Butter vs shortening, sugar and eggs: what each does in a batter or dough
Butter, shortening and oil compared by what they do, sugar understood as more than sweetness, eggs weighed by size, liquid and salt placed, and a substitute chosen by the job the missing ingredient was doing.
- Start here: the essentials
- Fat: butter, shortening, oil and lard
- Sugar: more than sweetness
- Eggs: sizes, weights and jobs
- Liquid, dairy and salt
- Substituting by function
- See it: a cookie exchange and half a recipe
- Practice: name the jobs in one recipe
- Your kitchen
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
For a first pass, read one recipe for what its fat, sugar, eggs and liquid are doing, and write down any change you make. When something is missing, the job it was doing decides the substitute.
- Read what fat your recipe uses, and whether it should be cold, soft or melted. The state of the fat is part of the method (fat).
- Weigh the eggs, or note their size. USDA sizes differ by weight, and a recipe usually means large (eggs).
- If you are missing an ingredient, look it up by what it was doing. The substitutions page is arranged that way (substituting by function).
- Write any change on the recipe card. Use the recipe cards, with what the original ingredient was doing.
Minimum time: 15 minutes with one recipe. Done when: the recipe card lists each change made and what the original ingredient was doing.
Fat: butter, shortening, oil and lard Understand
Fat does four jobs in a bake. It tenderizes, by coating flour and interrupting gluten. It carries flavor. It helps browning. And, depending on its state, it either traps air (solid fat beaten with sugar), makes layers (cold pieces that melt in the oven and release steam), or does neither (melted fat or oil) (Iowa State AnswerLine, How the Cookie Crumbles; Iowa State AnswerLine, Pie Baking). Physical principle Flour and gluten covers the gluten side.
The fats compared
| Fat | What it is | What it does in a bake | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Butter | At least 80% milkfat by federal law; the rest mostly water | Flavor and browning; melts sooner than shortening, so cookies spread farther and come out thinner and crisper | 21 U.S.C. 321a; Exploratorium |
| Shortening | 100% fat, no water, higher melting point | Cookies rise higher and hold their shape; dough has to get hotter before it spreads | Iowa State; Exploratorium |
| Oil | Liquid fat, 100% fat | Traps no air when mixed; cookies denser and flatter | Iowa State |
| Lard | Rendered pork fat, 100% fat | A solid fat; CSU lists it as a butter substitute | USDA FoodData Central; CSU Extension |
| Melted butter | Butter, liquid | Traps no air; cookies denser, flatter, chewier | Iowa State |
Sources: 21 U.S.C. 321a, "Butter" defined; Exploratorium, How do different fats affect the texture of cookies?; Iowa State AnswerLine; USDA FoodData Central SR Legacy; CSU Extension. Weights per cup are on the ingredient weights page.
Butter
Butter, by a 1923 federal law still in force, is made only from milk or cream, with or without salt and coloring, and contains at least 80 percent milkfat by weight. Salted and unsalted butter meet the same floor. USDA measured both at about 81 g of fat and 16 g of water per 100 g (USDA FoodData Central SR Legacy). Iowa State gives butter as at least 80 percent fat and 16 to 18 percent water. That water matters: it turns to steam in the oven, and it is why butter and shortening do not swap gram for gram.
European-style butter has no federal definition in the US. The European Union's own definition of butter is a milkfat content of at least 80 percent and under 90 percent, with no more than 16 percent water (Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013, Annex VII). So the legal floor in the EU is also 80 percent. Butters sold as European-style often carry more fat than that, but the figure is the maker's choice, not a legal one; read it on the label. Product-specific A higher-fat butter has less water, which a recipe written for ordinary butter did not plan for.
