Measuring
Measuring and heat

How to measure flour: by weight, by the cup, and as baker's percentages

Why a cup of flour is not a fixed amount, how to weigh flour with a scale and tare, how to measure flour without a scale by spooning and leveling, what the US cup is, and how to read a recipe as percentages of its flour.

Start here Essentials

For a first pass, measure the flour the same careful way every time and write down what it probably weighed. You can do all of it with measuring cups; a scale makes it shorter.

  1. If you have no scale, spoon the flour into the cup and level it. Do not scoop with the cup (flour by volume).
  2. Look up your recipe's flour on the ingredient weights page and write the gram figure beside the cup amount. Note whose figure it is (converting a recipe).
  3. If you have a scale, set the bowl on it, press tare, and weigh the flour. Tare again before each new ingredient (weighing with a scale).
  4. Write what you used on a recipe card. For each dry ingredient, the amount and how you measured it.

Minimum time: about 15 minutes, the next time you bake. Done when: the recipe card shows each dry ingredient with how it was measured, and the flour in grams.

Why a cup of flour is not a fixed amount Understand

A measuring cup measures volume: the space an ingredient takes up. A recipe works on the amount of the ingredient, and for flour the two do not line up. Flour is a powder with air between its particles. Press it down and more flour fits in the same space; fluff it and less does. The cup stays the same size while the amount of flour in it changes. Physical principle

King Arthur Baking measured the spread with its own all-purpose flour. Fluffed, spooned into the cup and leveled, a cup held around 120 grams. Packed down, the same cup held up to 160 grams (King Arthur Baking, How to measure flour). That is a third more flour from the same cup and the same bag, depending only on how it got in.

The disagreement does not stop at technique. Publishers who all spoon and level still print different figures for one cup of all-purpose flour:

PublisherOne cup of all-purpose flourWhat the figure is
Clemson Cooperative Extension (sourdough guide)106 gThe figure its starter recipe uses: 1 cup (106 g)
King Arthur Baking (ingredient weight chart)120 gThe company's own convention for a spooned and leveled cup
USDA FoodData Central, SR Legacy (2018)125 gA measured household portion in a federal food composition dataset
King Arthur Baking (measuring test)up to 160 gThe same flour packed into the cup

Sources: Clemson HGIC, Sourdough 101; King Arthur Baking, Ingredient Weight Chart; USDA FoodData Central downloads (SR Legacy, April 2018, portion weights).

Between 106 and 125 grams is a difference of 19 grams a cup before any reader's scoop adds its own error. In a recipe with 3 cups of flour, that is 57 grams, about half a cup by King Arthur's figure. Neither publisher is wrong. Each figure describes how that publisher filled its cup.

Limits

A published grams-per-cup figure is that publisher's own measure, not a property of flour. We cannot tell you what your recipe "needs" in grams unless the recipe says. We can tell you what the writer's cup probably weighed, if you know how the writer measured, and how to find out what your own cup weighs: weigh one cup filled three ways and write the numbers down. Test it

Why weighing is the default here

The National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), the federal agency for weights and measures, calls measuring ingredients by mass with a kitchen scale a best practice over measuring by volume (NIST, Culinary Measurement Tips). Mass is the amount of matter in something; a kitchen scale reports it as weight in grams or ounces. A gram of flour is a gram of flour however it was poured. So this manual teaches weighing as the default and spoon-and-level as the fallback, and says what each one costs.

Weighing removes the largest measuring error. It does not fix an oven that runs hot, butter that is too warm, or a batter that was overmixed; those are in The oven and the pan, Temperature and the methods chapters. And it does not make a recipe exact. Flour, eggs and kitchens vary, and recipes allow for that. King Arthur says that, generally, you can stay within 5 grams over or under the written amount without affecting the recipe (How to measure flour, above). One practitioner's tolerance

It is not only flour

Any ingredient that packs, settles or comes in different grain sizes has the same problem. Two examples from King Arthur's chart:

  • Salt. A tablespoon of table salt weighs 18 g. A tablespoon of Diamond Crystal kosher salt weighs 8 g, and of Morton kosher salt 16 g. The crystals are different shapes, so a spoonful holds different amounts. A recipe that says "1 tablespoon kosher salt" means twice as much salt with one brand as with the other. Product-specific
  • Brown sugar. USDA gives a packed cup as 220 g and an unpacked cup as 145 g. The word "packed" in a recipe is doing a lot of work.

