How to make flaky pie crust: cold dough, blind baking and fillings
Pie dough mixed cold and rested so the crust is flaky, rolled and fitted without shrinking, how to blind bake a pie crust, fruit fillings thickened, custard pies baked to temperature and refrigerated, and lamination explained.
- Start here: the essentials
- The dough: cold fat, cold water, little work
- Rolling and fitting without shrinking
- Blind baking: when the crust goes in first
- Fruit fillings and their thickeners
- Custard pies: pumpkin, pecan and cream
- Lamination: why puff pastry rises
- See it: two pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving
- Practice: one crust, baked and logged
- Your kitchen
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
For a first pass, make one crust cold, rest it, fit it without stretching, and bake it. A store-bought crust is a fine choice for the filling; this is for the day you make your own.
- Keep the fat, water and bowl cold, and cut the fat in until the largest pieces are about pea-size. (the dough).
- Add water a spoonful at a time until the dough holds, then wrap and chill it. At least 30 minutes.
- Roll it larger than the plate, ease it in without stretching, and chill it again. (rolling and fitting).
- Fill and bake, or blind bake first if the filling is a custard or is not baked. (blind baking).
Minimum time: about 2 hours, most of it chilling and baking. Done when: one crust is baked and the bake log records the fat, the chill time and whether it shrank.
The dough: cold fat, cold water, little work Understand
Pie dough (pastry, or crust) is flour, fat, a little salt and just enough cold water to hold it together. Iowa State University Extension's AnswerLine gives the classic proportion as 3-2-1: three parts flour, two parts fat, one part cold water (Iowa State AnswerLine, Pie Baking: Simple Ingredients and Equipment). Convention King Arthur Baking's double-crust recipe, by weight, comes close to it: 297 g (2 1/2 cups) all-purpose flour, 46 g (1/4 cup) shortening and 142 g (10 tablespoons) butter, with 85 to 142 g (6 to 10 tablespoons) of ice water and 1 1/4 teaspoons of salt (King Arthur Baking, Pie Crust). The range on the water is real: flour and kitchens vary, so the dough, not the recipe, says when there is enough.
Why the fat stays in pieces
Pie dough uses the biscuit method from Cookies, muffins and biscuits: cold fat cut into flour. Iowa State explains the two jobs the fat does. It coats some of the flour, which limits gluten and keeps the crust tender. And the pieces left whole, about the size of peas, melt in the oven and release steam that lifts the dough into flaky layers. Solid fats give a flakier crust than melted or liquid ones, and chilled fat and ice-cold water work best. Physical principle
So the size of the pieces decides the crust:
- Flaky crust: fat left in visible pieces, the largest about pea-size. The pieces become layers. Good under fruit.
- Mealy crust: fat worked in finely, so the mixture looks like coarse meal with no visible pieces. More tender and crumbly, with fewer layers, and it soaks less. Utah 4-H's judging manual lists a dry, mealy crust as the result of shortening cut in too finely, or too little liquid (Utah 4-H, Fair Judges' Manual).
Keep it cold
The Home Baking Association's temperature chart gives 35 to 40 °F (2 to 4 °C) for butter that is being cut in: refrigerator-cold (Home Baking Association, Baking Temperatures). Cube the butter and keep it in the refrigerator until you use it; use ice water; in a warm kitchen, chill the bowl and the flour too. Temperature covers ingredient temperatures in general. If the butter softens and smears while you work, stop and chill the whole bowl for 10 minutes.
Water, then rest
Add the ice water a spoonful at a time, tossing with a fork, until a handful of the shaggy mixture holds together when squeezed. Too much water and too much working build gluten, and King Arthur says both toughen a crust. Gather the dough into a disk, wrap it and chill it. King Arthur's range is 30 minutes to overnight: the rest firms the fat and relaxes the gluten, and the dough rolls more easily and shrinks less. Wrapped dough freezes for up to two months by the same guide.