Salted or unsalted
Iowa State calls unsalted butter the baking standard, and says salted butter can stand in for most cookies. The difference is real: USDA gives salted butter 643 mg of sodium per 100 g, against 11 mg for unsalted. Our default is unsalted, so that the recipe's salt is the salt in the bake. If you use salted, consider cutting some of the recipe's added salt; no source we read gives an amount, so that is a judgment you test. Preference
Cold, soft or melted
The recipe's word for the fat's state is an instruction about the method, not about convenience.
| The recipe says | What it means | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Cold butter, cut in | Firm from the refrigerator, in small pieces | Pea-size pieces melt in the oven and release steam that lifts layers apart (Iowa State, Pie Baking). Pie crust, biscuits, scones. |
| Softened, room-temperature butter | Cool and pliable, holding a dent when pressed | Solid fat creamed with sugar traps air (Iowa State). King Arthur Baking gives 68 to 70 °F (20 to 21 °C) for creaming. Butter cakes, most cookies. |
| Melted butter | Fully liquid, usually cooled a little | No air trapped; denser, chewier results (Iowa State). Some cookies, brownies, many quick breads. |
| Oil | Liquid at room temperature | Coats flour without trapping air. Many muffins and quick breads. |
Temperature covers checking butter and other ingredients, and Cookies, muffins and biscuits covers the creaming method itself.
Changing the fat's state changes the bake. Melting butter that was meant to be creamed loses the air the method depends on; softening butter meant to be cut in loses the layers. When a recipe gives you the state, keep it.
How much fat
All fats tenderize. The Exploratorium suggests that for a firmer cookie you can reduce the fat by 25 percent, or by 50 percent for firmer still. That is a cookie adjustment from one source, and it changes spread and flavor too. Log it as a change. Test it
The 82 percent claim
Many practitioner and press pages say European butter must legally be 82 percent fat. The EU regulation we read says at least 80 percent and under 90 percent. We read it in its 2013 adopted text; the consolidated version was not available at the address we tried, so a later amendment to that row is possible but not one we found. Some brands choose a higher figure; the label on the butter you buy is the figure for it.
Butter's water, in numbers
If butter is about 81 percent fat and 16 percent water, a 113 g stick holds about 18 g of water. Replacing it with 113 g of shortening, which has none, takes that water out of the dough, and adds about 21 g more fat. CSU's substitution for 1 cup of butter, 7/8 to 1 cup of shortening plus 1/2 teaspoon of salt, uses a little less shortening by volume and puts the salt back. That reasoning is our arithmetic on USDA's figures.
Sugar: more than sweetness
Take the sugar out of a cookie and you lose more than sweetness. Kansas State University's food science text calls sugar the most important tenderizing agent in baked goods (Kansas State University, Functions of Sugar). Physical principle
The jobs sugar does
- Tenderizes. Sugar holds water and delays gluten formation (Kansas State; Iowa State).
- Keeps a bake moist. Sugar is hygroscopic: it attracts and holds water (Iowa State).
- Controls spread. More white sugar gives thinner, crisper cookies that spread more (Iowa State). Kansas State names sugar as one factor in cookie spread.
- Traps air. Creamed with solid fat, sugar crystals help beat air into the fat (Iowa State).
- Browns. By caramelization and by the Maillard reaction, below.
- Feeds yeast. Sugar feeds yeast and speeds leavening (Kansas State), though a lot of it slows yeast down; Leaveners has Red Star's figure.
- Holds up a foam. In angel food, sugar raises the temperature at which the batter sets, giving the foam more time to rise; cutting it lowers the volume (Exploratorium, Why is my angel food cake such a flop?).
Two kinds of browning
Caramelization is sugar alone breaking down under heat. The Maillard reaction is sugars reacting with proteins (their amino groups) under heat (Kansas State). Both brown a bake and make flavor, and they are different reactions.
Les Copeland, a professor of agriculture at the University of Sydney, gives the conditions: Maillard reactions run fastest at low moisture and above about 130 °C (about 266 °F), which is why a crust browns and steamed bread does not; boiling and steaming reach only about 100 °C (212 °F). Caramel color is made by heating sugars to about 160 °C (320 °F) (The Conversation, Kitchen science). So the dry outside of a bake browns while its moist inside stays pale. Eggs and milk add protein for the Maillard reaction; sugar adds fuel for both.