The cup and the spoon, defined

A US recipe's cup is the US customary cup, a unit of volume. NIST's guide to units gives its exact size as 236.5882 milliliters (mL). In the same table, a US tablespoon is 14.78676 mL, a teaspoon 4.928922 mL and a US fluid ounce 29.57353 mL (NIST SP 811, Appendix B.9). Three teaspoons make a tablespoon, and sixteen tablespoons make a cup. Convention

A second cup appears on food packages. For nutrition labeling, a federal regulation says a cup means 240 mL, a tablespoon 15 mL, a teaspoon 5 mL, a fluid ounce 30 mL and an ounce of weight 28 g (21 CFR 101.9(b)(5)(viii)). NIST's own kitchen table rounds the same way, to 240 mL a cup and 5 mL a teaspoon, and marks those figures as approximate (NIST, Cooking Measurement Equivalencies).

UnitUS customary (exact, NIST SP 811)Label and kitchen rounding (21 CFR 101.9, NIST kitchen table)
1 teaspoon4.93 mL5 mL
1 tablespoon14.79 mL15 mL
1 fluid ounce29.57 mL30 mL
1 cup236.6 mL240 mL
1 ounce (weight)28.35 g28 g

The difference between the two cups is 3.4 mL, about 1.4 percent. That is small next to the 106 to 160 gram spread of flour in one cup, and it does not change how a cake turns out. It matters in one place: a converter has to say which cup it uses, and ours does (converter).

Dry cups, liquid cups and spoons

US kitchens use two kinds of cup for the same unit. A dry measuring cup is filled to the rim and leveled. A liquid measuring cup is clear, with marks below a spout, so liquid can be filled to a line without spilling. NIST names using a dry cup for liquid, or a liquid cup for dry ingredients, as a common way of introducing measurement errors. For liquids, NIST says to set the cup on a level surface and read the curved surface of the liquid, the meniscus, at eye level. For dry ingredients, it says to strike off the excess with a straight edge (Culinary Measurement Tips, above).

Measuring spoons work the same way as dry cups: fill, then level. A heaped teaspoon of baking soda is not a teaspoon. Small amounts carry the most weight per mistake, because leaveners and salt are measured in teaspoons and change a bake out of proportion to their size.

Go deeper

Recipes from other countries

NIST notes that customary cups and spoons mean different things in different countries, and that metric cups are slightly larger than US cups (Culinary Measurement Tips, above). A recipe from the UK, Australia or elsewhere that measures in cups may be using a different cup from yours, and the recipe often does not say which. NIST's suggestion for any recipe you want to keep is to measure it once with the tools it names and weigh the result in grams, so the next time you bake it the units do not matter. If a recipe already gives grams, use the grams; they mean the same thing everywhere. Convention

We have not found an agency source that gives each country's cup and spoon sizes, so this manual does not print a table of them.

Flour by volume: spoon and level

Without a scale, spoon-and-level is the method that gets closest to what most US recipe writers mean by "1 cup flour." King Arthur's figure for it is about 120 grams a cup (How to measure flour, above). One practitioner's method

  1. Fluff the flour in its bag or canister with a spoon or whisk, to loosen what has settled.
  2. Spoon it into a dry measuring cup until it mounds above the rim. Do not shake or tap the cup, and do not press the flour down.
  3. Level it with the back of a knife or another straight edge, sweeping across the rim.

Spoon-and-level has a cost: it is slower than scooping, and it is still a volume. Two careful people spooning the same flour will not land on the same gram figure, and the same person will drift from day to day. It narrows the spread; it does not remove it. That is why the Start here steps ask you to write the gram figure beside the cup, so the recipe card says what you meant.

The common alternative is dip and sweep: push the cup into the flour, lift it full and level it. It is quicker and it compresses the flour, so a dipped cup weighs more than a spooned one. Some recipe writers measure that way on purpose. If a recipe says how its flour was measured, do it that way; if it gives grams, the method stops mattering.

