Cakes and frosting
Methods

Cakes and frosting: why a cake sinks, swapping pan sizes, and which frostings need the fridge

Butter and foam cakes told apart by method, why a cake sinks in the middle, pans swapped by area in a cake pan size conversion, doneness read, layers cooled and leveled, and cream cheese and other frostings sorted by whether they need the refrigerator.

Start here Essentials

For a first pass, match the pans to the recipe, fill them right, check doneness early, and cool the cake fully. Frosting can wait until the layers are cold.

  1. Check that your pans match the recipe's, or find the swap. Compare bottom areas (pans).
  2. Grease and line the pans, and fill them no more than two-thirds. Foam cakes go into an ungreased tube pan instead (butter and foam cakes).
  3. Bake, and check at the earliest time with a toothpick or a thermometer. Do not open the door before then (done).
  4. Cool in the pan about 10 minutes, then fully on a rack before frosting. (cooling and leveling).

Minimum time: about 2 1/2 hours, most of it cooling. Done when: an unfrosted cake is cooled and the bake log records the pan, the time and the doneness test used.

Butter cakes and foam cakes Understand

Cakes fall into two families, and the family decides the pan, the mixing and the cooling. Nebraska Extension's 4-H judging guide draws the line by fat (Nebraska Extension, 4-H Foods Judging Guide):

  • Butter cakes (the guide's "shortened cakes") contain butter, shortening or oil and are raised by baking powder or baking soda, plus steam and the air beaten in. Yellow, white, chocolate layer, pound, carrot and most sheet cakes are butter cakes.
  • Foam cakes (the guide's "unshortened cakes") have little or no fat and many eggs or egg whites, and rise mainly on steam and the air in beaten eggs. Angel food, sponge and chiffon cakes are foam cakes. They bake in ungreased tube pans.

How butter cakes are mixed

King Arthur Baking describes the methods (King Arthur Baking, Cake mixing methods). Creaming, the most common, beats butter and sugar until lighter and fluffy, adds eggs one at a time, then adds the dry ingredients and the liquid alternately, starting and ending with dry; the result is sturdy yet soft, slices cleanly and stacks. Cookies, muffins and biscuits covers creaming and the butter's temperature in detail. The blended or one-bowl method stirs everything together, usually with oil, and gives a very moist cake with a pourable batter; carrot cake is the example.

How foam cakes are mixed

A foam cake depends on eggs beaten full of air. The Exploratorium's science of cooking pages say beaten eggs can foam to as much as eight times their volume, and that the liquid in a batter expands enormously as it turns to steam in the oven (Exploratorium, The Amazing Multi-Tasking Egg). Physical principle King Arthur's descriptions:

  • Angel food: no yolks, little or no fat and no chemical leavener. The whites are whipped to stiff peaks, usually with cream of tartar, and the flour is folded in. Folding means turning a light mixture into a heavier one with a spatula, cutting down and lifting over, so as little air as possible is lost.
  • Sponge: yolks or whole eggs beaten with sugar to a thick ribbon, with the flour folded in; or whites whipped separately to soft peaks and folded in.
  • Chiffon: Nebraska's guide groups it with angel food and sponge as a foam cake. None of the sources behind this manual gives a chiffon method, so follow your recipe.

Angel food has no fat to slow gluten, so it can turn gummy. The Exploratorium recommends cake flour or cake and pastry flour, and notes that cutting the sugar lowers the volume, because sugar raises the temperature at which the batter sets and gives it longer to rise (Exploratorium, Why is my angel food cake such a flop?). That makes sugar in a foam cake structural, not only sweet.

Go deeper

Reverse creaming, and why it suits stacking

King Arthur's reverse creaming (or paste) method beats soft butter into the dry ingredients first until sandy, then adds the liquids, then the eggs. Butter-coated flour forms less gluten, so overmixing is less likely to toughen the cake. The cakes bake flatter, with little dome, and slightly denser, and the crumb holds up to soaking syrups and stacked layers (King Arthur Baking, What is reverse creaming). Test it Bake one recipe both ways on two days and compare the dome, the crumb and how cleanly a slice holds.