A store-bought crust is a reasonable choice. It removes the dough from the work, and the filling, the blind bake and the storage rules in the rest of this chapter apply to it the same way. Preference
Do not eat raw pie dough. CDC includes pie crusts in the raw doughs not to eat, because most flour is raw and only baking kills germs such as E. coli and Salmonella (CDC, Raw Flour and Dough). Wash the counter, rolling pin and hands after rolling.
All-butter against shortening, and how big the pieces are
King Arthur's recipe uses both fats on purpose. It works the shortening in until it looks like coarse sand, for structure, since shortening's higher melting point keeps the crimps from slumping. It works the butter in unevenly, leaving pieces dime-sized and smaller, for flakiness: the butter melts after the crust has partly set and leaves spaces. It also folds the shaggy dough in thirds like a letter for more layers. Iowa State's pea-size guide and King Arthur's dime-size pieces describe the same idea at slightly different sizes; we use pea-size as the default because it is the extension figure and it is the safer side against a crust that falls apart. An all-butter crust tastes of butter and browns well, and its crimps soften more in the oven. An all-shortening crust holds its shape and tastes of little. Preference Test it Make one of each and compare.
Vodka and other liquids
Some recipes replace part of the water with vodka, on the reasoning that alcohol forms less gluten than water. We found no extension or practitioner source among those we read that tests it, so we do not recommend it either way.
How long dough keeps frozen
King Arthur says up to two months. NDSU Extension's freezing guide gives unbaked pastry 6 to 8 weeks, and says to bake it frozen at 475 °F (246 °C) until light brown (NDSU Extension, Food Freezing Guide (FN403)). These are quality times; the storage table carries them.
Rolling and fitting without shrinking
Roll the chilled dough on a lightly floured counter, from the center outward, turning it a quarter turn every few strokes so it stays round and does not stick. Nebraska Extension's judging guide gives about 1/8 inch as the thickness (Nebraska Extension, 4-H Foods Judging Guide), and King Arthur rolls to 12 to 13 inches across for a 9-inch pie. If the dough cracks at the edges, it is too cold; give it a few minutes. If it sticks or goes soft, it is too warm; slide it onto a sheet and chill it.
Why crusts shrink
Gluten in a rolled crust is stretched like a spring. Pull the dough to fit the plate and it springs back in the oven, slipping down the sides. The fix is to ease, not stretch: lift the edge and let the dough fall into the corner where the side meets the bottom, then trim and crimp. Chill the fitted crust before it goes into the oven; King Arthur's blind-baking guide says 30 minutes, to prevent shrinkage.
The judging tables list the other causes:
| What you see | Causes to check (Nebraska Extension) | Causes to check (Utah 4-H) |
|---|---|---|
| Crust shrinks | Handled too much; stretched into the pan; stored too long in the refrigerator; not pricked enough; nonstick pan with sides not secured | Stretched into the pan |
| Tough crust | Dough too warm when rolled; too much water; overmixed; overhandled; too much rolling flour; not enough fat | Overhandling; too much water; not enough shortening |
| Crumbly, falls apart | Fat cut in poorly; not enough water; too much fat; self-rising flour | Too much shortening; not cut in enough; not enough liquid; rolled too thin |
| Dry, mealy | Not listed | Shortening cut in too finely; not enough liquid |
| Large blisters | Not listed | Not pricked enough |
| Soggy bottom | Undermixed; shiny pie pan; pie baked on a cookie sheet | Not listed |
Sources: Nebraska Extension, 4-H Foods Judging Guide; Utah 4-H, Fair Judges' Manual. The symptoms table carries these with the filling faults.
These are causes to check, written for fair judges looking at a finished pie. They do not diagnose your crust, and two can act together. Change one thing on the next crust and log it; When a bake goes wrong sets out the method.
The pie plate
Iowa State's AnswerLine recommends clear glass for a brown, crisp crust that is seldom soggy, noting it may need a little less time or a lower temperature, and calls disposable aluminum pans the hardest to bake evenly. Nebraska lists a shiny pie pan among the causes of a soggy bottom. KitchenAid's bakeware guidance keeps the full recipe temperature for pies in dark metal, where a crisp crust is wanted (KitchenAid, What Bakeware Should be Used). Product-specific Our default: glass or dark metal, at the recipe's temperature, checked early. The oven and the pan covers pan materials.