Liquids, and the sticky exception

Water, milk and oil pour level and do not pack, so a liquid cup read at eye level is a reasonable measure. Weighing still helps with sticky syrups. A cup of honey weighs about 339 g by USDA's figure, more than a cup of water, and some of it stays in the cup when you pour. Setting the bowl on a scale and pouring the honey in until the display reaches the weight removes the scraping. USDA gives molasses at 337 g a cup, light corn syrup at 341 g and maple syrup at 315 g (FoodData Central, above).

Weighing with a scale

NIST recommends a digital kitchen scale for home cooking and gives the guidance behind it (NIST, Cookware and Tools):

  • Capacity. NIST calls a 5 kg capacity a common choice for home cooking. Count the bowl: capacity is the gross weight, bowl plus everything in it. A heavy stoneware bowl can use up a good part of a small scale's range.
  • Tare. Press zero, or tare, before each new ingredient. Tare sets the display to zero with the bowl and whatever is already in it on the platform, so the next number you see is only the next ingredient.
  • Do not mix on the scale. NIST advises against mixing in a bowl while it sits on the scale. Weigh in, then lift the bowl off to stir or beat.

Weighing into the bowl

  1. Turn the scale on with nothing on it, then set the empty bowl on the platform.
  2. Press tare. The display reads 0.
  3. Add the first ingredient until the display shows its weight. Spoon flour in rather than pouring from a heavy bag, so you can stop on the number.
  4. Press tare again and add the next ingredient. Repeat for each one.
  5. If you overshoot, spoon the extra out while the bowl is still on the scale. King Arthur's 5-gram tolerance (above) is a reasonable target for flour and sugar.

Grams, not ounces, for small amounts

Weigh in grams when the scale offers both. One ounce is about 28 grams (NIST), so a gram is a much finer step than an ounce, and recipe arithmetic in whole numbers is easier. A teaspoon of baking soda weighs about 4.6 g by USDA's figure; King Arthur gives half a teaspoon as 3 g. Whether your scale can tell 4 g from 5 g is a question for its manual, which states the smallest step the display shows. For a teaspoon or less of leavener, salt or yeast, a level measuring spoon is often as close as a household scale. Test it

We found no agency or extension figure for how accurate household kitchen scales are. NIST's page gives capacity and tare guidance but no accuracy or resolution figure. So this manual does not tell you a scale is accurate to a gram; it tells you to read your scale's manual and to cross-check it once, below.

Go deeper

Checking a scale

No source we found gives a procedure for checking a home kitchen scale. Our cross-check, labeled as ours: NIST says water weighs about 1 gram per milliliter, and uses that to measure pan volumes by weighing water. Fill a liquid measuring cup to its 1-cup line at eye level, weigh it, empty it, and weigh the empty cup. The difference should be near 237 g (the customary cup is 236.6 mL). It will not be exact, because a liquid cup's line is itself approximate and the water's temperature changes its weight slightly. A result far from 237 g, say 210 or 260, is a reason to replace the batteries, read the manual, or try a second scale. Test it

A scale that reads differently when the bowl sits on a different part of the platform, or that drifts away from zero with nothing on it, is a reason for the same steps.

Converting a recipe from cups to grams

NIST's advice for turning a traditional American recipe into weights is direct: measure the ingredient with the traditional tool, then weigh it (Culinary Measurement Tips, above). That gives you your own cup, filled your own way, in grams. Until you have done that, a published chart is the next best thing, and the charts disagree.

Our ingredient weights page shows two charts side by side for every row: USDA's measured household portions and King Arthur's chart. The converter shows both results and the difference. We show both because the difference is the point. A few rows:

Ingredient, 1 cupUSDA SR LegacyKing ArthurDifference
All-purpose flour125 g120 g5 g
Bread flour137 g120 g17 g
Cake flour137 g ("unsifted, dipped")120 g17 g
Whole wheat flour120 g113 g7 g
Granulated sugar200 g198 g2 g
Brown sugar, packed220 g213 g7 g
Butter, 1/2 cup (1 stick)113 g113 g0 g
Milk244 g227 g17 g

Sources: USDA FoodData Central SR Legacy portion weights; King Arthur Baking, Ingredient Weight Chart.

Two things explain most of the gaps. USDA's cake flour was dipped, not spooned, and dipping packs the cup. King Arthur's liquids are 8 ounces a cup, a rounding to the fluid ounce, while USDA's are measured; that is why milk differs by 17 g. Butter and sugar barely differ, because they do not pack the way flour does.