Kinds of sugar
| Sugar | What it is | In a bake | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Granulated (white) | Sucrose crystals | Crisper, thinner cookies with more spread; aerates fat when creamed | Iowa State |
| Brown, light or dark | White sugar with molasses, on or added to the crystals; dark has more | Holds more moisture: moister, chewier, denser. Slightly acidic, so it reacts with baking soda | Sugar Association; Iowa State |
| Powdered (confectioners') | Ground, sifted granulated sugar with about 3% cornstarch | Frostings and glazes; dissolves fast | Sugar Association |
| Honey | A liquid sugar, acidic (pH 3.9) | Adds moisture and browns faster; needs a recipe change to replace sugar | CSU Extension; Clemson Extension |
| Molasses | The syrup left from sugar refining; acidic (pH 5.0 to 5.5) | Color, flavor, moisture; reacts with soda | Clemson Extension; CSU Extension |
| Corn syrup | A liquid sugar | CSU limits it to half the sugar when replacing granulated | CSU Extension |
Sources: The Sugar Association, Types of Sugar (a trade association of US sugar producers); Iowa State AnswerLine; CSU Extension, Ingredient Substitutions; Clemson Extension's pH table. We found no maker page giving the share of molasses in light or dark brown sugar.
Brown sugar is measured packed, and the two publishers in this manual weigh a packed cup at 220 g (USDA) and 213 g (King Arthur Baking). Granulated sugar is 200 g and 198 g. The ingredient weights page carries both.
We make no claim about sugar and health. This chapter is about what sugar does in the bake.
Reducing the sugar, and what it changes
Every job in the list above moves when the sugar goes down. A cookie with less sugar spreads less, browns less and is less tender; a cake may be drier and firmer; a foam cake loses volume (Exploratorium). No source we read gives a safe percentage to cut by. If you cut sugar, change nothing else in that bake, and log the result. Test it
Invert sugar
The Sugar Association describes 50 percent invert sugar as half sucrose, a quarter glucose and a quarter fructose, made by splitting some of the sucrose. It is sweeter than sucrose and holds more moisture.
Making your own
Brown sugar: 1 cup of granulated sugar plus 1/4 cup of unsulphured molasses (CSU). Powdered sugar: 1 cup of granulated sugar blended with 1 tablespoon of cornstarch (Sugar Association).
Eggs: sizes, weights and jobs
Eggs bind a batter, set into structure as their proteins cook, add lift as a foam or as steam, and the yolk's fat tenderizes (Iowa State; Exploratorium, The Amazing Multi-Tasking Egg). Egg whites are about 88 percent water and yolks nearly 50 percent, so eggs are also a large share of a batter's liquid (Exploratorium). Physical principle
Sizes are weight classes
US egg sizes are set by the minimum weight of a dozen, not by the look of one egg. The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) standard:
| Size | Minimum per dozen, in shell | Edible part of one egg, measured |
|---|---|---|
| Jumbo | 30 oz | 63 g |
| Extra large | 27 oz | 56 g |
| Large | 24 oz | 50 g |
| Medium | 21 oz | 44 g |
| Small | 18 oz | 38 g |
| Peewee | 15 oz | No figure |
Sources: USDA Agricultural Marketing Service, Shell Egg Standards, section 56.218 (minimum weights per dozen); USDA FoodData Central SR Legacy (edible portion of one raw egg). The two are different measures: the first is the shell egg by the dozen, the second the egg out of its shell.
The steps between sizes are about 6 g each. In a recipe with three eggs, extra-large in place of large adds about 18 g of egg; jumbo adds about 39 g. That is enough to change a cake's texture. Our default reads "egg" in a recipe as a large egg, about 50 g out of the shell, which is the size both King Arthur Baking's chart and USDA's figures give for one egg; if a recipe gives a weight, use the weight. Convention
The large egg's 50 g splits into about 33 g of white and 17 g of yolk, by USDA's figures. To use part of an egg, beat it and weigh what you need: half a large egg is 25 g.
Raw eggs and safety
Raw and lightly cooked eggs can carry Salmonella. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) says egg mixtures are safe once they reach 160 °F (71 °C), and that egg dishes should be cooked to that temperature (FSIS, Shell Eggs from Farm to Table). In a cake, cookie or bread, the egg is baked through with the rest. The places a baker meets raw or barely cooked egg are frostings, mousses, some pie fillings and the dough itself.
FSIS advises avoiding icings made with uncooked eggs or egg whites, and using pasteurized eggs or egg products where a recipe calls for raw eggs. Cook custards and egg-based fillings to 160 °F (71 °C). Do not leave eggs or egg dishes out more than 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90 °F (32 °C) (FDA, Egg Safety).
- Frostings that are safe by FSIS's list: seven-minute frosting made by pouring hot sugar syrup into beaten whites, and dry meringue shells. Meringue-topped pies should be safe baked at 350 °F (177 °C) for about 15 minutes, FSIS says.
