Temperature in baking: room temperature butter, water for yeast, and doneness
Room temperature (softened) butter, eggs and water at the temperature the method needs, dough temperature set by a formula, and doneness read with a probe for bread, cakes and custards, with the federal egg line kept apart from the quality figures.
- Start here: the essentials
- The thermometer
- Ingredient temperatures
- Water for yeast
- Dough temperature
- Doneness by temperature, and the federal egg line
- Fahrenheit, Celsius and gas marks
- See it: a loaf in a cold kitchen
- Practice: one bake, its temperatures written down
- Your kitchen
- Check your work
- Knowledge check and scenario
Start here Essentials
For a first pass, get the butter to the right softness, the yeast water into the maker's range, and check one bake for doneness by more than the clock. Softened butter and a careful look at the finished bake are enough to start; a thermometer comes next.
- Take the butter out well ahead and press it before creaming. A finger should leave a dent while the butter still feels slightly cool (ingredient temperatures).
- If the recipe uses yeast, check the water with a thermometer against the range on the yeast package (water for yeast).
- Bake to the recipe's time, then check doneness by the test given for that bake (doneness).
- Write the temperature or the test on the bake log.
Minimum time: one ordinary bake, plus 10 minutes of checking and writing. Done when: one bake has its ingredient temperatures and its doneness check written on the bake log.
The thermometer Understand
Baking has three temperatures in it: the oven's, the ingredients', and the food's when it comes out. The oven and the pan covers the first with an oven thermometer. This chapter covers the other two, and for them the tool is an instant-read thermometer: a handheld probe with a thin metal stem that reads the temperature at its tip in a few seconds. It goes into butter, water, dough, a loaf, a cake or a custard.
A digital probe is the easiest to read. A dial thermometer works for water and dough, but reads more slowly. Either one is only as good as its last check.
Checking it
NIST, the federal measurement agency, gives the boiling-water check: at sea level, water boils at 100 °C (212 °F). Put the probe in a pot at a full boil, read it, and note the difference; that is the amount to adjust every reading by (NIST, Culinary Measurement Tips). Some digital thermometers can be reset to read true; the maker's instructions say how.
Boiling water is only 212 °F at sea level. Higher up it boils cooler, because there is less air pressure on it. Colorado State University Extension's figures (CSU Extension, High Elevation Food Preparation Guide): Physical principle
| Elevation | Water boils at |
|---|---|
| Sea level | 212 °F (100 °C) |
| 2,000 ft | 208 °F (98 °C) |
| 5,000 ft | 203 °F (95 °C) |
| 7,500 ft | 198 °F (92 °C) |
| 10,000 ft | 193 °F (89 °C) |
USDA's Food Safety and Inspection Service (FSIS) gives the rate as just under 1 °F for each 500 feet (FSIS, High Altitude Cooking). So at 5,000 ft, a thermometer that reads 203 °F in boiling water is reading true. Write the check, the reading and your elevation on the bake log.
Where to put the probe
- Bread and cake: the center of the thickest part, from the side or the top, without touching the pan. The Home Baking Association's chart says to probe breads and cakes only after oven spring has set, that is, once the bake has stopped rising and the top is firm (Home Baking Association, Baking Temperatures).
- A pan of rolls or muffins: one from the middle of the pan. King Arthur Baking found an edge roll at 192 °F while the center roll in the same pan read 171 °F (King Arthur Baking, Using a thermometer with yeast bread).
- Cheesecake: halfway down into the filling. King Arthur reads the center and a point about an inch from the edge (King Arthur Baking, How to keep cheesecake from cracking).
Ingredient temperatures
A recipe that says "softened butter" or "cold butter" is giving an instruction about temperature, and the method depends on it. In creaming, beating soft butter with sugar traps air that helps a cake or cookie rise; in pastry and biscuits, cold pieces of fat stay separate in the dough and melt in the oven, leaving flaky layers. The same butter at the wrong temperature does the other job, or neither. Cookies, muffins and biscuits and Pie and pastry apply this. Physical principle
| Ingredient and use | Figure | Who gives it |
|---|---|---|
| Butter for cutting in (pastry, biscuits) | 35 to 40 °F (2 to 4 °C) | Home Baking Association chart |
| Butter for creaming | 65 to 75 °F (18 to 24 °C) | Home Baking Association chart |
| Butter for creaming ("cool room temperature") | 68 to 70 °F (20 to 21 °C) | King Arthur Baking |
| Eggs at room temperature | 68 to 70 °F (20 to 21 °C) | King Arthur Baking |
Sources: Home Baking Association, Baking Temperatures (above); King Arthur Baking, Building a better butter cake; King Arthur Baking, eggs at room temperature.