Which figure to use

Our default, for a US recipe that does not say how its flour was measured: write King Arthur's spooned figure (120 g a cup of all-purpose) and USDA's measured portion (125 g) on the card, bake with one of them, and note which. If the recipe's publisher gives its own grams-per-cup figure anywhere, use that one; it describes the writer's cup. If the recipe says "scooped" or "dip and sweep," expect the writer's cup to be heavier than either chart, and weigh your own dipped cup. Convention

Eggs by weight

Eggs come in USDA size classes, set by minimum weight per dozen, in the shell (USDA AMS, Shell Egg Standards, section 56.218):

Size classMinimum per dozen (shell)Edible part of one egg (USDA SR Legacy)
Jumbo30 oz63 g
Extra large27 oz56 g
Large24 oz50 g
Medium21 oz44 g
Small18 oz38 g
Peewee15 ozno figure

US recipes usually mean large eggs. A large egg's edible part is about 50 g by USDA's figure (King Arthur gives the same), of which about 33 g is white and 17 g yolk. The class is a minimum for the dozen, not a weight for each egg; the standard lets 3.3 percent of the eggs in a lot fall into the next lower class. If you have extra-large eggs and a recipe calls for 4 large, weigh 200 g of beaten egg rather than counting. Fat, sugar, eggs and liquid covers what eggs do in a batter. Convention

Go deeper

The two charts, row by row

The full comparison is on the ingredient weights page, with a filter. The larger gaps beyond the table above: self-rising flour 125 g (USDA) against 113 g (King Arthur); powdered sugar 120 g unsifted or 100 g sifted (USDA) against 113 g unsifted (King Arthur); vegetable oil 218 g against 198 g; buttermilk 245 g against 227 g; light corn syrup 341 g against 312 g; baking powder 4.6 g a teaspoon against 4 g. Honey (21 g a tablespoon) and a large egg (50 g) agree. USDA's SR Legacy is a frozen 2018 release that USDA no longer updates; King Arthur's chart is undated.

Convert a whole recipe once

Pick one recipe you bake often. Measure every ingredient your usual way, with the cups and spoons, and weigh each one before it goes into the bowl. Write the grams on a recipe card. Bake it from the grams the next time and compare. If the two bakes match, the card is your recipe from then on, and the cups no longer matter.

Baker's percentages

Bread recipes, and many professional ones, are written as baker's percentages: every ingredient is given as a percentage of the flour's weight, and the flour is 100 percent. King Arthur Baking's professional reference uses this example, in pounds (King Arthur Baking, Baker's Percentage): Convention

IngredientKing Arthur's exampleBaker's percentageThe same formula at 500 g of flour
Flour50 lb100%500 g
Water33 lb66%330 g
Salt1 lb2%10 g
Yeast0.6 lb1.2%6 g
Total84.6 lb169.2%846 g

The percentages add up to more than 100, and that is expected: they are not shares of the dough, they are each ingredient compared with the flour. The last column is our arithmetic: each percentage times 500 g.

Hydration

Hydration is the liquid in a dough as a percentage of the flour's weight. King Arthur's example is a 66 percent hydration dough: 66 parts water to 100 parts flour. Hydration is the single number bakers use to compare how wet two doughs are. Yeast bread uses it, and so does a sourdough starter, which King Arthur feeds at equal weights of flour and water, 100 percent hydration (King Arthur Baking, sourdough feeding ratios).

Why percentages need weights

A percentage of the flour is only as good as the flour's weight. Take a loaf written as 3 cups of flour and 1 1/4 cups of water. At King Arthur's 120 g a cup the flour is 360 g; at Clemson's 106 g it is 318 g. With the water at King Arthur's 227 g a cup, about 284 g, the dough is 79 percent hydration by one figure and 89 percent by the other. Same recipe, ten points apart, before anyone has scooped. That is why the baker's percentage calculator asks for grams.

Scaling a recipe from its flour weight

To make more or less of a formula, King Arthur's method is to decide the new flour weight and multiply each percentage by it. At 750 g of flour, the example above becomes 495 g water, 15 g salt and 9 g yeast. Nothing else has to be worked out, and the dough keeps its hydration. The recipe scaler does the arithmetic and also scales a recipe written in cups, by a factor.