Egg whites: stiff or soft

King Arthur whips whites to stiff peaks for angel food and to soft peaks for a separated sponge. A stiff peak stands straight when the whisk is lifted; a soft peak curls over at the tip. At altitude, Colorado State University Extension advises beating whites for foam cakes only to shiny peaks that droop slightly (Colorado State, High Elevation Food Preparation Guide). Utah 4-H's judging manual lists whites beaten too little or too much as causes of poor volume, and overfolding as a cause of a tough, compact crumb (Utah 4-H, Fair Judges' Manual).

Pans: preparing, filling and swapping

Preparing

For a butter cake, grease the pan and line the bottom with a circle of parchment. Nebraska's judging tables list a pan not greased enough, and a cake left in the pan too long, as the reasons a cake sticks. For a foam cake, do the opposite: leave the tube pan ungreased, as Nebraska's guide specifies. The batter climbs the walls as it rises, and Utah's manual lists greased sides as a cause of a fallen foam cake.

Filling

Wilton, a pan and decorating-supply maker, and King Arthur both say to fill cake pans one-half to two-thirds full (Wilton, Cake Serving Chart; King Arthur Baking, How to swap baking pan sizes). Convention More than that and the batter can run over or rise into a dome that cracks; Nebraska lists too much batter under cakes that run over and cakes that fall. If you have more batter than your pans hold at two-thirds, bake the rest as cupcakes rather than overfilling.

Swapping one pan for another

Swap pans by the area of the bottom, for pans of the same depth. King Arthur's alternative pan sizes page gives the arithmetic: a square or rectangle is side times side; a round is radius times radius times 3.14 (King Arthur Baking, The essential alternative baking pan sizes). Physical principle The figures below assume pans 2 inches deep.

PanBottom areaSwaps for
8-inch round50 sq inAbout 80 percent of a 9-inch round
9-inch round63.6 sq in (round to 64)An 8-inch square
8-inch square64 sq inA 9-inch round
7 x 11 inch77 sq inAn 8 x 12 oval (75)
9 x 13 inch117 sq inTwo 9-inch rounds (about 10 percent more area, so slightly thinner layers); two 8-inch rounds (about 9 percent less, so a risk of overflow unless the pans are a full 2 inches deep)
10 x 15 inch jelly roll150 sq inThin cakes only; not a deep-cake swap

Source: King Arthur Baking, The essential alternative baking pan sizes. The pan sizes table lists more pans and their volumes, and the pan scaler does the arithmetic for your own pans.

The 8-inch against 9-inch round difference is the one that catches people. King Arthur's pan swap page puts it as volume: a 9-inch round holds 26.6 percent more than an 8-inch round. A recipe written for two 9-inch rounds, poured into two 8-inch rounds, fills them past two-thirds. Fill to two-thirds and bake the rest as cupcakes.

Time changes with the swap. King Arthur's rule: in a smaller pan, fill no more than two-thirds and expect 10 to 15 minutes longer; in a larger pan, check 10 to 15 minutes early. In a 10-cup Bundt pan, bake about 30 percent longer than for a 9 x 13. Glass and ceramic conduct heat more slowly than metal, and dark metal browns most. The oven and the pan covers pan material and color.

The swaps not to make

King Arthur calls chiffon, angel food and sponge cakes poor candidates for pan swaps, and says not to bake sponge or angel food in a Bundt pan. A 9-inch springform is usually 3 inches deep and holds about 13 cups, so it does not swap for a standard 9-inch pan either. Keep foam cakes in the pan the recipe names.