Softened butter: the press test
The figures are practitioners' ranges, and they overlap rather than agree. What matters more than the number is the feel, and King Arthur gives the test: press the butter with a finger. It should take a dent and still feel slightly cool, with some resistance (King Arthur Baking, Creaming butter and sugar). King Arthur explains why both ends fail: cold butter takes too long to cream, and butter that is too soft traps less air (Building a better butter cake, above). Test it
How long it takes depends on the kitchen and the butter. King Arthur's preferred way to soften butter is to leave it on the counter for a few hours. In a warm kitchen it may be ready sooner; press it and see. If you have a thermometer, push the probe into the middle of the stick and compare it with the table. Write what you did on the bake log: "on the counter 2 hours, 67 °F, dented with some resistance."
Cold butter
For pie dough, biscuits and scones the butter stays cold, 35 to 40 °F by the Home Baking Association's figure, which is about refrigerator temperature. Cut it into pieces straight from the refrigerator and keep the dough cool while you work.
Eggs
King Arthur's test kitchen found that cold eggs added to creamed butter and sugar can make the batter curdle, and the cake suffers. If a recipe does not say, cold or room-temperature eggs are usually fine. To warm cold eggs quickly, King Arthur sets them in a bowl of hot, not boiling, tap water: about 70 °F in about 10 minutes (eggs at room temperature, above). Eggs, like other perishable food, should not sit out for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90 °F (FSIS, Danger Zone). One practitioner's finding
Two butter figures, compared
The Home Baking Association's chart gives 65 to 75 °F for creaming butter and prints its Celsius as 20 to 21 °C, which does not match: 65 to 75 °F is about 18 to 24 °C, and 20 to 21 °C matches King Arthur's 68 to 70 °F. The chart is compiled from several practitioners (Rose Levy Beranbaum, Cook's Illustrated, King Arthur, Stella Parks and a culinary text), so its wider range may be the span across them. Neither figure is a standard. Both say the same thing in practice: cool to the touch, soft enough to dent.
Water for yeast
Yeast is a living organism that feeds on sugars in the dough and gives off gas, which raises it. Warm water wakes it; water that is too hot harms it. The maker's figures are the default here, because they are written for the maker's own yeast. Fleischmann's gives these (Fleischmann's, Yeast 101): Product-specific
| Yeast | How it goes in | Liquid temperature (Fleischmann's) |
|---|---|---|
| Active dry | Dissolved in the liquid | 100 to 110 °F (38 to 43 °C) |
| Instant (RapidRise, Bread Machine) | Mixed with the dry ingredients, liquid added | 120 to 130 °F (49 to 54 °C) |
| Fresh (cake) yeast | Dissolved in tepid water | 70 to 90 °F (21 to 32 °C) |
The two dry yeasts have different ranges because of where they meet the water. Instant yeast mixed into the flour first is cushioned by it: the warm liquid cools as it meets the flour. Active dry yeast dissolved in water meets the water directly. Fleischmann's adds that RapidRise loses its fast-rising ability if it is dissolved first (Fleischmann's, FAQ). Your package's own figures win over this table if they differ.
Checking that the yeast is alive
Fleischmann's proof test: stir the yeast and 1 teaspoon of sugar into 1/4 cup of 100 to 110 °F water and wait 10 minutes. Live yeast foams; Fleischmann's says to the 1/2-cup mark. No foam means start again with fresh yeast. Leaveners covers yeast types and converting between them.
Cooler water is not wrong
The maker's figures are for its own methods, which aim for a quick rise. King Arthur's dough-temperature method, below, often calls for cooler water and accepts a slower rise. With instant yeast, King Arthur says cool water is fine because the yeast is stirred into the flour; with active dry, it dissolves the yeast in about 3 tablespoons of the recipe's water warmed to 110 °F and adds the rest cool (King Arthur Baking, Desired dough temperature). Both approaches stay inside the maker's limits where the yeast meets the water.