- Pasteurized eggs are treated by processors with an FDA-accepted method and sold in some stores. FSIS says shell eggs are not practical to pasteurize at home.
- Storage: refrigerate eggs at 40 °F (4 °C) or below, in the carton (FDA). FSIS advises against washing eggs at home.
Temperature covers reading a custard or cheesecake with a thermometer, and Pie and pastry covers custard pies.
White and yolk: two publishers
For one large egg, USDA gives 33 g of white and 17 g of yolk; King Arthur Baking gives 30 to 35 g of white and 14 g of yolk. Both give 50 g for the whole egg. If a recipe calls for yolks or whites by count and you are scaling it, weigh them; the recipe scaler gives eggs as a count and in grams.
Egg sizes by the case
The AMS standard also gives minimums per 30 dozen and a 3.3 percent lot tolerance: a carton labeled large may hold a few eggs from the next size down. Weighing the beaten egg settles it for a recipe where it matters.
Liquid, dairy and salt
Liquid wets the flour so gluten can form, dissolves sugar and salt, lets baking soda and powder react, and becomes steam in the oven (Modernist Cuisine, Gluten; Arm & Hammer; Exploratorium). Physical principle Butter and eggs carry liquid too, which is why changing one of them changes how wet the batter is.
Water, milk and buttermilk
- Water is the plain liquid of lean bread doughs.
- Milk adds protein, sugar and fat, so a milk dough browns more and is softer. That follows from the browning reactions above; it is our reasoning, not a measured claim.
- Buttermilk, yogurt and sour cream are acidic. Arm & Hammer lists buttermilk, yogurt and sour cream among the acids that react with baking soda, which is why recipes that use them usually include soda. Leaveners covers the pairing.
By weight, USDA gives a cup of whole milk as 244 g and buttermilk as 245 g, measured. King Arthur Baking gives 227 g for each, which is 8 ounces, a rounding. For a recipe written in cups either is fine; for one written in grams, use the recipe's figure. The ingredient weights page carries both.
When the dairy is missing
| Missing | Substitute | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1 cup buttermilk | 1 tbsp lemon juice or vinegar, plus milk to make 1 cup; let it sit 5 minutes | Illinois Extension |
| 1 cup sour cream | 7/8 cup buttermilk or sour milk, or 1 cup yogurt | CSU Extension |
| 1 cup milk | 1/3 cup instant nonfat dry milk plus 1 cup water; or 1/2 cup evaporated milk plus 1/2 cup water | Illinois Extension |
| 1 cup heavy cream, for baking (it will not whip) | 1/3 cup butter plus 3/4 cup milk | Illinois Extension |
Sources: Illinois Extension, Substitutions for Common Ingredients; CSU Extension, Ingredient Substitutions.
Salt
Salt seasons a bake, and in a yeast dough it does two more jobs: Red Star Yeast says it controls the rate of yeast action and strengthens gluten (Red Star, FAQ). King Arthur Baking's professional reference uses 2 percent of the flour's weight as the salt in a lean bread; Measuring explains baker's percentages.
Salt is where measuring by volume fails worst. A tablespoon of table salt weighs 18 g by both USDA and King Arthur, but King Arthur gives a tablespoon of Diamond Crystal kosher salt as 8 g and Morton kosher salt as 16 g (King Arthur Baking, Ingredient Weight Chart). A recipe that says "1 tablespoon kosher salt" means very different amounts depending on the box. Product-specific Our default is to use the salt the recipe names, or weigh it if the recipe gives grams. If you swap table salt for a kosher salt by volume, convert by weight first.
Substituting by function
A substitution goes wrong when it replaces the name of an ingredient instead of its job. Butter and oil are both fat, but only one of them can be creamed. Buttermilk and milk are both liquid, but only one of them is an acid for the soda. So we choose a substitute in four moves.
- Name the jobs. What was the missing ingredient doing? Use the sections above: fat tenderizes, traps air or makes layers; sugar sweetens, tenderizes, browns and spreads; eggs bind, set, lift and add liquid; buttermilk is liquid and acid.
- Pick the job that matters most in this bake. In a creamed cookie, butter's main job is trapping air and setting the spread; in a muffin, oil's job is tenderness.