Cupcakes from a cake recipe

King Arthur's conversion: one 9 x 13 cake, two 9-inch layers or three 8-inch layers make about 24 standard cupcakes; one 8-inch square or 9-inch round layer makes about 12. Fill the wells about four-fifths full, a fuller fill than for a cake pan, because a cupcake rises above its paper. Most cupcakes bake at 325 to 375 °F (163 to 191 °C), and start checking well before the cake's time (King Arthur Baking, How to convert cake to cupcakes). Pound cake makes heavy cupcakes and sponge makes short, dry ones, so a creamed or one-bowl layer cake converts best.

Caution

Do not taste raw cake batter. CDC lists cakes among the raw doughs and batters not to eat, because most flour is raw and raw eggs can carry Salmonella; only baking kills the germs (CDC, Raw Flour and Dough).

Done: toothpick, spring-back and temperature

Three tests, used together. Start checking at the earliest time the recipe gives, and not before: Nebraska's tables list peeking (opening the oven early) and moving the cake while it bakes among the reasons a cake falls.

  • Toothpick. A wooden pick pushed into the center comes out clean or with a few moist crumbs, not wet batter.
  • Spring-back. A light press in the center springs back rather than leaving a dent, and the edges have begun to pull from the pan.
  • Temperature. ThermoWorks, a thermometer maker, gives 200 to 209 °F (93 to 98 °C) for cakes, cupcakes and angel food, and 210 °F (99 °C) for pound cake (ThermoWorks, Doneness Temperatures for Baked Goods). The Home Baking Association chart says to probe cakes only after the rise has set (Home Baking Association, Baking Temperatures).

The toothpick and spring-back are the default because they work in any kitchen. The thermometer is the tie-breaker when the top looks done and you are not sure about the middle, which is most often with a deep pan or a dark one.

Altitude caps the temperature test. A moist crumb does not normally get hotter than the boiling point of the water in it, and water boils lower as you go up: Colorado State gives 212 °F (100 °C) at sea level and 203 °F (95 °C) at 5,000 feet. Physical principle Above about 5,000 feet a target of 205 °F may not arrive, so read the lower end of the range and lean on the toothpick and spring-back. When a bake goes wrong and the altitude calculator cover the recipe changes.

Why cakes sink

A cake that rises and then falls in the middle is the commonest cake failure. The two extension judging tables list these causes:

Cause to checkNebraska ExtensionUtah 4-H
Too much leavenerToo much baking powderToo much baking powder or soda
Too much fat or sugarToo much shortening or sugarToo much shortening
UnderbakedYesYes
Door opened or cake moved too soonPeeking; moved while bakingDoor opened or cake moved too soon
Oven too coolOven temperature too lowNot listed for butter cakes
Too much batter in the panYesNot listed

Sources: Nebraska Extension, 4-H Foods Judging Guide; Utah 4-H, Fair Judges' Manual. The symptoms table carries these with the other cake faults.

At altitude, several of these causes arrive together. Colorado State gives air pressure as 14.7 pounds per square inch at sea level and 12.3 at 5,000 feet; with less pressure on it, the gas from the same amount of leavener expands more. Physical principle That is why the extension altitude tables reduce baking powder and sugar and add liquid. Colorado State's cake table starts its first band at 3,500 feet; When a bake goes wrong explains the bands and where the sources differ.

Cooling, leveling and filling two layers

Cooling

Recipes for butter cakes commonly say to cool the layers in the pan about 10 minutes, then turn them out onto a rack. The judging tables explain both halves: a cake left in the pan too long sticks (Nebraska) and steams in the pan, making a soggy crust (Utah), and a cake wrapped before it is cool goes soggy (Nebraska). Cool the layers completely, about an hour or more, before you frost. Warm cake melts frosting and tears when spread.

Foam cakes cool differently. Utah's manual lists a pan not turned upside down as a cause of a fallen angel food or sponge cake: invert the tube pan as soon as it comes out, on its feet or over a bottle neck, and leave it until cold, so the soft crumb hangs rather than collapses.

Leveling and filling: our method

None of the sources behind this manual gives a leveling or filling procedure, so the steps below are ours, written for a two-layer 8- or 9-inch cake.

