Baking substitutions: what the missing ingredient was doing
Reference

Baking substitutions: what the missing ingredient was doing

One row per missing ingredient: the job it did in the bake, the substitute, the amount, what changes, and who publishes the swap. Filter by kind of ingredient or by what your household avoids.

A substitution replaces a job, not an ingredient. Before you swap, ask what the missing ingredient was doing: leavening, building or limiting structure, adding moisture, acid, fat or sweetness. Most rows are from two extension tables: University of Illinois Extension's Substitutions for Common Ingredients (modified December 2024) and Colorado State University Extension's Ingredient Substitutions. Leavener rows add the makers: Arm & Hammer's Baking Soda vs. Baking Powder and Clabber Girl's FAQs. Yeast rows are from Red Star Yeast's Yeast Baking FAQ and Yeast Conversion Chart, Fleischmann's Yeast 101 and FAQ, and King Arthur Baking's Active dry versus instant yeast. "What changes" draws on Iowa State University Extension and Outreach's AnswerLine, How Ingredients Affect "How the Cookie Crumbles" and Meet the Flours. Single rows also cite Iowa State's Natural vs Dutch-process cocoa; the federal flour standards, 21 CFR part 137, and the gluten-free labeling rule, 21 CFR 101.91; Red Star's Tips & Troubleshooting Guide; King Arthur's What protein percentage in flour means and Why are my cookies spreading?; the WSU Bread Lab's Recipes page; Modernist Cuisine's Gluten: How Does It Work?; the Sugar Association's Types of Sugar; USDA's FoodData Central (SR Legacy weights); and Nebraska Extension's 4-H Foods Judging Guide. Where two publishers give different amounts for the same swap, both rows stay.