Yeast water figures, compared
Fleischmann's gives 100 to 110 °F for dissolving active dry. The Home Baking Association chart gives 105 to 115 °F, and King Arthur dissolves it at 110 °F. For instant yeast mixed with flour, Fleischmann's and the Home Baking Association agree on 120 to 130 °F. The chart also lists 85 to 100 °F for blooming instant yeast in water, which Fleischmann's does not recommend for RapidRise. We follow the maker of the yeast in your hand.
Dough temperature
A yeast dough rises at a speed set largely by its own temperature: warmer dough rises faster, cooler dough slower. Bakers who want the same loaf each week aim for the same dough temperature after mixing, whatever the season. The desired dough temperature (DDT) is that target. This is one practitioner's method, King Arthur Baking's; we found no university or agency source for it. One practitioner's method
King Arthur gives 75 to 78 °F (24 to 26 °C) as the ideal range for wheat yeast doughs (Desired dough temperature, above). Its test loaves show why: water at 50 °F gave a 72 °F dough and a sluggish first rise; water at 120 °F gave large bubbles and a wrinkled loaf with a gap under the crust; a dough at 75 °F gave the best rise and crumb.
The formula
You control one temperature directly: the water's. The others you measure. King Arthur's professional reference sets it out (King Arthur Baking, Dough Temperature):
- Multiply the desired dough temperature by 3 for a straight dough (by 4 if the recipe has a preferment, such as a starter). The result is the total.
- Subtract the flour temperature, the room temperature and the friction factor (and the preferment's temperature, if there is one).
- What is left is the water temperature.
King Arthur's worked example, for a straight dough with a desired temperature of 76 °F: 76 × 3 = 228; 228 − 72 (flour) − 74 (room) − 24 (friction) = 58 °F water.
The friction factor is the heat the mixing itself adds to the dough. King Arthur's figures for home mixing: 22 to 24 °F for a 7-quart stand mixer (stirred 3 minutes, then 4 minutes on speed 2), and 6 to 8 °F for mixing and kneading by hand for about 8 minutes (Desired dough temperature, above). Gentle folds or cool hands add 0 to 4 °F (King Arthur Baking, friction factor). Mixing time and speed change it.
Flour stored in the kitchen is usually at room temperature; read it with the probe to be sure. The dough temperature calculator does the arithmetic and remembers your friction factor. Yeast bread uses it at the mixing stage.
Measuring your own friction factor
King Arthur's reference works the formula backward from a trial dough: mix as usual, read the dough's temperature, multiply it by 3 (or 4), and subtract the flour, room and water temperatures (and preferment). What is left is your mixer's friction factor for that recipe. King Arthur's blog also gives a quicker adjustment: if the dough comes out 2 °F under the target, lower the friction factor by 2; if 1 °F over, raise it by 1. The full calculation moves the next water temperature further than the quick rule; repeat it over two or three loaves and keep the figure that settles. King Arthur notes that Jeffrey Hamelman's book Bread suggests 24 to 28 °F for most mixers, which are commercial ones.
Doneness by temperature, and the federal egg line
A bake is done when its inside has set: the starches have taken up water and firmed, the eggs have set, and enough water has left that the crumb holds its shape. A probe reads the inside. Color, smell and feel read the outside, which can be done before or after the middle. Both matter, and the publishers who give temperatures say so. Physical principle
Two kinds of number
The temperatures in this section are of two kinds, and they are kept apart on purpose.
- Quality figures. The temperatures at which practitioners find bread, cake and custard at their best. They come from bakers, test kitchens and a thermometer maker, they differ from one another, and they are not safety lines.
- The federal egg line. FSIS says egg dishes are safe once they reach 160 °F (71 °C), and to cook egg dishes to that temperature (FSIS, Shell Eggs from Farm to Table). This is a safety figure from the agency.
Quality figures by bake
For each bake, the default is one named publisher's figure, or the figure two publishers agree on; the full comparison is in Go deeper below and on the temperatures reference.