Glass bakeware can break with a sudden change of temperature. Pyrex's use and care page says not to set hot glass on a wet or cool surface, a countertop, metal or in the sink, not to go from freezer to hot oven, to preheat the oven before the glass goes in, and not to use glass on a stovetop or under a broiler (Pyrex, Safety and Usage). Cool a glass pie plate on a rack or a dry potholder. Follow your own bakeware maker's instructions.
Glass and the 25-degree question
KitchenAid says to lower the oven 25 °F (15 °C, as KitchenAid gives it) for ovenproof glass and ceramic, because they hold heat longer. Iowa State says glass may need a lower temperature or less time. Pyrex's own page gives no advice to lower the temperature. The sources agree glass bakes a bottom crust well; they do not agree on a number. Bake at the recipe's temperature, check 10 minutes early the first time, and log what you find. Iowa State's AnswerLine also notes that most glass bakeware sold in the US is now tempered soda-lime glass, which handles sudden heat less well than the older borosilicate (Iowa State AnswerLine, Glass Kitchenware Cautions).
Lattice tops
None of the sources we read gives a lattice method; follow your recipe. One thing does carry over: King Arthur's thickener chart says lattice and crumb tops need a little less thickener than a full top crust, because more of the juice evaporates.
Blind baking: when the crust goes in first
Blind baking (prebaking) means baking the crust before it is filled, weighted so it keeps its shape. King Arthur's guide sets out when (King Arthur Baking, How to prebake (blind bake) pie crust):
- Fully prebake for a filling that does not go into the oven, such as a cream pie.
- Partly prebake for a filling that bakes only briefly or at a low temperature: custard, pumpkin, quiche. The liquid filling would otherwise soak the raw bottom before it set.
- Do not prebake a double-crust pie. A single-crust fruit pie with a crumb top can be prebaked.
How, by King Arthur's method
- Chill the fitted crust 30 minutes. Cold fat holds the shape.
- Line it with foil, parchment or a coffee filter, pressed into the corners.
- Fill it about two-thirds with weights: dried beans, rice, pie weights or sugar.
- Bake at 375 °F (191 °C) for 20 minutes. That is a partly baked crust.
- To bake fully, lift out the liner and weights, prick the bottom with a fork, and bake 20 to 25 minutes more, until golden.
If the sides slip even with weights, King Arthur's fix is to bake the crust upside down, sandwiched between two nested pie pans. Pricking matters too: Utah's manual lists large blisters under a crust not pricked enough.
Fruit fillings and their thickeners
Fruit releases juice as it bakes. A thickener, a starch such as flour, cornstarch, tapioca or Instant Clearjel, swells in that juice and sets it so the slice holds. The default is the thickener and the amount your recipe gives. Three things help any of them work (King Arthur Baking's thickener guide, Pie Thickener):
- Mix the thickener with the sugar first, then toss with the fruit, so it does not clump.
- Bake until the filling bubbles through the vents or the lattice, not just until the crust is brown. Cornstarch in particular needs the filling bubbling to work fully, and Nebraska's table lists a raw, starchy taste under a thickener undercooked. Cover the edge with foil if it browns first.
- Let the pie cool completely before cutting. The filling sets as it cools.