MissingWhat it was doingSubstituteAmountWhat changesSource
Baking powder, double-actingLeavening: soda plus its own acid, reacting once when wet and again when heated1/4 tsp baking soda + 1/2 tsp cream of tartar (Colorado State adds 1/4 tsp cornstarch)Per 1 tsp baking powderThe mix reacts as soon as it is wet, like soda alone; mix quickly and bake right awayArm & Hammer; Clabber Girl; Colorado State
Baking powder, double-actingLeavening1/4 tsp baking soda + 5/8 tsp cream of tartarPer 1 tsp baking powderAs above; more cream of tartar than the makers' versionIllinois; Colorado State
Baking powderLeavening1/4 tsp baking soda + 1 tsp lemon juice or vinegarPer 1 tsp baking powderReacts at once; Arm & Hammer ranks cream of tartar firstArm & Hammer; Clabber Girl
Baking powderLeavening1/4 tsp baking soda + 1/2 cup buttermilk, sour milk or yogurtPer 1 tsp baking powder; cut the recipe's liquid by 1/2 cupTangier; reacts at onceColorado State
Baking powderLeavening1/4 tsp baking soda + 1/4 cup molassesPer 1 tsp baking powder; cut the liquid by 1 to 2 tbspDarker, molasses flavorColorado State
Baking sodaLeavening, and neutralizing the recipe's acidBaking powder3 tsp per 1 tsp baking sodaPowder carries its own acid, so the recipe's acid (buttermilk, brown sugar, natural cocoa) is no longer neutralized; Arm & Hammer calls soda 3 to 4 times as strongArm & Hammer; Clabber Girl
Cream of tartarAcid1 1/2 tsp lemon juice or vinegarPer 1/2 tsp cream of tartarAdds a little liquidIllinois
Dutch-process cocoa, when you have naturalFlavor and color; Dutch cocoa is neutral, so the recipe leavens with powderNatural cocoa, 1:1; replace the baking powder with half that amount of baking sodaCocoa 1:1Sharper flavor, redder color; natural cocoa's acid now feeds the sodaIowa State
Natural cocoa, when you have Dutch-processFlavor, color and acid for the sodaDutch-process cocoa, 1:1; leave out the soda and use an equal to twice the amount of baking powderCocoa 1:1Milder flavor, darker color; with no leavener in the recipe (frosting, sauce) either cocoa worksIowa State
Active dry yeast, when you have instantLeaveningInstant yeast1:1 by weight or volumeRises faster; stir it into the flour rather than dissolving itRed Star; King Arthur Baking
Instant (RapidRise) yeast, when you have active dryLeaveningActive dry yeast, proofed 5 minutes in 100 to 110 °F (38 to 43 °C) liquid25 percent more than the instant amountAdd about 20 minutes to the riseFleischmann's
Active dry yeast, using RapidRise in a recipe written for itLeaveningRapidRise stirred into the dry ingredients, liquids at 120 to 130 °F (49 to 54 °C)Equal amountThe first rise becomes a 10-minute restFleischmann's
Fresh (cake) yeastLeaveningDry yeast: one packet (1/4 oz, 7 g) per 0.6 oz cake; three packets per 2 oz cakePer cake; Red Star's blog gives each third of a 2 oz cake as 0.67 oz (18.9 g)If you proof fresh yeast in 1/2 cup of water, cut the recipe's liquid by 1/2 cup (Red Star)Fleischmann's; Red Star
A packet of dry yeast, measured by spoonLeavening2 1/4 tsp (Red Star, Fleischmann's); "a slightly heaped 2 teaspoons" (King Arthur); 2 1/2 tsp (Colorado State)Per 1/4 oz (7 g) packetWeigh 7 g if you can; the spoon figures differRed Star; Fleischmann's; King Arthur Baking; Colorado State
Cake flourLow protein, so a tender, fine crumbAll-purpose flourColorado State: 1 cup all-purpose = 1 cup + 2 tbsp cake flour, so use 1 cup all-purpose for 1 1/8 cups cake flourMore gluten potential: a less tender, less fine crumbColorado State; Iowa State
All-purpose flour, when you have cake flourStructureCake flour1 cup + 2 tbsp per 1 cup all-purposeMore tender; too little gluten for pie crust (Iowa State's pie basics)Colorado State
Self-rising flourFlour, leavener and salt in oneAll-purpose flour + baking powder + salt1 cup flour + 1 1/4 tsp baking powder + 1/4 tsp salt per cupClose to the original; the federal standard (21 CFR 137.180) defines self-rising flour as flour with soda, an acid phosphate and saltColorado State; FDA (21 CFR part 137)
Bread flourHigh protein: more gluten, a chewier loaf that holds its riseAll-purpose flour, 1:11:1Different texture: a softer, less chewy loaf (Iowa State)Iowa State
Bread flourHigh proteinAll-purpose flour + vital wheat gluten1 tsp vital wheat gluten per cup of all-purposeRed Star's fix for a weak flour that rises and collapsesRed Star
Bleached all-purpose, when you have unbleached (or the reverse)StructureThe other one1:1Iowa State says they can be used interchangeablyIowa State
White bread flour, to add whole grainStructure, flavorWhole grain flourRed Star: replace up to 50 percent, starting at 25 to 30 percentBran and germ interfere with gluten, so whole wheat does not behave like a high-protein white flour (King Arthur)Red Star; King Arthur Baking