- Find a substitute that does that job, from the table below or the substitutions page.
- Accept what changes, and write it down. Every substitute changes something. Write the change and the original ingredient's job on the recipe card.
| Missing | Its main jobs | Substitute | What changes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 cup butter | Tenderness, air when creamed, flavor, spread | 7/8 to 1 cup shortening plus 1/2 tsp salt | Less spread, taller cookies; less butter flavor | CSU; Exploratorium |
| 1 cup butter | Same | 7/8 cup lard plus 1/2 tsp salt | Different flavor; a solid fat, so it can still cut in or cream | CSU |
| 1 cup butter, in a melted-butter recipe | Tenderness, flavor | 7/8 cup oil plus 1/2 tsp salt | No butter flavor; not for creaming or for layers | CSU; Iowa State |
| 1 egg, as a binder | Binding | 1 tbsp ground flax or chia plus 3 tbsp water, left 5 minutes | Flavor and texture may be slightly altered | Illinois |
| 1 egg, for lift | Leavening | 1 1/2 tbsp water plus 1 1/2 tbsp oil plus 1 tsp baking powder | Same caution | Illinois |
| 1 egg, for moisture | Liquid, tenderness | 1/4 cup mashed banana, applesauce, pumpkin or silken tofu | Adds that ingredient's flavor; denser | Illinois |
| 1 cup brown sugar | Moisture, chew, acid for soda | 1 cup granulated plus 1/4 cup unsulphured molasses | Close to the original | CSU |
| 1 cup sugar | Sweetness, tenderness | 13/16 cup honey (1 cup less 3 tbsp); cut liquid by 3 tbsp per cup of honey; add a pinch of soda | Browns faster, moister, honey flavor | CSU |
| 1 cup buttermilk | Liquid and acid | 1 tbsp lemon juice or vinegar, plus milk to 1 cup | Close to the original | Illinois |
Sources: CSU Extension, Ingredient Substitutions; Illinois Extension, Substitutions for Common Ingredients (modified December 2024); Exploratorium; Iowa State AnswerLine. Leavener swaps are in Leaveners, flour swaps in Flour and gluten.
A substitute that does one job does not do the others. Flax binds but does not foam; applesauce adds moisture but does not set into structure; oil tenderizes but does not cream. When a recipe leans on an ingredient for several jobs, as a sponge cake leans on its eggs, no single substitute we found stands in, and a recipe written without that ingredient is the better start. Convention
This chapter makes no health claim for any fat or sugar and gives no diet advice; it says what an ingredient does in the bake. The egg substitutes above are substitutions that change the bake. They are not advice for anyone with an egg allergy: whether a food is safe for someone with an allergy is for that person, or their caregiver, to decide with a clinician. If you bake for someone with an allergy, ask them what they need, list what went into the bake, and say what else your kitchen handles. Ask the authority
The allergen card in the occasion plan records what each bake contains. Baking ahead and for an occasion covers labeling for a gift or a bake sale.
See it: a cookie exchange and half a recipe See it
Ruth Adeyemi is fictional, and every fact about her here is invented for this manual. She bakes eight dozen cookies of three kinds for a December cookie exchange. Her grandson has a peanut allergy. On the morning of the bake, her brown sugar cookie recipe calls for 1 cup of softened butter, creamed with the sugar, and 2 large eggs. She has 3/4 cup of butter, a can of shortening, and a carton of extra-large eggs.
Known: the butter's job here is to cream with the sugar, trapping air, and to set how far the cookies spread. Shortening is a solid fat, so it can still cream. CSU gives 7/8 to 1 cup of shortening plus 1/2 teaspoon of salt for 1 cup of butter, so for the missing 1/4 cup she uses 1/4 cup of shortening and a pinch, about 1/8 teaspoon, of salt. The Exploratorium and Iowa State both say shortening melts at a higher temperature, so the cookies will spread a little less and stand a little taller. For the eggs, USDA's figures put 2 large eggs at about 100 g out of the shell; she beats 2 extra-large eggs and weighs out 100 g.
Assumed (Ruth's assumption): that a quarter of the fat as shortening changes the cookies only a little. Under that assumption, the batch will look like her usual ones.