Swapping one thickener for another
Thickeners differ in strength, so they do not swap one for one. NDSU Extension's freezing guide, telling bakers how much extra to add to a juicy filling before freezing, treats 1 tablespoon of flour, 1 tablespoon of quick-cooking tapioca and 1/2 tablespoon of cornstarch as the same amount of thickening (NDSU Extension, FN403). That is the extension rule: cornstarch is about twice as strong as flour. Convention King Arthur's chart, which is fruit by fruit, shows the ratio moving with the fruit: for apples, cornstarch is 3 1/2 times as strong as flour; for peaches, the two are equal. The chart and the comparison are under Go deeper. King Arthur also notes that quick-cooking tapioca needs the filling to rest 15 to 30 minutes before baking, that cornstarch clouds the filling, and that Instant Clearjel holds through freezing.
| Filling fault | Causes to check (Nebraska and Utah) |
|---|---|
| Runny, too thin | Too little thickener; too much sugar |
| Gummy, or a layer of thickening | Too much thickener; underbaked |
| Raw, starchy taste | Thickener undercooked |
| Filling spills over | Oven too low; too little thickener or fruit; too much sugar; top crust not sealed or stretched |
Sources: Nebraska Extension, 4-H Foods Judging Guide; Utah 4-H, Fair Judges' Manual.
Keeping a fruit pie
A fruit pie made with sugar can stay at room temperature. Iowa State's AnswerLine says such pies are safe at room temperature for up to two days, because sugar and the fruit's acid slow bacteria, then go into the refrigerator, loosely wrapped, for two more (Iowa State AnswerLine, Pie Storage). University of Illinois Extension says the same for fruit pies without dairy (Illinois Extension, Do I Need to Refrigerate the Pie?). FSIS's power-outage list keeps fruit pies (FSIS, Keep Your Food Safe During Emergencies). A fruit pie with a cream or custard layer is a custard pie and follows the next section. Freezing fruit pies, baked and unbaked, is in Baking ahead and for an occasion.
King Arthur's thickener chart
One practitioner's chart. King Arthur sells two of the thickeners on it (Instant Clearjel and its own pie filling enhancer), and it is the only fruit-by-fruit chart in the sources behind this manual. Amounts are per cup of fruit; a 9-inch pie holds about 8 cups.
| Fruit (per cup) | All-purpose flour | Cornstarch | Quick-cooking tapioca | Instant Clearjel |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apples | 1 3/4 tsp | 1/2 tsp | 3/4 tsp | 1/2 tsp |
| Blackberries, raspberries | 1 Tbsp + 1 tsp | 1 Tbsp | 1 Tbsp | 2 3/4 tsp |
| Blueberries | 1 Tbsp | 2 1/2 tsp | 1 1/2 tsp | 2 tsp |
| Cherries | 1 Tbsp | 2 1/2 tsp | 1 1/4 tsp | 2 1/2 tsp |
| Peaches | 2 1/2 tsp | 2 1/2 tsp | 1 1/2 tsp | 2 1/2 tsp |
| Strawberry and/or rhubarb | 1 Tbsp + 1 1/2 tsp | 1 Tbsp + 1/4 tsp | 2 1/2 tsp | 2 1/2 tsp |
Source: King Arthur Baking, Pie Thickener. King Arthur notes that farmers-market fruit, which is often juicier, may need more, and lattice and crumb tops a little less.
The extension rule against the chart
NDSU's rule and Clemson's freezing sheet both treat cornstarch as twice as strong as flour. King Arthur's chart agrees for some fruits and not others: its apple row has cornstarch at more than three times flour's strength, its peach row at the same strength, and it calls cornstarch about as strong as Instant Clearjel. Neither source explains the other. If you are converting a recipe from flour to cornstarch, the extension rule is the simpler starting point; if you are starting from no recipe, the chart gives a figure per fruit. Either way, the pie is the test: write the amount and the result on the recipe card.
Custard pies: pumpkin, pecan and cream
A custard pie has a filling set by eggs: pumpkin, sweet potato, pecan, custard and chess pies, and quiche. Cream pies (a cooked pudding filling in a prebaked crust) and chiffon pies (a filling lightened with beaten whites) belong with them for storage. The eggs decide two things: when the pie is done, and that it goes in the refrigerator.
When it is done
King Arthur's Baker's Hotline gives the signs for pumpkin pie (King Arthur Baking, How to tell when pumpkin pie is done):
- The jiggle. Take it out when a circle about 4 inches across in the center of a 9-inch pie still jiggles when the pie is nudged, and the edges are set and matte about 2 inches in from the rim. It keeps cooking as it cools.