  1. Cool both layers completely. Chilled layers cut more cleanly.
  2. If a layer has domed, slice the dome off level with a long serrated knife, sawing gently while you turn the cake. Keep the trimmings for tasting.
  3. Set the first layer cut side down on the plate or a board. Spread the filling or about a cup of frosting to within half an inch of the edge.
  4. Set the second layer on top, cut side down, so the flat bottom of the pan becomes the top of the cake.
  5. Spread a thin first coat of frosting over the whole cake to fix the crumbs, chill it 15 to 30 minutes until firm, then spread the final coat.
Limits

This chapter stops at a two-layer cake and a sheet cake. Tiered and stacked cakes, three or more layers or one cake set on another, need internal supports and a structural method that this manual does not teach. King Arthur notes that a sponge cake compresses when stacked more than two layers high. Wilton advises a heating core for pans 3 inches deep and 12 inches or wider. For a tiered cake, use a source that teaches the supports, or ask a professional baker.

Go deeper

Cake strips and flatter layers

Cake strips are fabric bands soaked in water and wrapped around the outside of a pan, so the edge heats more slowly and the cake rises more evenly. King Arthur tested soaked strips on cheesecake, wetting them 10 to 15 minutes and doubling them where possible, and found they helped (King Arthur Baking, How to keep cheesecake from cracking). We found no source testing them on layer cakes, so treat them as something to try and log. A lower oven within the recipe's range also domes less, at the cost of a longer bake. Nebraska lists an oven too hot at first as a cause of humps, peaks and cracks on top.

Frosting: how much, and which ones need the refrigerator

Frosting (or icing) is the sweet coating spread on a cake. Four kinds cover most home cakes:

  • American buttercream: softened butter beaten with powdered sugar and a little milk or cream. The quickest to make.
  • Cream cheese frosting: cream cheese and butter beaten with powdered sugar. Softer, tangier, and it needs the refrigerator.
  • Whipped cream: cream whipped with a little sugar. Light, and it needs the refrigerator.
  • Cooked frostings: made with a hot sugar syrup or on the stove, such as seven-minute frosting, egg whites beaten while hot sugar syrup is poured in, and the meringue buttercreams under Go deeper.

How much

King Arthur's amounts, for 8- or 9-inch rounds, with about 2 tablespoons per cupcake (King Arthur Baking, How much frosting do I need for a cake?):

CakeFrosting
Single layer, or 12 cupcakes1 1/2 cups
9 x 13 sheet, or 18 to 24 cupcakes3 cups
Two-layer cake, or 24 cupcakes3 1/2 to 4 cups
Two-layer cake with more between the layers, or 24 to 30 cupcakes4 1/2 cups

Wilton's chart is close: 3 1/2 cups to ice and decorate a two-layer 8-inch round, 4 cups for a 9-inch, and 7 cups for a two-layer 9 x 13 (Wilton, Cake Serving Chart). King Arthur's own cream cheese frosting recipe makes 3 cups, so a two-layer cake needs a batch and a third. King Arthur says frosting freezes for up to three months and thaws overnight in the refrigerator.

Which frostings need the refrigerator

The default comes from the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS). Its power-outage list says which baked goods to keep after more than 4 hours above 40 °F (4 °C): cakes stay on the keep list, except cakes with cream cheese frosting or cream fillings, which are discarded along with custard, chiffon and cheese pies and cream-filled pastries (FSIS, Keep Your Food Safe During Emergencies, 2013). We use that list to sort frostings, not as a holding time.