All-purpose flour, in ordinary recipes, to bake whole grainStructure, flavorWhole-grain flourThe WSU Bread Lab often swaps it 1:1None stated; a research lab's own practice, not a substitution tableWSU Bread Lab
Wheat flour, for a gluten-free bakeGluten: the stretchy network that holds gas and gives structureNone published as a one-for-one swap in our sourcesNoneWithout wheat's two gluten-forming proteins no gluten network forms (Modernist Cuisine); bake a recipe written gluten-free. FDA's label rule (21 CFR 101.91) names wheat, rye and barley as gluten-containing grainsModernist Cuisine; FDA
ButtermilkAcid for the soda, tenderness, moisture1 tbsp lemon juice or vinegar + milk to make 1 cup; stand 5 minutesPer 1 cupThinner than cultured buttermilkIllinois
MilkMoisture, browning, tendernessInstant nonfat dry milk 1/3 cup + 1 cup water; non-instant 3 tbsp + 1 cup water; or 1/2 cup evaporated milk + 1/2 cup waterPer 1 cupNone statedIllinois
Sour creamAcid, fat and moisture7/8 cup buttermilk or sour milk, or 1 cup yogurtPer 1 cupNone statedColorado State
Heavy cream, for bakingFat and moisture1/3 cup butter + 3/4 cup milkPer 1 cupWill not whipIllinois
Egg, bindingHolding the batter together as its proteins set1 tbsp ground flax or chia + 3 tbsp water, stand 5 minutes; or 1 package plain gelatin + 2 tbsp warm waterPer whole eggFlavor and texture may be slightly altered (Illinois)Illinois
Egg, leaveningLift from whipped or beaten egg and its steam1 1/2 tbsp water + 1 1/2 tbsp oil + 1 tsp baking powder (or the flax or gelatin mixes above)Per whole eggNone stated beyond the note aboveIllinois
Egg, moistureWater and fat in the batter1/4 cup mashed banana, avocado, applesauce, pumpkin, sweet potato, beans or silken tofuPer whole eggAdds the flavor of what you usedIllinois
Egg, moisture (mayonnaise option)Water and fat2 tbsp mayonnaisePer whole eggMayonnaise is usually made with egg, so this row does not serve an egg-free bakeIllinois
Egg, general purposeBinding, moisture, structure2 egg whites, or 1/4 cup commercial egg substitutePer whole eggNone stated; check a commercial substitute's label for eggIllinois
A large egg, when you have another sizeLiquid and protein in a set amountBeat the eggs you have and measure50 g of beaten egg per large egg (USDA; King Arthur), or 3 1/3 tbsp (Colorado State)Matches the recipe; eggs larger than specified can make cookies spread (King Arthur)USDA; King Arthur Baking; Colorado State
Brown sugarSweetness, moisture, a little acidGranulated sugar + unsulphured molasses1 cup sugar + 1/4 cup molasses per cupClose; brown sugar's molasses makes cookies moister and denser and reacts with soda (Iowa State)Colorado State; Iowa State
Granulated sugar, with honeySweetness, tenderness, browning, spreadHoney13/16 cup (1 cup less 3 tbsp) per cup of sugar; cut liquid 3 tbsp per cup of honey; add a pinch of sodaHoney flavor; the liquid and soda changes balance the honey's water and acidColorado State
Granulated sugar, with molassesSweetnessMolasses + baking soda1 cup molasses + 1/2 tsp soda per cup of sugar; cut baking powder by 1 tsp and liquid by 6 tbspDark, strong flavorColorado State
Granulated sugar, with corn syrupSweetnessCorn syrupFor no more than half the sugarColorado State sets the limitColorado State
Powdered (confectioners') sugarFine sweetness for frosting; its starch helps it setGranulated sugar + cornstarch, blended fine1 cup sugar + 1 tbsp cornstarchCommercial powdered sugar carries about 3 percent cornstarchSugar Association
Butter, with shorteningFat for tenderness and flavor; in creaming, it holds airShortening + salt7/8 to 1 cup shortening + 1/2 tsp salt per cup of butterShortening is all fat and melts higher: cookies rise higher and hold their shape; less butter flavorColorado State; Iowa State
Butter, with lardFatLard + salt7/8 cup lard + 1/2 tsp salt per cupDifferent flavor; all fat, no waterColorado State
Butter, with oilFatOil + salt7/8 cup oil + 1/2 tsp salt per cupLiquid fat traps no air: denser, flatter cookies; not for creamingColorado State; Iowa State
Butter in cookies that spread too muchFatShorteningOne-for-one by volume, or half and halfLess spread, less butter flavorKing Arthur Baking
Unsalted butterFat without added saltSalted butter1:1Iowa State: salted can stand in for most cookies; USDA measures salted butter at 643 mg sodium per 100 g, unsalted at 11 mgIowa State; USDA
Unsweetened chocolateCocoa solids and cocoa butterCocoa + butter or other fat3 tbsp cocoa + 1 tbsp fat per 1 ozLeaving out the extra fat makes a cake dry or crumbly (Nebraska Extension's judging table)Colorado State; Nebraska Extension