Scaling the ingredients does not scale the pan or the time. A double batch in a pan of the same depth takes longer to bake, and a pan swap changes the depth. The oven and the pan covers pan size.

Go deeper

A sweet dough in percentages

Baker's percentages work for any recipe with flour in it, not only bread. As arithmetic practice, here is an enriched dough written as example numbers (not a tested recipe): 500 g flour, 250 g milk, 75 g sugar, 75 g butter, 100 g egg (two large), 8 g salt, 7 g yeast. Divide each by 500: milk 50%, sugar 15%, butter 15%, egg 20%, salt 1.6%, yeast 1.4%. The liquid is the milk plus most of the egg's weight, which is one reason bakers who compare enriched doughs often state milk and eggs separately rather than one hydration figure.

Formulas with a preferment

A preferment is part of the flour, water and yeast mixed hours ahead and added to the final dough; a sourdough starter is one kind. King Arthur describes two ways to write it: count the preferment as one more ingredient at its own percentage, or work out the "overall" baker's percentages by adding the preferment's flour and water back into the totals. The second tells you the true hydration of the finished dough. Yeast bread uses the second when it adds a starter.

See it: one cup, three ways See it

Fictional example

Dana Reyes is fictional, and every fact about her here is invented for this manual. She lives in an apartment near sea level, bakes in a full-size electric oven, and measures with cups and spoons only. Her chocolate chip cookies spread flat and her banana bread is gummy in the center. The cookie recipe, from the back of a chocolate chip bag, calls for 2 1/4 cups of all-purpose flour and does not say how the flour was measured. Dana scoops her flour.

A neighbor lends her a kitchen scale for an afternoon. She weighs one cup of her flour filled three ways, taring the empty cup each time: scooped and leveled, 138 g; spooned and leveled, 121 g; packed down, 157 g.

Known: her three readings; her own spooned cup (121 g) lands within a gram of King Arthur's 120 g figure, and her packed cup inside King Arthur's "up to 160 g." Her scooped cup is 17 g heavier than her spooned one. For 2 1/4 cups, scooping gives about 311 g of flour and spooning about 272 g, a difference of 39 g.

Assumed (Dana's assumption): that the recipe's writer spooned and leveled, at about 120 g a cup. Under that assumption, the recipe means about 270 g, and her scooping has been adding roughly 40 g.

Open: how the writer actually measured (a version of the recipe from the same publisher that gives grams would settle it); and whether the flour played any part in the flat cookies. Her scooped cups put in more flour, not less, so short measure is an unlikely cause of spread under her assumption, but one measurement does not settle a cause. When a bake goes wrong takes the checks in order, and checking the oven comes early in it.

She writes on her recipe card: "Flour 2 1/4 cups, spooned and leveled, about 272 g (my cup: 121 g spooned, 138 g scooped)." She does the same for the banana bread's 1 1/2 cups: about 182 g spooned.

Practice: weigh your own cup Practice

Minimum: one recipe card with the flour spooned and leveled and its gram figure written beside it from the ingredient weights page. No scale is needed for the minimum. Time: 15 minutes for the card; 20 minutes more for the three-way weighing if you have or can borrow a scale. Materials: your flour, a dry measuring cup, a spoon, a knife or straight edge, a recipe you bake, the ingredient weights page, a recipe card, and a kitchen scale if you have one.

  1. Choose one recipe you bake and open a recipe card for it.
  2. Look up each dry ingredient on the ingredient weights page, and write both publishers' gram figures beside the cup amount on the card.
  3. Measure the flour by spoon and level the next time you bake it, and write "spooned and leveled" on the card.
  4. If you have a scale, weigh one cup of your flour three ways: scooped, spooned and leveled, and packed. Tare the empty cup each time. Write the three numbers on the card.
  5. Weigh the recipe's flour into the bowl at the gram figure you chose, and write which figure it was.
Go deeper

Weigh the rest of the recipe. Measure each other ingredient your usual way and weigh it before it goes in. The recipe card then holds a full gram version to bake from next time.

Write a bread formula in percentages. Take any bread recipe that gives grams, divide each ingredient by the flour weight, and write the percentages beside the grams. Check the hydration against the recipe's description of the dough.