Frosting or fillingRefrigerate?What it rests on
Cream cheese frosting or fillingYesFSIS excludes cream cheese frosted cakes from its keep list. Kansas State University tested submitted recipes and found some cream cheese frostings needed refrigeration and some did not, so Kansas fairs allow none
Whipped cream, pastry cream, custard fillingsYesFSIS excludes cream fillings; Iowa State treats frostings with dairy, eggs or custard as perishable
American buttercream (butter and powdered sugar)Not by the FSIS list; refrigerate to keep longerFSIS keeps cakes other than cream cheese and cream; Kansas State gives at least 65 percent sugar by weight as a practical sign a frosting holds at room temperature
Seven-minute frostingFSIS addresses how it is made, not how it is storedFSIS lists it as safe because the hot syrup cooks the whites
Icings made with uncooked eggs or whitesAvoidFSIS says to avoid them; use pasteurized eggs or pasteurized dried whites where a recipe calls for raw

Sources: FSIS, Keep Your Food Safe During Emergencies; Kansas State, Food Safety of Frostings and Fillings (MF3544), 2020; FSIS, Shell Eggs from Farm to Table; Iowa State AnswerLine, Food Safety Practices for Baked Goods, 2026.

Kansas State's sheet explains the reasoning. What matters is water activity: how much of a food's water is free for bacteria to use. Sugar ties water up, so a frosting with enough sugar leaves bacteria too little; a frosting with cream cheese, cream or eggs and less sugar leaves them enough, and Kansas State calls such foods time and temperature control for safety (TCS) foods. Physical principle A buttercream heavy on butter and light on sugar, or thinned with a lot of milk, moves toward the perishable side, which is why the table says "refrigerate to keep longer."

A refrigerated cake still comes out for the party. FSIS's limit is 2 hours out of refrigeration, or 1 hour above 90 °F (32 °C) (FSIS, "Danger Zone"). For a cream cheese frosted cake, plan refrigerator space and the moment it comes out. FSIS's mail-order table, dated 2015, gives frosted cakes 3 days in the refrigerator and 2 months in the freezer (FSIS, Mail Order Food Safety). Baking ahead and for an occasion plans the days and the drive.

Caution

Hot sugar syrup for seven-minute frosting or a meringue buttercream sticks to skin and causes serious burns. Keep children away from the stove while it cooks, and pour it with the mixer on low, down the side of the bowl.

Go deeper

Swiss and Italian meringue buttercreams

Both whip butter into a meringue, so they are smoother and less sweet than American buttercream. Italian meringue buttercream pours hot sugar syrup into beating whites, the same hot-syrup method FSIS names for seven-minute frosting; FSIS does not name Italian meringue itself. Swiss meringue buttercream heats the whites and sugar together over simmering water before whipping. FSIS says egg mixtures are safe once they reach 160 °F (71 °C), so heat the whites and sugar to 160 °F, read with a thermometer, or use pasteurized whites. King Arthur's Swiss buttercream recipe makes 5 to 5 1/2 cups. Wilton advises against Swiss meringue buttercream and cream cheese frosting on long summer trips, because both soften in heat (Wilton, How to Transport a Cake).

Where the sources part on buttercream

FSIS's list keeps buttercream-frosted cakes, and its mail-order table lists frosted cakes at 2 days at room temperature. Iowa State's 2026 AnswerLine post counts frostings made with dairy as perishable, to be refrigerated and out no more than 2 hours. Butter is dairy, but a powdered-sugar buttercream is high in sugar, and Kansas State's 65 percent figure is the reason it can hold. Kansas State also counts corn syrup as 70 percent sugar for its calculation. If your buttercream has cream, cream cheese, eggs or a lot of milk in it, or you cannot tell, refrigerate it.

Servings per pan

Wilton publishes a serving chart for its pans. It defines a party serving as about 1 1/2 by 2 inches and a wedding serving as about 1 by 2 inches, both cut from a cake about 4 inches tall: two 2-inch layers. A cake 3 to 6 inches tall yields the same count; a cake under 3 inches tall yields half (Wilton, Cake Serving Chart). Product-specific