| Bake | Center temperature | Whose figure | Also check |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sandwich loaves and soft rolls | 190 °F (88 °C) | King Arthur's benchmark for most loaves and rolls | Crust color, a hollow sound |
| Lean crusty loaves (baguettes, hearth bread) | Crust color decides | King Arthur: a baguette's interior reached 212 °F at a medium golden brown | Color, crust firmness |
| Quick breads, muffins, biscuits | 200 to 205 °F (93 to 96 °C) | ThermoWorks and the Home Baking Association agree | Top springs back, color |
| Cakes and cupcakes | 200 to 209 °F (93 to 98 °C) | ThermoWorks | Top springs back, edges pull from the pan |
| Chocolate chip cookies | 180 °F (82 °C) | ThermoWorks | Edges set, color |
| Custard and pumpkin pie | 170 to 175 °F (77 to 79 °C) | ThermoWorks and the Home Baking Association agree | Center still jiggles slightly |
| Cheesecake | 150 °F (66 °C) in the center | ThermoWorks; King Arthur gives at least 150 °F center, at most 175 °F near the edge | Edge firm, center just set |
Sources: ThermoWorks, Doneness Temperatures for Baked Goods; Home Baking Association, Baking Temperatures; King Arthur Baking, Using a thermometer with yeast bread; King Arthur Baking, How to keep cheesecake from cracking.
Temperature is half the test
King Arthur's own doneness guide calls temperature a secondary check: the center of a loaf can reach its finished temperature several minutes before the bake is done, and smell, color, feel and sound decide (King Arthur Baking, How to tell if bread is done). America's Test Kitchen found the same: rustic Italian loaves passed 200 °F halfway through the bake, and a loaf pulled at 210 °F, 15 minutes early, had a pale crust and a gummy inside (America's Test Kitchen, Testing Bread for Doneness). So read the temperature, then look. If the color and the number disagree, bake a few minutes more and read again. Test it
Without a thermometer, use the "also check" column. America's Test Kitchen's quick-bread class names internal temperature as the most accurate test and a toothpick as the fallback: push a toothpick into the center of a quick bread or cake; wet batter on it means the center has not set. One practitioner's method
The boiling point is a ceiling
A moist crumb cannot get much hotter than the boiling point of water, because the water in it boils away instead. King Arthur notes a baguette's interior cannot rise above 212 °F (Using a thermometer, above). At altitude the ceiling drops: at 5,000 ft water boils at about 203 °F (CSU, above), so a moist crumb there tops out near 203 °F, short of a 205 or 210 °F target. Above about 3,000 ft, cap any target at your local boiling point and lean on color and the other checks. When a bake goes wrong covers baking at altitude. Physical principle
Custard, cheesecake and the 160 °F line
Here the two kinds of number meet. The practitioners' figure for custard and pumpkin pie, 170 to 175 °F, is above the federal 160 °F. Their figure for cheesecake, 150 °F in the center, is below it. King Arthur gives 160 to 170 °F for the center of a pumpkin pie (King Arthur Baking, How to tell when pumpkin pie is done).
Doneness temperatures for cakes and breads are practitioners' quality figures, not safety lines. For egg dishes, custards and cheesecake, the agency figure is FSIS's 160 °F. We do not say that a custard or cheesecake taken out below 160 °F is safe. We report what the agency says, 160 °F for egg dishes, and what practitioners do, 150 °F for a cheesecake center, and the choice between them is yours. If you bake for someone at higher risk from foodborne illness, their clinician is the person to ask. Ask the authority
Custard, pumpkin and cheesecake fillings are perishable once baked. Cool them, then refrigerate. FSIS says not to leave perishable food out for more than 2 hours, or 1 hour above 90 °F (Danger Zone, above). FoodSafety.gov's chart gives pumpkin and pecan pie 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator, and custard and chiffon pies 3 to 4 days, not to be frozen (FoodSafety.gov, Cold Food Storage Chart). The refrigerator should be at 40 °F (4 °C) or below. Baking ahead covers which bakes need the refrigerator.
The doneness charts, compared
| Bake | King Arthur | ThermoWorks | Home Baking Association | Kansas State (2017) | America's Test Kitchen |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lean yeast bread | 190 °F for most loaves; baguettes by color | 190 to 210 °F | 190 to 210 °F | 195 to 210 °F | 195 to 210 °F |
| Rich yeast bread | 190 °F | 180 to 190 °F | 180 to 190 °F | rolls 190 to 195 °F | no figure |
| Quick bread, muffins | no figure | 200 to 205 °F | 200 to 205 °F | 210 °F | no figure |
| Butter and layer cakes | no figure | 200 to 209 °F | 190 to 205 °F | 205 to 210 °F | no figure |
| Pound cake | no figure | 210 °F | 190 to 205 °F | 210 °F | no figure |
| Custard, pumpkin pie | 160 to 170 °F | 170 to 175 °F | 170 to 175 °F | no figure | no figure |
| Cheesecake | at least 150 °F center | 150 °F | 145 to 150 °F | no figure | no figure |
Sources as above, plus Kansas State University Research and Extension, When are Baked Goods Done? (a Word document, April 2017). Kansas State's Bundt cake figure, 212 °F, is the sea-level boiling point itself. King Arthur's side-by-side loaves favored 190 °F over 205 °F for sandwich bread: moister, softer and staying fresher. Gluten-free yeast breads run about 5 °F higher by ThermoWorks' and the Home Baking Association's notes.