Open: how much less they spread with a quarter shortening (her first tray settles it, and she can flatten the rest slightly before baking if she wants the usual look); and what her grandson can eat from the exchange table. That is for him and his parents to decide. Ruth's part is to list what each of her three cookies contains, including the peanut butter cookies, on the allergen card in the occasion plan, and to say that all three were made in the same kitchen.
What she writes on the recipe card: "1/4 cup shortening for 1/4 cup butter (fat: creaming and spread) plus 1/8 tsp salt. Eggs: 100 g beaten extra-large for 2 large (binding, structure)."
Jun Park (fictional) bakes small batches in a countertop oven and halves most recipes. A muffin recipe calls for 1 egg. Known: a large egg is about 50 g out of the shell by USDA's figure, so half is 25 g. Assumed (Jun's): that the recipe means a large egg. Open: nothing the scale does not settle. Jun beats one egg, weighs out 25 g, and keeps the rest covered in the refrigerator for the next morning. The recipe scaler gives the same figure.
- Iowa State AnswerLine, How the Cookie Crumbles: what fat, sugar and eggs each do in a cookie.
- Exploratorium, How do different fats affect the texture of cookies?: butter, margarine and shortening compared by melting point.
- CSU Extension, Ingredient Substitutions: an extension table of swaps for fat, sugar, dairy and leaveners.
- Illinois Extension, Substitutions for Common Ingredients: egg substitutes grouped by the egg's job.
Practice: name the jobs in one recipe Practice
Minimum: one recipe read for its fat, sugar, eggs and liquid, with the job of each written on its recipe card. Time: 15 minutes to read and write; one ordinary bake if you also make it. Materials: a recipe you bake, a kitchen scale if you have one, the recipe cards sheet and the substitutions page.
- Find the fat. Write its kind and its state (cold, softened, melted, oil), and the job that state points to.
- Find the sugars. Write each kind and the job you think it is doing most: spread, moisture, browning, tenderness.
- Find the eggs. Write the count, the size you will use, and the weight it should come to.
- Find the liquid and any acid. If there is buttermilk, yogurt, sour cream, brown sugar or honey, note that the recipe probably uses soda with it.
- Pick one ingredient you might run out of, and write its substitute by job, with what would change.
- If you bake it, weigh the eggs, and write any change you made on the card.
Bake one cookie dough three ways. Divide one batch of a creamed cookie dough into thirds before the fat goes in, if the recipe allows, or make three small batches: one with butter, one with shortening, one with melted butter. Bake a tray of each at the same time and temperature and compare spread, height and texture. Record each in the bake log. Test it
Weigh a carton. Weigh each egg in a carton of large eggs in the shell, and see how far they spread above the standard's minimum.
Your kitchen Your kitchen
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- For your recipe, can you name the fat's state and the job that state does?
- Were the eggs the size the recipe means, or weighed to match?
- Did any substitute do the main job of the ingredient it replaced?
- Is every change written on the recipe card, with the original ingredient's job?
- If you baked for someone with an allergy, did you list what went in rather than decide for them?
Worked example
Ruth's card meets every criterion: the fat's job (creaming and spread) is named, the substitute is a solid fat that can still cream, the eggs were weighed to the large-egg figure, and both changes are written with their jobs. Her allergen card lists what each cookie contains and that they share a kitchen, and leaves the decision to her grandson's family. What she cannot know before baking is how much less the cookies spread; under her assumption it is a little, and her first tray settles it.
Common mistakes
- Melting butter that was meant to be creamed. The air goes, and the cookies come out flatter and denser.
- Swapping kosher salt by the spoon. King Arthur's figures for two brands differ by half. Convert by weight.
- Treating all eggs as one size. Extra-large in place of large in a three-egg cake is about 18 g more egg.
- Replacing an acid ingredient with a neutral one. Milk for buttermilk leaves the soda with nothing to react with. Sour the milk first.
- Expecting one substitute to do every job. Choose the job that matters most, and accept the rest.
- Frosting with raw egg whites. FSIS advises against icings made with uncooked eggs. Use a cooked method or pasteurized whites.
What is still unresolved
This chapter cannot tell you exactly how a substitute will change your recipe; the sources describe directions, not amounts, and a test bake settles it. It does not say how much sugar or fat you can cut before a bake fails. It says nothing about what is healthy, or safe for someone with an allergy; those questions belong to the person and their clinician. Why a particular bake went wrong is in When a bake goes wrong.