PanParty servings (two layers, 4 in tall)Wedding servingsBatter per 2-inch layerBake
6-inch round12122 1/4 cups350 °F (177 °C), 35 to 40 min
8-inch round20244 cups350 °F, 37 to 42 min
9-inch round24325 cups350 °F, 40 to 45 min
10-inch round28386 cups350 °F, 40 to 45 min
8-inch square20326 cups350 °F, 45 to 50 min
7 x 11 inch sheet24325 1/2 cups350 °F, 45 to 50 min
9 x 13 inch sheet365010 cups350 °F, 40 to 45 min
11 x 15 inch sheet547411 1/2 cups325 °F (163 °C), 50 to 55 min

Source: Wilton, Cake Serving Chart. A single 2-inch sheet cake is under 3 inches tall, so it yields half the figure shown: a single-layer 9 x 13 gives about 18 party servings. The servings table carries the full chart, and the occasion plan uses it.

Limits

These are one maker's portion sizes, not a promise of how much your guests will eat. Children may take less, adults may take seconds, and a cake served after a large meal may go further than one served on its own. We found no extension table for dessert servings at a party. Use the chart to choose a pan, and decide for yourself how much margin you want.

Go deeper

Wilton's batter cups against King Arthur's

Wilton's batter figures are how much to put in each pan at the half to two-thirds fill: 4 cups in each 8-inch round, 10 cups in a 9 x 13. King Arthur says a typical two-layer or 9 x 13 recipe makes about 6 cups of batter. The two do not conflict. A 6-cup recipe fills two 8-inch rounds well, and fills a 9 x 13 to a thin cake; for Wilton's 2-inch-tall 9 x 13, you would make more batter. Measure your own recipe's batter once, and write it on its recipe card.

Cheesecake is a custard

A cheesecake is a custard: a mixture that sets because its eggs thicken as they heat. The Exploratorium notes that eggs thicken custards at lower temperatures than flour or cornstarch thicken a sauce. So a cheesecake is judged like a custard, not like a cake: it should come out with the edge set and the center still soft, because it keeps cooking as it cools.

Doneness

King Arthur's test, from a side-by-side trial: the edge firm and the center just set; a digital thermometer pushed halfway into the filling reads no more than 175 °F (79 °C) about an inch from the edge and at least 150 °F (66 °C) in the center (King Arthur Baking, How to keep cheesecake from cracking). ThermoWorks gives 150 °F for cheesecake, and the Home Baking Association 145 to 150 °F.

The federal line is different. FSIS says egg dishes are cooked to 160 °F (71 °C), and that egg mixtures are safe once they reach it (FSIS, Shell Eggs from Farm to Table). The practitioners' cheesecake figures sit below that line.

Limits

We do not call a cheesecake center below 160 °F safe. The 150 °F figures are the practitioners' doneness temperatures for texture; FSIS's egg line is 160 °F, and none of the sources we read reconciles the two. If you want the federal line, bake until the center reads 160 °F and accept a firmer texture and a higher chance of cracks, or choose a recipe that does not depend on a soft center. Who eats it, and what risk is acceptable for them, is their decision and their clinician's.

Cooling and keeping

FSIS calls cheesecake a perishable food that needs prompt handling. Its mail-order table gives 7 days in the refrigerator and 3 months in the freezer, and its power-outage list discards cheese pies after more than 4 hours above 40 °F. Cool the cheesecake, then refrigerate it, and keep it out no more than the 2 hours of the danger zone rule when you serve it.

King Arthur names overbaking as the chief cause of cracks, and says recipes with only cream cheese, eggs and sugar crack more readily than those with sour cream or heavy cream, and thinner cakes are easier to keep from overbaking.

Go deeper

The cracking trial

King Arthur baked the same cheesecake four ways and scored each out of 10 for cracking: a plain bake scored 5; a pan of water on a lower rack 5.5 (it kept the cake moist but did not stop overbaking); soaked cake strips 7; a water bath, with the hottest tap water halfway up the pan and older springforms wrapped in foil, 9.5. That is one practitioner's trial with one recipe, and we found no extension trial to set beside it. A water bath slows the bake, so if you also aim for the federal 160 °F center, expect a long bake and read the center, not the clock.