- The thermometer. The center reads 160 to 170 °F (71 to 77 °C), the range King Arthur gives for eggs to set. Above 175 °F (79 °C) risks dry edges and cracks.
- When to start. Check 10 minutes before the recipe's time.
The federal line is 160 °F. FSIS says to cook egg dishes to 160 °F (71 °C), and that egg mixtures are safe once they reach it (FSIS, Shell Eggs from Farm to Table). For pumpkin pie, the two meet: King Arthur's range starts at the federal line. Our default is the jiggle to tell you when to read, and a center reading of at least 160 °F before the pie comes out.
The practitioners' custard temperatures and the federal egg line are different kinds of figure: one is where the texture is right, the other is the agency's safety line. This chapter shows both and does not call a reading below 160 °F safe. The jiggle test alone does not tell you the center has reached 160 °F; a thermometer does. Some recipes give lower figures for other custards, and cheesecake figures sit lower still (Cakes and frosting); none of them is a safety figure.
Into the refrigerator
Every source we read agrees that egg-rich pies are refrigerated once cool.
- Iowa State's AnswerLine, citing USDA, says to refrigerate pumpkin, pecan, custard and meringue pies after baking and cooling unless they are served within two hours. Cool the pie completely, chill it uncovered, then cover it loosely, so condensation does not make the crust soggy. A pie not cool within two hours can go into the refrigerator unwrapped to finish (Iowa State AnswerLine, Storing Pumpkin and Pecan Pie).
- Illinois Extension says pies with eggs, cream, sour cream, cream cheese or milk stay out of the refrigerator no more than two hours. It explains why a store pumpkin pie can sit on a shelf: a commercial shelf-stable pie is heated to 180 °F (82 °C) at its coldest point and made with preservatives, microbial testing and a use-by date. A homemade pie has none of those.
- FSIS's limit for perishable food is 2 hours out of refrigeration, 1 hour above 90 °F (32 °C) (FSIS, "Danger Zone").
How long they keep, from the federal cold storage chart on FoodSafety.gov (FoodSafety.gov, Cold Food Storage Chart), with the refrigerator at 40 °F (4 °C) or below and the freezer at 0 °F (−18 °C):
| Pie, after baking | Refrigerator | Freezer |
|---|---|---|
| Pumpkin or pecan pie | 3 to 4 days | 1 to 2 months |
| Custard and chiffon pies | 3 to 4 days | Do not freeze |
| Quiche | 3 to 5 days | 2 to 3 months |
Source: FoodSafety.gov, Cold Food Storage Chart (last reviewed September 19, 2023). Freezer times are for quality; the chart says food held at 0 °F keeps safe indefinitely. The storage table carries these with the fruit pie rows.
Meringue, chiffon and cream
- Meringue-topped pies: FSIS says they should be safe baked at 350 °F (177 °C) for about 15 minutes.
- Chiffon pies made with raw beaten whites: FSIS says their safety is not assured, and suggests pasteurized dried whites, whipped cream or a whipped topping instead.
- Cream pies: refrigerate. Iowa State's pie storage post says custard, cream, mousse, chiffon and fresh-fruit pies are refrigerated and used within four days, and do not freeze well.
Above 5,000 feet, Colorado State University Extension says to cook pudding and cream pie fillings over direct heat rather than in a double boiler, because the starch may not fully thicken at the lower boiling point (Colorado State, High Elevation Food Preparation Guide). The same guide suggests slightly more liquid in pie dough and baking in the lower third of the oven.
Custard pie temperatures: the sources compared
King Arthur's pumpkin pie page gives 160 to 170 °F. ThermoWorks gives 170 to 175 °F (77 to 79 °C) for pumpkin pie, crème brûlée and flan, and 160 °F for quiche and meringue pies (ThermoWorks, Doneness Temperatures for Baked Goods). The Home Baking Association chart gives 170 to 175 °F for custard, cream and pumpkin pies and 160 to 175 °F for quiche. FSIS's line is 160 °F. All of these are at or above the federal line, so for a pumpkin pie the choice among them is texture: King Arthur warns that above 175 °F the edges dry and crack. The comparison changes for cheesecake, where the practitioner figures fall below 160 °F; Cakes and frosting takes that up.