Carryover in custards
A custard keeps cooking after it leaves the oven, as heat from the hot edges moves into the center. King Arthur takes a 9-inch pumpkin pie out with a jiggly center about 4 inches across and the edges set and matte about 2 inches in from the rim, and lets the carryover finish it. It begins checking 10 minutes before the recipe's time, and warns that above 175 °F the edges can dry and crack (How to tell when pumpkin pie is done, above).
Fahrenheit, Celsius and gas marks
US recipes use Fahrenheit; most others use Celsius; older British recipes use gas marks. NIST gives the exact conversions (NIST, SI Units: Temperature): Convention
- °C = (°F − 32) ÷ 1.8
- °F = (°C × 1.8) + 32
Oven temperatures in recipes are rounded: 350 °F is 176.7 °C exactly, and recipes write 180 °C or 175 °C. That rounding is smaller than most ovens' error.
A gas mark is a numbered setting from older British gas ovens. Which?, the UK consumer association, gives this table, with fan (convection) settings 20 °C below conventional (Which?, Oven temperature conversion):
| Gas mark | °F | °C | °C fan | Which? calls it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 275 | 140 | 120 | cool |
| 2 | 300 | 150 | 130 | cool |
| 3 | 325 | 160 | 140 | moderate |
| 4 | 350 | 180 | 160 | moderate |
| 5 | 375 | 190 | 170 | moderately hot |
| 6 | 400 | 200 | 180 | moderately hot |
| 7 | 425 | 220 | 200 | hot |
| 8 | 450 | 230 | 210 | hot |
| 9 | 475 | 240 | 220 | very hot |
The oven converter converts between all three and applies your oven's offset. A "fan" temperature in a UK recipe already includes a convection reduction; The oven and the pan covers how your own oven converts.
See it: a loaf in a cold kitchen See it
Marcus Bell is fictional, and every fact about him here is invented for this manual. He bakes a sandwich loaf every week in a kitchen that sits at 64 °F (18 °C) in winter. He has a stand mixer, a scale and an instant-read thermometer. His loaves come out dense, and the tops tear.
He keeps his flour in the kitchen and reads it with the probe: 64 °F, the same as the room. He wants a dough at 76 °F (24 °C), inside King Arthur's 75 to 78 °F range. For his stand mixer he uses King Arthur's friction figure, 22 to 24 °F.
Known: 76 × 3 = 228. 228 − 64 (flour) − 64 (room) − 22 to 24 (friction) = 76 to 78 °F water. He uses 78 °F water, and the dough reads 77 °F (25 °C) after mixing, one degree over his target and inside the range. Working King Arthur's formula backward, his mixer's friction factor for this dough is 77 × 3 − 64 − 64 − 78 = 25 °F, a little above King Arthur's home figure. He writes the water, the dough temperature and the friction factor on the bread log. At the end of the bake he reads the center of the loaf: 190 °F (88 °C), King Arthur's benchmark for a sandwich loaf, with an even brown crust.
Assumed (Marcus's assumption): that the friction factor of 25 °F will hold for the same recipe, the same mixing time and the same speed. Under that assumption, next week's water is 228 − 64 − 64 − 25 = 75 °F.
Open: whether a cold dough caused his dense loaves. Earlier loaves were mixed with cool tap water; a dough well below the range rises slowly, as King Arthur's 50 °F test showed, and a slow rise judged by the clock can go into the oven underproofed. That is a reasonable thing to test, not a settled cause. The torn tops have other possible causes, in shaping and scoring, which Yeast bread covers. His next loaf, with one change logged, settles part of it.