Leaveners

Baking soda needs an acid in the recipe and reacts once, as soon as it is wet; baking powder carries its own acid. A double-acting powder reacts twice. Clabber Girl's baking powder page puts the split at 30 percent in the bowl and 70 percent in the oven, while Rumford, an aluminum-free powder from the same company, reverses it. Product-specific So a homemade powder of soda and cream of tartar behaves like a fast single-acting powder: mix, pan and bake without a wait.

The cream of tartar figure differs by source. Arm & Hammer and Clabber Girl use 1/2 tsp per 1/4 tsp soda, as does Colorado State's three-part version with cornstarch; Illinois and Colorado State's two-part version use 5/8 tsp. Both are published figures and either is a reasonable starting point; the makers' 1/2 tsp is the one printed on the boxes' own pages. Convention To check whether your soda and powder are still active, use the soda check. Why soda and powder are not interchangeable is in Leaveners.

Yeast types swap more easily. Red Star and King Arthur use instant and active dry one for one; Fleischmann's uses 25 percent more active dry when it replaces instant. Teaspoons per packet differ by source, so weigh 7 g when you can. The yeast converter does the arithmetic.

Flour

Flour swaps change gluten, the network two wheat proteins form with water. More protein means more gluten potential and a chewier result; less means a more tender one. Iowa State gives all-purpose flour as 9 to 12 percent protein, bread flour 12 to 14 and cake flour 7 to 8, and says brands blend differently, so one label's figure is not another's. Product-specific There is no federal standard naming bread, cake, pastry or all-purpose flour; the standards in 21 CFR part 137 cover flour, enriched flour, self-rising flour and whole wheat flour. A federal rule allowing salt substitutes in standardized foods takes effect on 2026-12-14 and amends the self-rising flour standard. More in Flour and gluten.

Dairy

Buttermilk and sour cream bring acid as well as liquid, and in a recipe leavened with baking soda that acid is part of the rise. A swap that keeps the acid (milk soured with lemon juice or vinegar, yogurt for sour cream) keeps the soda working. A swap to plain milk does not. Physical principle We found no extension or agency table for non-dairy milks in baking, so this page lists none; the butter rows tagged No dairy are the dairy-free swaps our sources publish.

Eggs

An egg binds, leavens and moistens, and Illinois groups its egg swaps by that job, which is why the egg rows split three ways. Choose the row for the job the egg did in your recipe. For a recipe whose lift comes from whipped eggs, such as angel food or sponge cake, we would look for a recipe written without eggs rather than swap. Preference What eggs do is in Fat, sugar, eggs and liquid.

Sugar

Sugar sweetens, tenderizes, browns and controls spread, and liquid sweeteners also add water and acid, which is why Colorado State's honey and molasses rows cut liquid and add soda. Brown sugar is white sugar with molasses; the Sugar Association says dark has more molasses than light, but no maker page we read gives the percentage. A sugar swap changes texture more than any other on this page, so try it in one batch first. Test it

Fat

US butter is at least 80 percent milk fat by federal definition (21 U.S.C. 321a), and Iowa State gives the rest as 16 to 18 percent water. Shortening and lard are all fat. That water and the lower melting point are why butter cookies spread more, and why the Colorado State rows use 7/8 cup of a pure fat for a cup of butter. Physical principle Oil cannot be creamed, so it suits recipes mixed by the muffin or one-bowl method, not creamed ones. The methods are in Cookies, muffins, quick breads and biscuits.

Limits

The No eggs, No dairy and No gluten tags mark rows that leave out that ingredient. They do not make a bake safe for anyone with a food allergy or celiac disease: cross-contact in a shared kitchen, other ingredients and labels all matter, and the person who will eat it, or their caregiver or clinician, decides. Every swap here changes the bake a little, and the publishers say so; bake one batch before an occasion.