Freezing pumpkin pie: the sources compared
FoodSafety.gov gives baked pumpkin pie 1 to 2 months frozen. Iowa State's pie storage post gives up to two months with some loss, warning that the filling may separate and the crust go soggy. Both agree custard and chiffon pies are not for the freezer.
Lamination: why puff pastry rises Go deeper
Lamination is the method behind puff pastry, croissants and Danish. Nebraska Extension's judging guide describes it: butter is enclosed in dough, then the dough is rolled out and folded, over and over, so that butter and dough form thin, separate layers. In the oven the water in each butter layer turns to steam, and the fat layers trap it, so the dough lifts apart into flakes. The lift comes mainly from that steam. Physical principle
It is the same physics as a flaky pie crust taken much further. Pie dough has scattered pieces of fat; laminated dough has continuous sheets. Nebraska's figures for the classic method:
- The butter is conditioned to 57 to 60 °F (14 to 16 °C): pliable enough to roll with the dough, firm enough to stay a separate layer.
- Laminated doughs take at least three half folds (a fold in thirds, like a letter).
- Classic puff pastry is turned six times, which gives more than 1,000 layers, and rises to about five times its volume.
- Rough puff (quick puff) tosses large cubes of butter with the flour before the water goes in, then rolls and folds; it rises less and takes far less time.
Nebraska's croissant table shows why the butter's temperature carries so much: butter that breaks through the dough was too cold, or the dough too soft; butter that oozes out was too warm; pastry that comes out bread-like rather than flaky points to a kitchen too hot, an oven too cool or overproofing.
This manual does not teach a laminated dough step by step. Store-bought puff pastry is the practical route for most home bakers, and a pie crust is the place to learn the cold-fat principle first.
See it: two pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving See it
Ruth Adeyemi is fictional, and every fact about her here is invented for this manual. She lives in Illinois. She bakes two pumpkin pies for Thanksgiving dinner at her house on Thursday, in two 9-inch glass pie plates, with an all-butter crust she makes herself. Her grandson has a peanut allergy.
Known: pumpkin pie is a custard pie, so each crust is partly blind baked: chilled 30 minutes, lined, weighted and baked at 375 °F for 20 minutes. The filled pies bake on Wednesday afternoon. She starts checking 10 minutes before the recipe's time; she takes each pie out when about 4 inches of the center still jiggles and the center reads at least 160 °F, and she writes both readings in the bake log. The pies cool on a rack, not the cold counter, because the plates are glass. Within two hours they go into the refrigerator uncovered, and once cold she covers them loosely. By the federal chart they keep 3 to 4 days, so Wednesday's pies are well inside that on Thursday. On Thursday they come out for dessert and go back within two hours.
Assumed (Ruth's assumption): the two pies bake at the same rate. They are on different racks, so one may finish first; under that assumption she would pull both together, and the assumption is the reason she reads each pie separately.
Open: whether the lower pie's bottom crust browns enough (her log settles it; The oven and the pan covers rack position); and whether the pies are safe for her grandson. The recipe has no peanuts, but that is only the start of the question: what else her kitchen handles, and the labels on the canned pumpkin, the spice and the crust ingredients, are for his parents to judge with her. The manual does not decide it; Baking ahead and for an occasion covers labeling and cross-contact.
- King Arthur Baking, How to prebake (blind bake) pie crust: when to prebake, and the method step by step.
- King Arthur Baking, How to tell when pumpkin pie is done: the jiggle, the edges and the thermometer range.
- Illinois Extension, Do I Need to Refrigerate the Pie?: which pies go in the refrigerator, and why store pies differ.
- Iowa State AnswerLine, Pie Baking: the 3-2-1 crust, the fats and the pie plates.