See it: a birthday cake at 5,280 feet See it

Fictional example

The Hale household (Priya and Tom, and their daughter Maya) is fictional, and every fact about them here is invented for this manual. They live in Denver, at 5,280 feet. They have a gas range with a convection setting, a kitchen scale, two 8-inch round pans and a 9 x 13. Maya turns seven on a Saturday three weeks out, with 20 guests. Last year's birthday cake sank in the middle. Maya wants cream cheese frosting.

Known: their recipe is a creamed butter cake written for two 9-inch rounds. A 9-inch round holds 26.6 percent more than an 8-inch, so the batter overfills their pans. Filled to two-thirds, the two 8-inch rounds take about 100 of the recipe's 127 square inches of layer, and the rest makes about 5 cupcakes by King Arthur's conversion. At Wilton's party size, a two-layer 8-inch cake gives 20 servings, one for each guest and none spare; a single-layer 9 x 13 gives about 18. Cream cheese frosting goes in the refrigerator, and a two-layer cake takes 3 1/2 to 4 cups, so King Arthur's 3-cup recipe needs a batch and a third.

Assumed (Priya's assumption): last year's cake sank because of the altitude, since the recipe was written for sea level and they changed nothing. Two causes on the sinking table, too much leavener and too much sugar, are exactly what Colorado State's cake table reduces at 3,500 to 6,500 feet: 1/8 teaspoon less baking powder per teaspoon, up to 1 tablespoon less sugar per cup, 1 to 2 tablespoons more liquid per cup, and an oven 15 to 25 °F (8 to 14 °C) hotter. Under that assumption, those changes are potentially enough.

Open: whether last year's cake was also underbaked, or the oven ran cool (checking the oven with a thermometer, as in The oven and the pan, settles the oven); whether to use convection (their range's owner's manual settles the conversion; for a first test they bake on the regular setting); whether the altered recipe sinks (a test cake the Saturday before settles it); and whether 20 servings is enough, since the chart is Wilton's portion size, not a count of what guests eat (Priya and Tom decide; making the 9 x 13 as well gives them 38).

What they do: they bake a test layer the Saturday before with the altitude changes, check it at the earliest time with a toothpick, and read the center at about 200 °F (93 °C), close to the 203 °F boiling point Colorado State gives for 5,000 feet. It does not sink. They write the changes on the recipe card, plan refrigerator space on the day, and use Baking ahead and for an occasion for how far ahead to bake and frost.

Practice: one cooled, unfrosted cake Practice

Minimum: one butter cake recipe baked in pans you have checked against the recipe, tested for doneness at the earliest time, cooled completely and logged. Frosting can wait. Time: about 30 minutes to mix, the recipe's bake time, and 1 to 2 hours to cool. Materials: a butter cake recipe and its ingredients, one or two cake pans or a 9 x 13, parchment, butter or spray for the pans, wooden picks, a cooling rack, a ruler, and the bake log. A thermometer is optional.

  1. Measure your pans. Across the top inside edge, and the depth. Compare with the recipe's pans by area, using the table above or the pan scaler.
  2. Prepare the pans. Grease, line the bottoms with parchment, grease the parchment.
  3. Mix by the recipe's method and fill to no more than two-thirds. Weigh the batter into each pan if you have a scale, so the layers match. Spoon any extra into cupcake liners.
  4. Bake without opening the door until the earliest time. Then test with a pick, a light press, and a thermometer if you have one.
  5. Cool about 10 minutes in the pan, then turn out onto a rack and cool completely.
  6. Write the pan, its fill, the time, the doneness test and the result in the bake log. Note whether the top domed or sank.
Go deeper

Frost and fill it. Level, fill and frost the cooled cake by the method under cooling and leveling. Measure how much frosting it took, and write it on the recipe card.

A doneness map. On one layer, read the temperature at the center and halfway to the edge when the pick first comes out clean. Write both. The gap is your pan's and your oven's figure.

A cheesecake. Bake one, read the center and an inch from the edge, and write both readings beside the King Arthur and federal figures.

