Before you bake today: five checks
Five checks before the oven goes on: the oven's real heat, the flour's real amount, the ingredients' temperature, the pan the recipe means and the earliest time to look. Each links the chapter with the reasons.
Most failed bakes trace back to the amount, the heat or the order of mixing, and a recipe hides all three. These five checks take a few minutes before the oven goes on. Each one is the short version of a chapter, linked for when you want the reasons. If a bake has already gone wrong, start at the symptoms page instead.
The five checks
- Know the oven's real heat. Preheat fully: GE gives 5 to 10 minutes for an oven with a visible bake element and 15 to 20 for a hidden element or gas. If you have checked the oven with a thermometer, set the dial by its offset: an oven that runs 20 °F hot gets a dial 20 degrees lower. If you have not, check the first sheet or pan early. Checking your oven has the 30-minute check and the maker's bake test.
- Get the flour right. With a scale: set the bowl on it, press tare and weigh. Without one: stir the flour, spoon it into the cup, and level it with a straight edge; never scoop with the cup and never pack it. King Arthur Baking says a packed cup of all-purpose flour can hold up to 160 g against about 120 g spooned and leveled. How much flour is in the cup explains, and the ingredient weights give the grams.
- Set the ingredients' temperature. For creaming, butter soft enough to dent with a finger but still holding its shape, 65 to 75 °F by the Home Baking Association's chart; for pie crust, biscuits and scones, fat straight from the refrigerator. Water for yeast at the temperature the yeast maker gives. Ingredient temperatures has the figures and who publishes them.
- Use the pan the recipe means. Measure across the inside top edge. A 9-inch round holds about a quarter more than an 8-inch, so a swap changes depth and time. If your pan differs, the pan scaler says by how much; dark, nonstick and glass pans bake hotter, as Pans explains.
- Look at the earliest time. Set a timer for the low end of the recipe's range, or a few minutes before it in an oven you have not checked, and test then: a toothpick or a light press for cakes and quick breads, edges and color for cookies, an instant-read thermometer in the center of a loaf. Doneness lists the tests and temperatures.
Done when: the oven is at its real temperature, the flour is weighed or spooned, the fat is at the method's temperature, the pan is the recipe's or scaled for, and a timer is set for the first check.
After the bake
Write one line in the bake log: what you made, the oven setting, the time, how you checked doneness and what you saw. If something went wrong, write the cause you suspect and the one thing you will change. One change at a time explains why one.
Dana Reyes, a fictional first-time baker with cups, a light sheet pan and an electric oven, ran these checks before her chocolate chip cookies. She had no oven thermometer, so she baked one test tray of four cookies and looked at the earliest time; the bottoms were already dark. Her oven later read 20 °F hot. She spooned and leveled the flour instead of scooping, and the second tray spread less. Known: the oven offset and how she measured. Open: whether the softer butter she used also played a part, which her next tray, with firmer butter and nothing else changed, will settle.
These checks remove the most common causes of a failed bake; they do not guarantee a result. Recipes, flours, ovens and kitchens vary. If you live above 3,000 feet, add a sixth check: the altitude adjustments. Do not taste raw dough or batter at any point; flour is a raw food.