  7. Cool it on a rack until cool through, then slice it and write what the crumb looks like.
Go deeper

Find your friction factor. From the loaf above, multiply the dough temperature you got by 3 and subtract the flour, room and water temperatures. Use the result for the next loaf, and see whether the dough lands on target.

Bake two loaves to different temperatures. Take one to 190 °F and one to 205 °F, as King Arthur did, and compare them the next day.

Weigh the loss. Weigh the shaped dough and the cooled loaf. King Arthur expects a loss of at least 15 percent.

Your kitchen Your kitchen

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Did you choose the water temperature from the dough temperature formula, and read the dough after kneading?
  • Did the dough pass the windowpane test before it rose?
  • Did you judge both rises by the dough (a doubled tape mark, a slow-springing dent) rather than by the recipe's time?
  • Did you bake to the recipe's temperature and check the center, or the crust and the hollow sound?
  • Did the loaf cool on a rack until cool through before slicing?
  • Does the bread sheet show both temperatures, both rise times and the doneness check?

Worked example

Marcus's sheet meets most of the criteria. He chose a water temperature and read his dough at 77 °F, one degree over his target and within King Arthur's range. His bulk rise was judged by a tape mark. His loaf reached 195 °F. One criterion is not met: the final proof was timed, not tested, so his sheet cannot say whether it was underproofed. His next loaf changes only that, poke tested in a warmer spot, and his oven check runs separately. If the next loaf rises evenly and the crumb opens up, the proof was the cause; if one side still tears, the oven and the scoring are next.

Common mistakes

  • Adding all the flour at once. A recipe's flour is approximate. Hold some back and stop when the dough stops sticking; too much gives a dense loaf.
  • Hot water "to help the yeast". Water hot enough to push the dough well above 78 °F speeds the rise past the point of flavor and can give large bubbles and a gap under the crust, as King Arthur's test showed.
  • Rising by the clock in a cold room. Your kitchen is not the recipe writer's. Use the tape mark and the poke test.
  • A tea towel over the bowl. The surface dries and forms a skin, which can streak the crumb. Use a lid or wrap.
  • Slicing a warm loaf. The crumb is still setting; it turns gummy.
  • Cooling in the pan. Steam softens the crust. Turn it out at once.

What is still unresolved

This chapter cannot tell you how long your dough will take; your bread sheet over two or three loaves will. It cannot tell you whether your oven runs true; an oven thermometer and The oven and the pan settle that. A dense or torn loaf has several possible causes, and When a bake goes wrong lists them in the order to check. For a regular sourdough practice, pre-ferments and fermentation logs, this manual stops at the starter.

Knowledge check and scenario

Your kitchen is 66 °F, your flour is 66 °F, you knead by hand (friction 7 °F) and you want a 77 °F dough. What water temperature?
231 − 66 − 66 − 7 = 92 °F (33 °C). The formula is King Arthur's: three times the desired dough temperature, minus flour, room and friction.
The recipe says the first rise takes 1 hour. At 1 hour your dough is about one and a half times its size. What do you do?
Wait and check again. The recipe's time was true for its writer's kitchen; the dough decides. Doubled, against a tape mark, is the sign. A cooler room just means a longer rise.
You poke the shaped loaf and the dent springs straight back. Bake it?
Not yet. King Arthur's test: if the indent springs back, wait; if it stays, bake. An underproofed loaf tends to rise hard in the oven and burst along one side.
A sandwich loaf reads 190 °F in the center but the crust is pale. Is it done?
Probably not by the crust's standard. King Arthur puts the senses first and the thermometer second, because the center can reach temperature before the crust is done. Give it a few more minutes for color.
(Go deeper) You want to bake sourdough at 8 in the morning. Which feeding ratio does King Arthur's trial suggest for the night before?
1:4:4 at bedtime. In the trial at about 78 °F it peaked at about 12 hours. In a cooler kitchen it will peak later.
Your shaped loaf has risen about 1 inch over the rim of the pan the recipe names. When you poke it, the dent fills in very slowly and the dough feels slightly fragile. The oven is hot. What do you do?
It is already at or near its peak. More time takes it toward overproofed, and a weak, overproofed loaf can collapse in the oven.
Height over the rim and a slow dent both say it is ready, and a slightly fragile feel says not to wait. Bake now; a light hand with the blade keeps it from deflating.
King Arthur says a quick reshape may save a dough that has gone too far, but this one has not yet. Reshaping costs another rise and some flavor; save it for a dough that collapses when poked.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.