Your kitchen Your kitchen

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Did your pans match the recipe's by area, or did you adjust the fill and bake the extra separately?
  • Were the pans filled no more than two-thirds?
  • Did you leave the door shut until the earliest time, then test with more than one sign?
  • Did the cake cool fully before it was wrapped, filled or frosted?
  • If the frosting has cream cheese, cream or eggs, is there a plan for the refrigerator and for the 2 hours out?
  • Does the bake log say pan, fill, time, test and result?

Worked example

The Hales' test layer meets the criteria: the pans were checked by area and filled to two-thirds, the extra batter went into cupcakes, the layer was tested at the earliest time by pick and thermometer, and it cooled before it was wrapped. Their frosting plan includes refrigerator space. What it does not show is whether the oven runs true: their result rests on the assumption that the altitude was last year's cause, and a cake that holds with the changes is consistent with that assumption without proving it. An oven check settles the rest.

Common mistakes

  • A 9-inch recipe in 8-inch pans, filled to the top. The batter runs over or the cake sinks. Fill to two-thirds and bake the extra as cupcakes.
  • Opening the door early to look. The tables list it as a cause of falling. Wait for the earliest time.
  • Frosting a warm cake. The frosting melts and slides. Cool it completely.
  • Greasing an angel food pan. The batter cannot climb. Leave the tube pan bare.
  • A cream cheese frosted cake left out through a long party. FSIS's limit is 2 hours, 1 above 90 °F. Bring it out to serve.
  • Taking a chart's servings as a headcount. They are one maker's slice size.

What is still unresolved

This chapter cannot tell you why your own cake sank; the sinking table gives causes to check, and When a bake goes wrong gives the order and the one-change test. The altitude changes for your elevation are in the altitude calculator. How far ahead a cake can be baked, frozen, frosted and carried is in Baking ahead and for an occasion. Whether a cake is safe for someone with a food allergy is for them or their caregiver to decide; Baking ahead and for an occasion covers labeling.

Knowledge check and scenario

Your recipe is for one 9 x 13. You want two 8-inch rounds. What does King Arthur's area rule say?
Two 8-inch rounds have about 9 percent less area than a 9 x 13 (100 against 117 square inches), so the layers come out deeper and risk running over unless the pans are a full 2 inches deep. Fill to two-thirds and bake any extra as cupcakes.
Why does an angel food cake go into an ungreased pan and cool upside down?
The batter climbs the bare walls as it rises; Utah's manual lists greased sides as a cause of a fallen foam cake. Inverting lets the soft crumb hang while it sets instead of collapsing; Utah lists a pan not inverted as a cause too.
Which needs the refrigerator: a cake with American buttercream of butter and powdered sugar, or one with cream cheese frosting?
The cream cheese one. FSIS excludes cakes with cream cheese frosting or cream fillings from its keep list; cakes with ordinary frosting stay on it. Refrigerating the buttercream cake keeps it longer.
A two-layer 8-inch cake gives 20 party servings by Wilton's chart. Does that mean it feeds 20 people?
It means 20 slices of about 1 1/2 by 2 inches. How many people that feeds depends on them; the chart is one maker's portion size.
(Go deeper) For a Swiss meringue buttercream, what temperature do the whites and sugar reach, and why?
160 °F, read with a thermometer, because FSIS says egg mixtures are safe once they reach 160 °F. Or use pasteurized whites.
The party starts at 2:00. Your cream cheese frosted cake is in the refrigerator. The cake will be cut at about 3:30, and the day is 85 °F. When does it come out?
That is two hours out before the first slice, with serving still to come. FSIS's limit is 2 hours out of refrigeration, so the cake reaches it as you cut.
It stays inside the 2-hour limit with time to serve. The day is under 90 °F, so the 1-hour limit does not apply; on a hotter day it would.
Three and a half hours out is past the 2-hour limit FSIS gives for perishable food. A cold cake cuts cleanly with a knife dipped in hot water.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.