Dana Reyes (fictional) has no thermometer yet. She bakes banana bread to the recipe's time and pushes a toothpick into the center: it comes out with wet batter, though the top is dark brown. Known: the center is not set. Her oven runs 20 °F hot by her oven check (The oven and the pan). Assumed (Dana's assumption): that the top browned early because of the hot oven. Open: whether lowering the dial to correct for the offset lets the center set before the top darkens; her next loaf settles it. Next time she will set the dial by her offset and change nothing else, so the loaf tests one thing. She writes "toothpick wet at 60 minutes, top dark" on the bake log.
- King Arthur Baking, Desired dough temperature: the method for home bakers, with test loaves at three water temperatures.
- King Arthur Baking, Using a thermometer with yeast bread: side-by-side loaves at different finishing temperatures.
- ThermoWorks, Doneness Temperatures for Baked Goods: a thermometer maker's chart for breads, cakes and custards.
- FSIS, Shell Eggs from Farm to Table: the federal 160 °F line and the egg storage times.
Practice: one bake, its temperatures written down Practice
Minimum: one bake with the butter pressed before creaming and the doneness checked by the test for that bake, both written on the bake log. No thermometer is needed for the minimum. Time: one ordinary bake, plus about 10 minutes of checking and writing; 10 minutes more for the boiling-water check. Materials: a recipe you bake, butter, an instant-read thermometer if you have one, a toothpick, a pot of water if you check the thermometer, and the bake log.
- If you have a thermometer, check it in boiling water and write the reading and your elevation.
- Take the butter out ahead and press it before creaming. Write how long it sat and how it felt, and its temperature if you read it.
- For a yeast recipe, read the water and compare it with the package's range, or work out the water with the dough temperature calculator.
- Bake to the low end of the recipe's time, then check doneness: the probe in the center, or the toothpick, plus the color.
- Write the reading or the test result, and whether you baked longer.
Measure your mixer's friction factor. Mix a yeast dough, read the flour, room, water and dough temperatures, and work the formula backward. Repeat on two more loaves and keep the figure that settles.
Read a loaf twice. Read a sandwich loaf when the crust first looks done and again five minutes later, and compare the crumb of two loaves taken out at different points.
Read a custard's carryover. Read a pumpkin pie's center as it comes out and again 15 minutes later on the rack.
Your kitchen Your kitchen
Check your work Check your work
Criteria
- Does the bake log say how the butter was softened and how it felt, or its temperature?
- For a yeast recipe, is the water temperature written, inside the maker's range or worked out from a desired dough temperature?
- Was doneness checked by a test for that bake, not by the clock alone, and is the result written down?
- If you used a thermometer, was it checked, and was the reading taken in the center?
- For a custard or cheesecake, do you know the federal 160 °F line and the figure you baked to, and was it refrigerated after cooling?
- At altitude, is your doneness target at or below your local boiling point?
Worked example
Marcus's bread log meets the yeast and doneness criteria: flour, room, water and dough temperatures are written, the dough came out inside King Arthur's range, and the loaf read 190 °F at the center with an even crust. His thermometer check is missing; a boiling-water reading would complete it. His friction factor rests on one loaf, and his assumption that it holds is reasonable under the same mixing; two more loaves settle it. Dana's entry meets the doneness criterion without a thermometer: she checked the center, found it wet, and wrote it down with the color.
Common mistakes
- Butter softened in the microwave until shiny. Too soft traps less air. Press it: it should dent and still feel cool.
- Hot tap water for yeast, unmeasured. Read it. Above the maker's range harms the yeast.
- Dissolving instant yeast in hot water. Fleischmann's says RapidRise loses its fast rise that way. Mix it with the flour.
- Taking a loaf out on temperature alone. The center can read done before the crust is. Look as well.
- Probing too early. The Home Baking Association's chart says to probe breads and cakes only after oven spring has set. Wait until the top is firm.
- Treating a quality figure as a safety line. 190 °F for bread is about texture. For egg dishes the agency's figure is 160 °F.
- Leaving a pumpkin pie on the counter overnight. FSIS's two-hour limit applies.
What is still unresolved
This chapter cannot tell you whether a cheesecake at 150 °F is safe enough for the people you bake for; the agency's figure is 160 °F, and anyone at higher risk should ask their clinician. It cannot give a university source for desired dough temperature; the method is King Arthur's. It does not say what each temperature does to a method in detail; Cookies, muffins and biscuits, Cakes and frosting and Yeast bread apply it. Altitude adjustments to recipes are in When a bake goes wrong.