Cross-check your scale with a cup of water, as in the checking a scale note above.

Your kitchen Your kitchen

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does the recipe card say how each dry ingredient was measured: weighed, spooned and leveled, or scooped?
  • Is the flour written in grams, with whose figure it is (yours, USDA's or King Arthur's)?
  • If you weighed, did you tare before each ingredient and lift the bowl off to mix?
  • If you weighed one cup three ways, are the three numbers on the card?
  • For a bread recipe, can you state its hydration from the gram weights?

Worked example

Dana's card meets the first four criteria. It says how the flour was measured, gives grams with the source of the figure (her own spooned cup), and records all three of her readings. The hydration criterion does not apply to cookies. The card does not yet show the other dry ingredients by method; the sugar and leaveners are still "1 cup" and "1 tsp" with no note. Adding "leveled" to each spoon line, and the gram figures from the ingredient weights page, finishes it. Her conclusion that she has been adding about 40 g of flour rests on her assumption about the writer's cup; under that assumption it holds, and a gram version of the recipe from its publisher settles it.

Common mistakes

  • Scooping and calling it a cup. A scooped cup of flour can weigh well above a spooned one. Spoon and level, or weigh.
  • Treating one chart as the truth. 120 g is King Arthur's figure for its method. If the recipe came from somewhere else, its cup may have been different.
  • Forgetting to tare. The display then shows the bowl plus the flour. Check that the display reads 0 before each ingredient.
  • Mixing with the bowl on the scale. NIST advises against it. Weigh, then lift the bowl off.
  • Measuring kosher salt by the spoon without the brand. Diamond Crystal and Morton differ by half by volume. Weigh it, or follow the brand the recipe names.
  • Scaling a cup recipe by percentages. Percentages need the flour in grams. Convert first.

What is still unresolved

This chapter cannot tell you what an old family recipe's cup weighed; only the person who wrote it, or a bake from it that you like, settles that. It cannot tell you how accurate your scale is; its manual and a cross-check come closest. It does not say why a particular bake failed: measuring is one cause among several, and When a bake goes wrong takes them in order. What each ingredient is doing, and so how much a gram or two matters, is in Flour and gluten, Leaveners and Fat, sugar, eggs and liquid.

Knowledge check and scenario

Two published charts give 120 g and 125 g for a cup of all-purpose flour. Which one is right?
Both, for what they describe. King Arthur's 120 g is its figure for a spooned and leveled cup; USDA's 125 g is a measured household portion. A grams-per-cup figure is a publisher's measure, not a property of flour. If the recipe's own publisher gives a figure, that one describes the writer's cup.
Why does a packed cup of flour weigh more than a spooned one, when the cup is the same size?
Flour is a powder with air between the particles. Packing pushes the air out and fits more flour into the same volume. King Arthur measured up to 160 g packed against about 120 g spooned and leveled.
A recipe says 1 tablespoon of kosher salt. You have the other brand. What do you do?
Weigh it if you can. King Arthur gives Diamond Crystal at 8 g a tablespoon and Morton at 16 g, so a spoon of one is about twice the salt of the other. If the recipe names its brand, weigh to that brand's figure.
A dough has 400 g flour and 300 g water. What is its hydration, and how much water would 600 g of flour need at the same hydration?
300 ÷ 400 = 75 percent. At 600 g of flour, 75 percent is 450 g of water.
(Go deeper) Why might a UK recipe that measures in cups come out differently from a US one?
NIST notes that cups and spoons mean different things in different countries, and that metric cups are slightly larger than US cups. The recipe may assume a different cup. Measuring it once with the named tools and weighing the result gives you grams that mean the same everywhere.
A friend's banana bread recipe calls for 2 cups of flour. You have a scale. Your friend scoops. What do you weigh?
King Arthur's figure is for a spooned and leveled cup. A scooped cup is usually heavier, so 240 g may be noticeably less flour than your friend uses. It is a reasonable starting point only if you write down that it is an assumption.
This settles the open question: the writer's own cup, in grams. Write the figure and its source on your recipe card. It still leaves the oven and the bananas, which a scale does not settle.
A good approximation if your friend is not available. Your scoop and theirs will not match exactly, so write "my scoop, estimating theirs" on the card and adjust after the first loaf.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.