Practice: one crust, baked and logged Practice
Minimum: one single crust, mixed cold, chilled, fitted without stretching, chilled again and blind baked fully, with the fat, the chill times and any shrinking written down. No filling needed. Time: 20 minutes to mix, 30 minutes or more to chill, 15 minutes to roll and fit, 30 minutes to chill again, and about 45 minutes to bake. Materials: half of King Arthur's double-crust recipe (about 149 g, or 1 1/4 cups, all-purpose flour, with its butter and shortening, salt and ice water halved), a bowl, a pastry blender or two knives or your fingers, plastic wrap, a rolling pin, a 9-inch pie plate, foil or parchment, dried beans or rice as weights, a ruler, and the bake log.
- Chill everything. Cube the butter and keep it cold; put ice in the water.
- Cut the fat into the flour and salt until the largest pieces are about pea-size.
- Add ice water a spoonful at a time, tossing, until a squeezed handful holds. Write how many spoonfuls.
- Form a disk, wrap it and chill it at least 30 minutes. Write the time.
- Roll to about 1/8 inch and a circle 12 to 13 inches across. Ease it into the plate, trim, crimp and prick the bottom.
- Chill the fitted crust 30 minutes. Measure the height of the crimp above the rim with a ruler.
- Blind bake fully: line, weight, 375 °F (191 °C) for 20 minutes, then out with the weights and 20 to 25 minutes more until golden.
- Measure the crimp again when it is cool. Write whether it shrank and by how much, and how the crust breaks: flaky layers, or crumbly and mealy.
A fat pair. Make two crusts on the same day, one all butter and one half butter and half shortening. Blind bake both and compare flakiness, color, taste and shrinking.
A stretch pair. Fit one crust by easing it in and a second by stretching it to the rim. Bake both and measure the difference. This is the shrinking cause the tables agree on, seen in your own oven.
A fruit pie. Bake a fruit pie with your recipe's thickener, until it bubbles through the vents. Cool it completely, cut it, and write how the slice held on the recipe card.
Your kitchen Your kitchen
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Were the fat and water cold, and did you stop cutting in with pea-size pieces still visible?
- Did the dough rest at least 30 minutes before rolling, and the fitted crust chill again before baking?
- Did you ease the dough into the plate rather than stretch it?
- Did you blind bake when the filling was a custard or did not go into the oven?
- For a fruit pie, did the filling bubble before the pie came out, and did it cool before cutting?
- For a custard pie, did the center read at least 160 °F, and did the pie go into the refrigerator within two hours?
- Does the bake log record the fat, the chill times and any shrinking?
Worked example
Ruth's pies meet the criteria: crusts partly blind baked after chilling, each pie read separately for the federal 160 °F, both cooled on a rack and refrigerated within two hours, and the readings logged. Her one open point is the rack: the two pies baked on different racks, so her assumption that they finish together is the thing her two readings test. Whether the pies are safe for her grandson is not a criterion this chapter can check; it is his parents' call with her.
Common mistakes
- Warm butter, worked to paste. The crust comes out tender and mealy, not flaky. Keep it cold and stop at pea-size.
- Water poured in all at once. Too much water makes a tough crust. Add it by the spoonful.
- Stretching the dough to the rim. It springs back in the oven. Ease it in, and chill it before baking.
- Pulling a fruit pie when the crust looks done. If the filling is not bubbling, the thickener has not finished.
- Cutting a fruit pie warm. The filling runs. Cool it completely.
- Pumpkin pie left on the counter overnight. Homemade custard pies go into the refrigerator within two hours.
- Hot glass on a wet counter. Cool it on a rack or a dry potholder.
What is still unresolved
This chapter cannot tell you why your own crust shrank or toughened; the tables give causes to check, one per crust, and When a bake goes wrong gives the order. Which flour suits a crust, and why bread flour toughens one, is in Flour and gluten. How far ahead to bake pies for an occasion, freezing them and carrying them are in Baking ahead and for an occasion. Whether a pie is safe for someone with a food allergy is for them or their caregiver to decide.